This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/live/2015/jun/16/bronwyn-bishop-suggests-gillian-triggs-resign-and-run-for-office-politics-live

The article has changed 23 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 21 Version 22
Coalition gains support of Greens for changes to pension assets test – politics live Coalition gains support of Greens for changes to pension assets test – politics live
(25 days later)
10.44am BST10.44am BST
10:4410:44
Good night and good luckGood night and good luck
Well, that’s it my friends – all I can manage for Tuesday. Thank you dear readers, hate readers, neutral readers, curious readers – take a bow.Well, that’s it my friends – all I can manage for Tuesday. Thank you dear readers, hate readers, neutral readers, curious readers – take a bow.
Let’s try and work out what happened today.Let’s try and work out what happened today.
Pensions:Pensions:
Boats:Boats:
Citizenship:Citizenship:
There was more, but there’s your main points.There was more, but there’s your main points.
Enjoy the Killing Season if that’s your pleasure. See you in the morning.Enjoy the Killing Season if that’s your pleasure. See you in the morning.
10.08am BST10.08am BST
10:0810:08
To be fair to the Greens, given the government has ridiculously ruled out any changes to super tax concessions (despite clear arguments in the tax review and elsewhere for change) – it would have been impossible to budge the government anyway.To be fair to the Greens, given the government has ridiculously ruled out any changes to super tax concessions (despite clear arguments in the tax review and elsewhere for change) – it would have been impossible to budge the government anyway.
9.50am BST9.50am BST
09:5009:50
Interesting that was nailed down so quickly. The government is making it clear it doesn’t intend to give any ground on retirement incomes – apart from a few more weeks consulting. The Greens must have wanted to do this to agree to changing the assets test with such limited scope to achieve anything substantial on retirement incomes.Interesting that was nailed down so quickly. The government is making it clear it doesn’t intend to give any ground on retirement incomes – apart from a few more weeks consulting. The Greens must have wanted to do this to agree to changing the assets test with such limited scope to achieve anything substantial on retirement incomes.
Hockey’s statement tonight:Hockey’s statement tonight:
The government’s objectives for our retirement income system are to ensure stability and certainty, while optimising retirement incomes, ensuring fiscal sustainability and equity and encouraging self-provision for retirement.The government’s objectives for our retirement income system are to ensure stability and certainty, while optimising retirement incomes, ensuring fiscal sustainability and equity and encouraging self-provision for retirement.
This is why the government has given clear commitments that there will be no unexpected, adverse changes to superannuation in this term of government nor do we have any plans for such changes beyond the next election.This is why the government has given clear commitments that there will be no unexpected, adverse changes to superannuation in this term of government nor do we have any plans for such changes beyond the next election.
Specifically, the government will not increase taxes on superannuation and will not remove any current flexibility in accessing superannuation in retirement.Specifically, the government will not increase taxes on superannuation and will not remove any current flexibility in accessing superannuation in retirement.
9.43am BST9.43am BST
09:4309:43
Ah yes, here's the deal. Pension peace in our timeAh yes, here's the deal. Pension peace in our time
A statement from the Greens leader Richard Di Natale, confirming his party has said yes to changes to the pension assets test.A statement from the Greens leader Richard Di Natale, confirming his party has said yes to changes to the pension assets test.
When I took on the leadership of the Greens I said I was here to get positive outcomes for the community wherever I could, so I’m pleased to be able to deliver on this. The government has agreed to give special consideration to retirement incomes in its Tax White Paper, which means we can finally look at superannuation as part of the equation.When I took on the leadership of the Greens I said I was here to get positive outcomes for the community wherever I could, so I’m pleased to be able to deliver on this. The government has agreed to give special consideration to retirement incomes in its Tax White Paper, which means we can finally look at superannuation as part of the equation.
9.38am BST9.38am BST
09:3809:38
Let's talk about retirement incomes provided we don't have to do anythingLet's talk about retirement incomes provided we don't have to do anything
Interesting statement just issued by the treasurer, Joe Hockey, about extending the consultation period for the tax white paper.Interesting statement just issued by the treasurer, Joe Hockey, about extending the consultation period for the tax white paper.
