This article is from the source 'independent' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/facility-to-breed-dogs-for-experiments-is-given-the-goahead-after-government-intervenes-in-planning-dispute-10394223.html
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Facility given the go-ahead to breed beagles for experiments after Government intervenes in planning dispute | |
| (about 1 hour later) | |
| A facility will breed beagles for laboratory experiments after being given the go-ahead when Communities Secretary Greg Clark intervened in a local planning dispute. | |
| The proposal to create a facility housing 200 beagles and 180 puppies, along with ferrets, in Grimston, East Yorkshire, had previously been turned down twice following opposition from local residents and anti-vivisection campaigners. | The proposal to create a facility housing 200 beagles and 180 puppies, along with ferrets, in Grimston, East Yorkshire, had previously been turned down twice following opposition from local residents and anti-vivisection campaigners. |
| Local Government and Communities secretary Greg Clark however exercised his legal right to step in to back an appeal from Bantin & Kingman Ltd (B&K Ltd). | Local Government and Communities secretary Greg Clark however exercised his legal right to step in to back an appeal from Bantin & Kingman Ltd (B&K Ltd). |
| Animal rights campaigners have condemned the decision which now paves the way for the facility. | Animal rights campaigners have condemned the decision which now paves the way for the facility. |
| No breeding currently takes place at the site, where dogs are taken to be prepared for experiments. | No breeding currently takes place at the site, where dogs are taken to be prepared for experiments. |
| Cruelty Free International said it had successfully campaigned in recent years against two previous applications to build the breeding facility. East Riding Council had rejected the proposal on each occasion. | Cruelty Free International said it had successfully campaigned in recent years against two previous applications to build the breeding facility. East Riding Council had rejected the proposal on each occasion. |
| Former Communities and Local Government Secretary Eric Pickles upheld the second rejection in 2012, but agreed to look at it again after the application was amended. | Former Communities and Local Government Secretary Eric Pickles upheld the second rejection in 2012, but agreed to look at it again after the application was amended. |
| Following the general election and the appointment of David Cameron's new cabinet, the final decision fell to Mr Clark. | Following the general election and the appointment of David Cameron's new cabinet, the final decision fell to Mr Clark. |
| Michelle Thew, chief executive of Cruelty Free International, said the organisation was “deeply disappointed” by the decision. | Michelle Thew, chief executive of Cruelty Free International, said the organisation was “deeply disappointed” by the decision. |
| She said: “The planning application to expand this .. facility has been an issue of strong public concern as is using dogs in research. This is a sad day for animals and, as a result, thousands of dogs will now be bred at Bantin & Kingman and be supplied to laboratories across Europe to suffer and die in experiments.” | She said: “The planning application to expand this .. facility has been an issue of strong public concern as is using dogs in research. This is a sad day for animals and, as a result, thousands of dogs will now be bred at Bantin & Kingman and be supplied to laboratories across Europe to suffer and die in experiments.” |
| Nick Palmer, Cruelty Free International's director of policy, has said the organisation was taking legal advice. | Nick Palmer, Cruelty Free International's director of policy, has said the organisation was taking legal advice. |
| The move can still legally be challenged in the High Court. | The move can still legally be challenged in the High Court. |
| According to the Press Association, the decision is understood to hinge on a letter from the Home Office advising the dogs might be at risk of infection if kept outside. | According to the Press Association, the decision is understood to hinge on a letter from the Home Office advising the dogs might be at risk of infection if kept outside. |
| Penning beagles outside would not be acceptable on planning grounds due to noise nuisance to residents. | Penning beagles outside would not be acceptable on planning grounds due to noise nuisance to residents. |
| “We've yet to see the Home Office letter,” said Mr Palmer. “The logic of the Home Office position is that nobody should ever let their dogs out because they might catch a bug.” | “We've yet to see the Home Office letter,” said Mr Palmer. “The logic of the Home Office position is that nobody should ever let their dogs out because they might catch a bug.” |
| The planning application was made under the name of Yorkshire Evergreen, whose registered address is the same as that of the beagle facility owned by B&K Universal. | The planning application was made under the name of Yorkshire Evergreen, whose registered address is the same as that of the beagle facility owned by B&K Universal. |
| Initial plans were for a facility where 2,000 beagles and ferrets could be bred at a time for animal experiments. | Initial plans were for a facility where 2,000 beagles and ferrets could be bred at a time for animal experiments. |
| The November 2013 application was rejected by the East Riding of Yorkshire Council. | The November 2013 application was rejected by the East Riding of Yorkshire Council. |
| B&K belongs to American company Marshall BioResources, which operates sites around the world breeding and selling animals for use in laboratories. | B&K belongs to American company Marshall BioResources, which operates sites around the world breeding and selling animals for use in laboratories. |
| Wendy Jarrett, chief executive of Understanding Animal Research, whose members include companies, universities, charities and societies involved in animal testing said: "We welcome this decision. | Wendy Jarrett, chief executive of Understanding Animal Research, whose members include companies, universities, charities and societies involved in animal testing said: "We welcome this decision. |
| "As the European Commission reported earlier this month, we are not yet at the stage where animal research can be completely replaced by non-animal methods, and if we want to see more desperately-needed new therapies for cancer, Alzheimer's, cystic fibrosis, motor neurone disease and the rest of the long list of conditions that are currently incurable, then animal research will be a necessary part of the drug discovery and development process. | "As the European Commission reported earlier this month, we are not yet at the stage where animal research can be completely replaced by non-animal methods, and if we want to see more desperately-needed new therapies for cancer, Alzheimer's, cystic fibrosis, motor neurone disease and the rest of the long list of conditions that are currently incurable, then animal research will be a necessary part of the drug discovery and development process. |
| "Relatively few dogs are used in research in the UK, and their use has to be approved by ethical review boards. | "Relatively few dogs are used in research in the UK, and their use has to be approved by ethical review boards. |
| "By law, scientists also have to prove that they could not get the same results from non-animal alternatives, or from another species of animal. | "By law, scientists also have to prove that they could not get the same results from non-animal alternatives, or from another species of animal. |
| "Given that we will continue to need to use dogs in research for the foreseeable future, we believe it is in everyone's interests that those dogs are bred in the UK and housed in buildings that are designed for their optimum welfare." | "Given that we will continue to need to use dogs in research for the foreseeable future, we believe it is in everyone's interests that those dogs are bred in the UK and housed in buildings that are designed for their optimum welfare." |
| A Department for Communities & Local Government spokesperson said: "Ministers are required to assess the application’s conformity with legislation and national and local planning policy, and granted it permission solely on planning grounds." | A Department for Communities & Local Government spokesperson said: "Ministers are required to assess the application’s conformity with legislation and national and local planning policy, and granted it permission solely on planning grounds." |
| The Independent has approached B&K Ltd for comment. | The Independent has approached B&K Ltd for comment. |
| Additional reporting by PA | Additional reporting by PA |