Houston man makes last-ditch plea to supreme court to halt his execution

http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/may/12/houston-texas-supreme-court-halt-execution

Version 0 of 1.

A Houston man facing execution for killing his 15-year-old girlfriend, her mother and her grandfather 13 years ago is looking to the US supreme court to stop his lethal injection.

Derrick Dewayne Charles is set to die on Tuesday evening. The 32-year-old would be the seventh prisoner executed this year in Texas, the nation’s most active capital punishment state.

His attorneys are arguing that he is mentally incompetent for execution and that they need time and court-approved money for experts and investigators to pursue that claim.

State attorneys say questions about his competency were rejected in earlier rounds of appeals and there is no evidence he is incompetent.

Charles in 2003 pleaded guilty to capital murder charges. He was on parole for a burglary conviction at the time of the triple slaying.

He was wanted by authorities for ignoring mandatory meetings with his parole officer when he was arrested for killing his 15-year-old girlfriend Myiesha Bennett, her mother Brenda Bennett and her grandfather Obie Bennett at their home in Houston 13 years ago.

Ten months later, in May 2003, Charles pleaded guilty to capital murder, leaving a jury to decide whether he should spend the rest of his life in prison or be sent to death row. Jurors decided he should be executed after hearing about his extensive juvenile record, his burglary conviction and the details of the killings.

He is one of at least three Texas inmates scheduled for lethal injection over the next several weeks. The Texas department of criminal justice has said it has enough pentobarbital to carry out two of the executions, meaning the prison agency would need to replenish its supply of the difficult-to-obtain sedative for capital punishment use or find a substitute drug to replace it.

Charles was arrested a day after the bodies of Myiesha Bennett, her 44-year-old mother, and 77-year-old grandfather were found at their north-east Houston home. People who knew them became alarmed after not hearing from them for several days.

Relatives have said Brenda Bennett was not thrilled with her daughter’s relationship with Charles, who was 19 at the time.

Attorneys for Charles – who are seeking to get the punishment halted – say he is mentally incompetent for execution and that the courts should authorize money for psychologists and investigators, so the defense can develop those arguments.

The supreme court has said condemned inmates must be aware they are about to be executed and have a rational understanding of why they are being put to death.

Charles was diagnosed as mentally ill when he was a child and was deprived of care and medication while growing up, one of his attorneys, Paul Mansur, told the justices in a filing.

Another appeal argued that the trial court violated Charles’s constitutional rights by refusing to appoint psychiatric experts and investigators.

State attorneys are opposing any delay in the punishment. They say questions about whether Charles is mentally incompetent for execution were rejected by courts earlier and that his lawyers improperly filed their constitutional challenge.

Court records show a warrant was issued for Charles in February 2002, two months after he was paroled after serving eight months of a three-year burglary sentence. He met once with his parole officer, then failed to show up for other required sessions.

Charles was arrested at a Houston motel where Brenda Bennett’s car was found. Police have said he told them he beat and strangled Obie Bennett. Myiesha Bennett was choked with an extension cord, beaten with a box containing stereo speakers and hit with a TV.

Brenda Bennett was thrown into a water-filled bathtub along with a plugged-in TV. When that failed to electrocute her, she was dragged through the house, raped and strangled.

Court documents indicate that Charles said he smoked marijuana soaked in embalming fluid before the killings, then hallucinated while committing them.