This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-32812448
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Pianist James Rhodes can publish child abuse memoir | Pianist James Rhodes can publish child abuse memoir |
(34 minutes later) | |
A concert pianist has won a legal battle to publish an autobiographical book giving details of sexual abuse he experienced as a child. | A concert pianist has won a legal battle to publish an autobiographical book giving details of sexual abuse he experienced as a child. |
James Rhodes, 40, persuaded Supreme Court justices to lift an injunction that had barred its publication. | James Rhodes, 40, persuaded Supreme Court justices to lift an injunction that had barred its publication. |
The Court of Appeal granted a temporary injunction in October, blocking parts of the memoir, Instrumental. | The Court of Appeal granted a temporary injunction in October, blocking parts of the memoir, Instrumental. |
This was after Mr Rhodes's ex-wife raised fears it would cause their 12-year-old son "serious harm". | This was after Mr Rhodes's ex-wife raised fears it would cause their 12-year-old son "serious harm". |
Justices had ruled that Mr Rhodes could not be identified, either in media reports or on social media. | Justices had ruled that Mr Rhodes could not be identified, either in media reports or on social media. |
Following the injunction, Mr Rhodes asked the Supreme Court for a ruling. | Following the injunction, Mr Rhodes asked the Supreme Court for a ruling. |
Five Supreme Court justices have now ruled in his favour on Wednesday after examining the case at a January hearing. | Five Supreme Court justices have now ruled in his favour on Wednesday after examining the case at a January hearing. |
Some reporting restrictions have subsequently been lifted. | Some reporting restrictions have subsequently been lifted. |
The justices said Mr Rhodes could be named but the names of his son and ex-wife should not be made public. | The justices said Mr Rhodes could be named but the names of his son and ex-wife should not be made public. |
'Public interest' | |
Mr Rhodes's book is now due to be released next week. | Mr Rhodes's book is now due to be released next week. |
It includes accounts of physical and sexual abuse and rape inflicted on him from the age of six by the boxing coach at his school. | |
It goes on to chart his subsequent abuse of drink and drugs, self-harm, attempts at suicide and time in a psychiatric hospital, culminating in his redemption through music. | |
Mr Rhodes's alleged abuser was prosecuted but died before he could face trial. | |
Judges heard that the pianist's son lived with his mother overseas and had disabilities including Asperger's Syndrome and dyspraxia. | |
His mother said their child was "particularly intelligent" and "very proud" of his father, but did not know about the sexual abuse or the scale of his father's self-harm and mental illness. | His mother said their child was "particularly intelligent" and "very proud" of his father, but did not know about the sexual abuse or the scale of his father's self-harm and mental illness. |
It was argued that the boy would become "greatly disturbed" if he became aware of those details. | |
Hugh Tomlinson QC, representing Mr Rhodes, told the Supreme Court the book was a "true autobiographical account" and there was "a clear public interest in publication". | |
He also said courts should not become involved "matters of taste" and editorship. | |
'Freedom of speech' | |
Speaking outside the court, Mr Rhodes said the ruling was a "victory for freedom of speech". | Speaking outside the court, Mr Rhodes said the ruling was a "victory for freedom of speech". |
"If this had been allowed to continue anyone could have used this to ban any book. We do not ban books in this country." | "If this had been allowed to continue anyone could have used this to ban any book. We do not ban books in this country." |
He said the decision also sent a message to children who were victims of abuse. | He said the decision also sent a message to children who were victims of abuse. |
"I was told not to tell when I was a child. Children are told not to tell. The message is 'tell someone'. This is a victory for victims." | "I was told not to tell when I was a child. Children are told not to tell. The message is 'tell someone'. This is a victory for victims." |
And he said his son would not be harmed by the details published in the book. | And he said his son would not be harmed by the details published in the book. |
"I love him more than anything. I am his father," said Mr Rhodes. "He is not going to read the book. This is not a children's book." | "I love him more than anything. I am his father," said Mr Rhodes. "He is not going to read the book. This is not a children's book." |
Mr Rhodes was joined by actor Benedict Cumberbatch, who said the pair had been friends since school. | |
Mr Cumberbatch said: "I am here to give my support. It is a very emotional moment... It is a searing vindication of freedom of speech. | |
"This man suffered abuse when he was a child and was held in silence then, unable to tell a world that turned a blind eye to him during that horrific period of his life. | |
"And then in adult life, through searing, humbling honesty in a excoriating account of it, in a brilliant, witty, passionate, utterly transparent way in this book, was then trying to express exactly what he'd experienced years later as a adult, was then gagged again. | |
"To re-experience that veil of silence, that inability to be able to shout for help, is appalling." |