As a result of the strong public response to the tax white paper, stakeholder interest in the retirement incomes component of this review and discussions with the Senate, the government has decided to extend the submission period by six weeks and initiate an additional stakeholder engagement process.As a result of the strong public response to the tax white paper, stakeholder interest in the retirement incomes component of this review and discussions with the Senate, the government has decided to extend the submission period by six weeks and initiate an additional stakeholder engagement process.
The extension allows more time for interested parties to put their views into the tax white paper process in relation to key interactions between the age pension, superannuation, taxation and employment, consistent with the government’s objective of ensuring stability and the commitments we have made to the Australian people.The extension allows more time for interested parties to put their views into the tax white paper process in relation to key interactions between the age pension, superannuation, taxation and employment, consistent with the government’s objective of ensuring stability and the commitments we have made to the Australian people.
This will facilitate more detailed consideration of the interactions between the tax system and the transfer system, including the sustainability of Australia’s retirement income arrangements.This will facilitate more detailed consideration of the interactions between the tax system and the transfer system, including the sustainability of Australia’s retirement income arrangements.
This sounds a whole lot like a large olive branch to the Greens. Labor today said it would vote against pension changes outlined in the budget. The Greens have expressed an interest but want a review of retirement incomes, including super concessions. Hockey’s statement makes it clear consulting about this issue doesn’t mean doing anything – but it’s a gesture nonetheless.This sounds a whole lot like a large olive branch to the Greens. Labor today said it would vote against pension changes outlined in the budget. The Greens have expressed an interest but want a review of retirement incomes, including super concessions. Hockey’s statement makes it clear consulting about this issue doesn’t mean doing anything – but it’s a gesture nonetheless.
UpdatedUpdated
at 9.45am BSTat 9.45am BST
9.30am BST9.30am BST
09:3009:30
I thought I’d share the trust in professions list because there’s a fury typhoon down in the thread about Labor stepping back from scrutiny of the boats issue, and about the failure of journalism. All journalism. Ever.I thought I’d share the trust in professions list because there’s a fury typhoon down in the thread about Labor stepping back from scrutiny of the boats issue, and about the failure of journalism. All journalism. Ever.
In terms of Labor, I’ve argued yesterday and today that the opposition should pursue this story, in the parliament, because that’s the forum where misleading can’t happen (as opposed to stonewalling and evasion, which happens routinely, sadly). There is no reason not to pursue this story if their account today was true: if no Labor government authorised payments to people smugglers (criminals) to transport asylum seekers (an unlawful activity). This alleged activity is quite different to other forms of disruption by law enforcement or spooks – paying for intelligence, or preventing a crime.In terms of Labor, I’ve argued yesterday and today that the opposition should pursue this story, in the parliament, because that’s the forum where misleading can’t happen (as opposed to stonewalling and evasion, which happens routinely, sadly). There is no reason not to pursue this story if their account today was true: if no Labor government authorised payments to people smugglers (criminals) to transport asylum seekers (an unlawful activity). This alleged activity is quite different to other forms of disruption by law enforcement or spooks – paying for intelligence, or preventing a crime.
As for journalism, well, it can only keep pursuing the issue. We can keep asking questions. That’s what we do.As for journalism, well, it can only keep pursuing the issue. We can keep asking questions. That’s what we do.
9.18am BST9.18am BST
09:1809:18
Because it’s mildly fun, back to Essential. Journalists – less trustworthy than bankers – more trustworthy than real estate agents. Politicians – less trustworthy than all of the above.Because it’s mildly fun, back to Essential. Journalists – less trustworthy than bankers – more trustworthy than real estate agents. Politicians – less trustworthy than all of the above.
Q. In general, how much trust do you have in the following professions?Q. In general, how much trust do you have in the following professions?
