This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-32842881
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Evie Thomas death: Judge blames father for injuries | Evie Thomas death: Judge blames father for injuries |
(about 5 hours later) | |
A man acquitted by a jury of fracturing his baby daughter's skull was responsible for inflicting her injuries, a judge has said. | A man acquitted by a jury of fracturing his baby daughter's skull was responsible for inflicting her injuries, a judge has said. |
Mr Justice Peter Jackson concluded that 16-week-old Evie, who died in February 2013, had been assaulted by her father Martin Thomas, from Wigan. | Mr Justice Peter Jackson concluded that 16-week-old Evie, who died in February 2013, had been assaulted by her father Martin Thomas, from Wigan. |
She suffered three skull fractures and more than a dozen broken ribs. | She suffered three skull fractures and more than a dozen broken ribs. |
The judge made his conclusion public after a family court ruling relating to Mr Thomas and Evie's mother. | The judge made his conclusion public after a family court ruling relating to Mr Thomas and Evie's mother. |
'Determined liar' | 'Determined liar' |
Lifting the normal reporting restrictions, Mr Justice Jackson said the law would be "a screen to hide the truth" if the father went unnamed. | Lifting the normal reporting restrictions, Mr Justice Jackson said the law would be "a screen to hide the truth" if the father went unnamed. |
Mr Thomas had been accused of causing grievous bodily harm. | |
He was acquitted by a jury at Liverpool Crown Court in October 2014. | |
But, giving judgement in a custody dispute, Mr Justice Jackson said Mr Thomas was a "determined liar" who, on the balance of probabilities, had caused Evie's injuries. | But, giving judgement in a custody dispute, Mr Justice Jackson said Mr Thomas was a "determined liar" who, on the balance of probabilities, had caused Evie's injuries. |
The girl's mother, Hayley Fisher, was "entitled to be exonerated", he added. | The girl's mother, Hayley Fisher, was "entitled to be exonerated", he added. |
The judge said Miss Fisher had heard Mr Thomas "blame her for Evie's death" and blame another daughter for one of the skull fractures. | The judge said Miss Fisher had heard Mr Thomas "blame her for Evie's death" and blame another daughter for one of the skull fractures. |
In a written ruling, published on Thursday, the senior family court judge said that "sole responsibility of Evie's injuries rests with the father". | In a written ruling, published on Thursday, the senior family court judge said that "sole responsibility of Evie's injuries rests with the father". |
He added that the assaults on Evie "significantly contributed" to her death which was "unascertained". | He added that the assaults on Evie "significantly contributed" to her death which was "unascertained". |
Mr Thomas told BBC North West Tonight's Clare Fallon: "I've been advised not to comment and I feel I have nothing more to say." | |
Family courts make far-reaching decisions, such as whether children should be taken into care or put up for adoption, or given contact with parents who are divorcing. | Family courts make far-reaching decisions, such as whether children should be taken into care or put up for adoption, or given contact with parents who are divorcing. |
In this case, family proceedings took place in 2013 but the judge deferred the decision on the publication of his fact-finding conclusion. | In this case, family proceedings took place in 2013 but the judge deferred the decision on the publication of his fact-finding conclusion. |
Previous version
1
Next version