This article is from the source 'independent' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/ramadan-2015--as-ramadan-approaches-an-argument-over-how-long-northern-european-muslims-should-fast-springs-up-10318852.html
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Ramadan 2015: As holy month approaches, debate emerges over how long northern European Muslims should fast | Ramadan 2015: As holy month approaches, debate emerges over how long northern European Muslims should fast |
| (about 20 hours later) | |
| As the Muslim holy month of Ramadan approaches, and British Muslims prepare for four weeks of fasting during daylight hours, a perennial debate on changing the Ramadan observance times in northern regions has sprung up again. | As the Muslim holy month of Ramadan approaches, and British Muslims prepare for four weeks of fasting during daylight hours, a perennial debate on changing the Ramadan observance times in northern regions has sprung up again. |
| Dr Usama Haswan, an Islamic researcher from anti-extremism group Quilliam, has said that it would make more sense for Muslims in the UK to follow Mecca timings, as daylight lasts much longer this far north than it does in the Middle East. | Dr Usama Haswan, an Islamic researcher from anti-extremism group Quilliam, has said that it would make more sense for Muslims in the UK to follow Mecca timings, as daylight lasts much longer this far north than it does in the Middle East. |
| Muslims at the East London Mosque break their fast after a long day of no food or water. In Mecca, daylight during Ramadan usually lasts from around 12 to 13 hours. In the southern part of the UK, it typically lasts around 16 hours or more, and the timings mean that observers will have to wake up at around 4am if they want to eat in the morning. | Muslims at the East London Mosque break their fast after a long day of no food or water. In Mecca, daylight during Ramadan usually lasts from around 12 to 13 hours. In the southern part of the UK, it typically lasts around 16 hours or more, and the timings mean that observers will have to wake up at around 4am if they want to eat in the morning. |
| As the start of Ramadan is based on the first sighting of the new moon, it comes earlier and earlier each year. For the last few years, however, it has occurred during summer, meaning a much longer fasting time. This year, Ramadan will begin on 18 June. | As the start of Ramadan is based on the first sighting of the new moon, it comes earlier and earlier each year. For the last few years, however, it has occurred during summer, meaning a much longer fasting time. This year, Ramadan will begin on 18 June. |
| #Ramadan fast in UK 'should be shortened' says scholar: http://t.co/3yeSPhsDDz Ridiculous! you either fast not fast. | #Ramadan fast in UK 'should be shortened' says scholar: http://t.co/3yeSPhsDDz Ridiculous! you either fast not fast. |
| Dr Hasan said that Islamic law is about balance, and reducing the fasting hours to something more reasonable is more sensible. | Dr Hasan said that Islamic law is about balance, and reducing the fasting hours to something more reasonable is more sensible. |
| However, things get worse the further north you go. In Aberdeen, more than 500 miles north of London, daylight will last for around 18 hours during Ramadan. | However, things get worse the further north you go. In Aberdeen, more than 500 miles north of London, daylight will last for around 18 hours during Ramadan. |
| And elsewhere in northern Europe, such as the far north of Sweden, the sun may only set for a couple of hours a day, if at all. | And elsewhere in northern Europe, such as the far north of Sweden, the sun may only set for a couple of hours a day, if at all. |
| In Kiruna, Sweden's northernmost town, the sun has not set this month - and it's not going to go down before August. | In Kiruna, Sweden's northernmost town, the sun has not set this month - and it's not going to go down before August. |
| This leaves Swedish muslims in a tricky position, as observing the fast and consuming no food or water would kill them in a matter of days. | |
| There is no agreed-upon standard - some Muslims choose to observe Mecca time, others observe the timings of their own country. | There is no agreed-upon standard - some Muslims choose to observe Mecca time, others observe the timings of their own country. |
| The Uppsala mosque in Sweden, where the sun will rise at around 3:30am and won't go down until around 19 hours later during Ramadan (Pic by Johan A via Flickr, published under Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 License) | |
| Mohammed Kharaki, a spokesman for Sweden's Islamic Association, said the organisation had this week issued guidelines that said Muslims should fast between the times that the sun was last clearly seen to rise and fall - despite this concession, this could well amount to a 19-hour fast. | Mohammed Kharaki, a spokesman for Sweden's Islamic Association, said the organisation had this week issued guidelines that said Muslims should fast between the times that the sun was last clearly seen to rise and fall - despite this concession, this could well amount to a 19-hour fast. |
| However, he also advised against being too strict with the daylight rule. | However, he also advised against being too strict with the daylight rule. |
| Speaking to AFP, he said: "People can try to fast for 19 hours but not handle it. That's not the idea... If you don't manage to do your work or stay on your feet, then it's time to break the fast." | Speaking to AFP, he said: "People can try to fast for 19 hours but not handle it. That's not the idea... If you don't manage to do your work or stay on your feet, then it's time to break the fast." |
| However, even with a lengthy fast for British Muslims, the vast majority are adamant that they will observe it, no matter how difficult it is. | However, even with a lengthy fast for British Muslims, the vast majority are adamant that they will observe it, no matter how difficult it is. |