9.07am BST9.07am BST
09:0709:07
Apart from the new video that has emerged this afternoon, Fairfax Media’s Indonesia correspondent Jewel Topsfield, who is doing an outstanding job on the ground with this payments for people smugglers story, has been shown the money. Yes, that’s a saying in our business, but in this case, it’s a literal statement.Apart from the new video that has emerged this afternoon, Fairfax Media’s Indonesia correspondent Jewel Topsfield, who is doing an outstanding job on the ground with this payments for people smugglers story, has been shown the money. Yes, that’s a saying in our business, but in this case, it’s a literal statement.
Take it away, Jewel.Take it away, Jewel.
Photographs of thousands of US dollars handed to six people smugglers have been provided to Fairfax Media, which Indonesian police say is proof of bribery by Australian officials.Photographs of thousands of US dollars handed to six people smugglers have been provided to Fairfax Media, which Indonesian police say is proof of bribery by Australian officials.
“We have given you the evidence,” says General Endang Sunjaya, the police chief of Nusa Tenggara Timur province.“We have given you the evidence,” says General Endang Sunjaya, the police chief of Nusa Tenggara Timur province.
“It’s now up to you and other organisations to demand an answer from the Australian government.”“It’s now up to you and other organisations to demand an answer from the Australian government.”
UpdatedUpdated
at 9.07am BSTat 9.07am BST
8.54am BST8.54am BST
08:5408:54
The Essential poll is out and about this evening. The Essential two party preferred number is much like everyone else’s – Labor 52%, Coalition 48%.The Essential poll is out and about this evening. The Essential two party preferred number is much like everyone else’s – Labor 52%, Coalition 48%.
There are a couple of questions on housing affordability. Basically we are all worried about whether we can afford to buy a house.There are a couple of questions on housing affordability. Basically we are all worried about whether we can afford to buy a house.
8.42am BST8.42am BST
08:4208:42
Reverse the trouser.Reverse the trouser.
Happy to withdraw trouser comment in QT today re @billshortenmp - was genuinely oblivious to alt meanings - but he will trouser your superHappy to withdraw trouser comment in QT today re @billshortenmp - was genuinely oblivious to alt meanings - but he will trouser your super
I wasn’t game to raise the full scope of trouser bandit meanings with the social services minister, Scott Morrison. Others obviously have.I wasn’t game to raise the full scope of trouser bandit meanings with the social services minister, Scott Morrison. Others obviously have.
8.17am BST8.17am BST
08:1708:17
More Senate business.More Senate business.
The red room has also agreed to conduct an inquiry into the handling of the Man Monis letter. (This is the one the Sydney siege gunman sent to the attorney-general George Brandis – which the government said initially was passed on to the joint NSW/federal inquiry, then later clarified was not passed on to the joint NSW/federal inquiry.)The red room has also agreed to conduct an inquiry into the handling of the Man Monis letter. (This is the one the Sydney siege gunman sent to the attorney-general George Brandis – which the government said initially was passed on to the joint NSW/federal inquiry, then later clarified was not passed on to the joint NSW/federal inquiry.)
8.03am BST8.03am BST
08:0308:03
Senate business.Senate business.
The red room has passed the Greens order to produce documents (we flagged this yesterday) – which in theory compels the government to reveal whether taxpayer funds were used to pay people smugglers to transport asylum seekers to Indonesia. The government has 24 hours to comply.The red room has passed the Greens order to produce documents (we flagged this yesterday) – which in theory compels the government to reveal whether taxpayer funds were used to pay people smugglers to transport asylum seekers to Indonesia. The government has 24 hours to comply.
The government won’t comply. The Senate will then have to think about its response.The government won’t comply. The Senate will then have to think about its response.
7.53am BST
07:53
More on boats and payments. This video from Reuters includes an on camera account from an asylum seeker about the reported payments.
7.44am BST
07:44
To say I am not amused would be an understatement
My colleague Lenore Taylor has been speaking to Bret Walker after the eyebrow raising question time effort that I’ve covered in the last few posts.
Take it away Bret:
I am impatient with and I condemn those who persist in reading pages of my report as if they say the government can exercise ministerial discretion after dispensing with a criminal trial. I said the minister should have discretion over the revocation of citizenship after a criminal trial ... and it reflects very poorly that those quoting me can’t read beyond the few lines they are citing.
I assume they have been given speaking notes to that effect, but my report does not provide a justification for what they intend to do … it is not what I said, nor what I think now, and anyone who claims otherwise is wrong. In fact I am saying the opposite. I doubt many of those citing my report have read beyond the one paragraph they refer to and that does not bode well for mature consideration or lawmaking.
To say I am not amused would be an understatement.
Updated
at 7.44am BST
7.38am BST
07:38
Just because he’s not finished, Malcolm Turnbull notes in the interview he’s still interested in media reform – reform of media ownership. He’d like to see Sky News on free to air television.
Where everyone can see it.
What time is it in New York? Probably doesn’t matter. New York never sleeps.
7.35am BST
07:35
Access to the courts an important principle? Of course it is.
The communications minister Malcolm Turnbull, meanwhile, is helping out again on Sky News. Turnbull at the moment is explaining the separation of powers to Sky political editor David Speers. It’s quite useful to reflect on these principles when we are celebrating the 800th anniversary of the Magna Carta, Turnbull notes.
He says it is very important to protect the national security of Australia. Very important. He also notes we all have to comply with the constitution. He notes that the government is still drafting the citizenship legislation, still taking legal advice.
Is access to the courts an important principle, Speers wonders?
Turnbull:
Access to the courts – of course it is.
7.21am BST
07:21
Boats, Bret and trousers
Because it’s been scrappy, I think we should take stock briefly before adjusting the dials for the early evening.
A few observations.
6.51am BST
06:51
Also delightful.
Rise, oh Messiah.
6.33am BST
06:33
Mikearoo had some transmission issues in question time. Pictures flowing in now, including this lovely frame of the foreign minister. I’ll share more shortly.
6.20am BST
06:20
A small debate about impartiality
Question time has ended. Former speaker Anna Burke has a question for Madam Speaker. Burke wants to know how it is that Madam Speaker can speak of issues in the media that will come before her in the Speaker’s chair. I’m not sure precisely what Burke means, but perhaps she means Madam Speaker’s comments last night on Q&A on the government’s citizenship revocation proposal.
Madam Speaker is both resigned to this insurrection, and not amused. She tells Burke in Australia’s Ausminster system (our version of Westminster), the speaker is politically affiliated but impartial in the chair.
There is much laughter at that proposition. Haw haw haw.
Madam Speaker, crisply:
Being impartial in the chair doesn’t mean you give into the noisiest lot.
Bishop says she understands it is the job of oppositions to make life difficult for the government. She said when she was in opposition, she took to the calling with alacrity. But she’s displeased at this question from Burke, a former speaker. Not cool Anna.
Quite a satisfying little exchange, this. (Albeit inconclusive.)
Updated
at 6.47am BST
6.05am BST
06:05
Labor’s deputy leader, Tanya Plibersek.
Q: Given The Australian Financial Review reports a first home buyer on their own would need to earn about $152,000 a year to afford an average house or unit in Sydney, how can teachers and firefighters expect to buy their first home in Sydney?
Joe Hockey:
Well, for any individual, it is hard in Sydney. It is hard. I know – I understand that.
But what’s interesting is, the Labor party actually wants to make it harder. And why does the Labor party want to make it harder? Because the Labor party has now indicated that they are looking at abolishing negative gearing.
Hockey is going through the stats on low and middle income folks who use negative gearing concessions.
The treasurer:
There are 383,000 Australians earning less than $37,000 a year that have negatively geared properties. And they are using that in a number of cases to try and get into the market to get those investment loans when they may not be able to get a home loan for a particular market.
Updated
at 6.48am BST
5.59am BST
05:59
Shadow treasurer Chris Bowen would like the treasurer Joe Hockey to outline some of the good jobs that he suggested last week were necessary for good folks to get into the housing market in Sydney.
Hockey seems all out of examples. Fortunately Peter Dutton has turned up to declare Labor weak on border protection.