This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-31813268
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Gordon Brown: EU exit would be 'North Korea option' | Gordon Brown: EU exit would be 'North Korea option' |
(35 minutes later) | |
Leaving the European Union would make Britain the North Korea of Europe with "few friends [and] no influence", Gordon Brown has warned. | Leaving the European Union would make Britain the North Korea of Europe with "few friends [and] no influence", Gordon Brown has warned. |
The former prime minister said the UK would be "out in the cold" if it withdrew from the 28-member bloc. | The former prime minister said the UK would be "out in the cold" if it withdrew from the 28-member bloc. |
David Cameron has promised an in/out referendum on Britain's membership of the EU if the Conservatives win in May. | David Cameron has promised an in/out referendum on Britain's membership of the EU if the Conservatives win in May. |
But in an article for the Guardian, Mr Brown said the government's stance had marginalised Britain in the EU. | But in an article for the Guardian, Mr Brown said the government's stance had marginalised Britain in the EU. |
The article came ahead of an adjournment debate on the subject called by Mr Brown - which could be his last speech in the Commons before he steps down in May. | The article came ahead of an adjournment debate on the subject called by Mr Brown - which could be his last speech in the Commons before he steps down in May. |
Being "half-in half-out, a Britain that is semi-detached and disengaged... has made us weaker than ever" in the EU, on international issues such as the Greek crisis, climate change and Ukraine, he said. | Being "half-in half-out, a Britain that is semi-detached and disengaged... has made us weaker than ever" in the EU, on international issues such as the Greek crisis, climate change and Ukraine, he said. |
Under Mr Cameron's plans, the referendum on the EU would take place in 2017 after a period of renegotiation of the UK's terms of membership. | Under Mr Cameron's plans, the referendum on the EU would take place in 2017 after a period of renegotiation of the UK's terms of membership. |
Labour has said it would not offer such a referendum unless there was a significant shift of power away from London to Brussels. | Labour has said it would not offer such a referendum unless there was a significant shift of power away from London to Brussels. |
'True patriotic course' | 'True patriotic course' |
Mr Brown said: "We must tell the truth about the three million jobs, 25,000 companies, £200bn of annual exports and the £450bn of inward investment linked to Europe; and how the 'Britzerland' or Norwegian alternatives (even Norwegians oppose the Norwegian option) leave us subject to EU rules, but denied a vote in shaping them. | Mr Brown said: "We must tell the truth about the three million jobs, 25,000 companies, £200bn of annual exports and the £450bn of inward investment linked to Europe; and how the 'Britzerland' or Norwegian alternatives (even Norwegians oppose the Norwegian option) leave us subject to EU rules, but denied a vote in shaping them. |
"And we must talk about how the Hong Kong option - 'leaving Europe to join the world' - is really the North Korea option, out in the cold with few friends, no influence, little new trade and even less new investment." | "And we must talk about how the Hong Kong option - 'leaving Europe to join the world' - is really the North Korea option, out in the cold with few friends, no influence, little new trade and even less new investment." |
He said the UK was on course to overtake Germany as Europe's biggest economy in a decade, and it would not make sense to withdraw from the bloc now. | He said the UK was on course to overtake Germany as Europe's biggest economy in a decade, and it would not make sense to withdraw from the bloc now. |
"It would be a terrible irony if Britain opts out, leaving Europe divided, Russia empowered, the US bypassing us for a Franco-German axis - and Scotland threatening to abandon a non-European UK." | "It would be a terrible irony if Britain opts out, leaving Europe divided, Russia empowered, the US bypassing us for a Franco-German axis - and Scotland threatening to abandon a non-European UK." |
The Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath MP argued that Britain's future lay within the European Union, saying it was the country's "true patriotic course" to lead it. | The Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath MP argued that Britain's future lay within the European Union, saying it was the country's "true patriotic course" to lead it. |
"Our destiny is not a bit player on someone else's stage, or a spectator hectoring from the wings, but always setting the agenda, bringing people together, and championing change," he said. | "Our destiny is not a bit player on someone else's stage, or a spectator hectoring from the wings, but always setting the agenda, bringing people together, and championing change," he said. |
Hyperbole? | |
Mr Brown's remarks have been met with criticism by some commentators, in particular his comparison between the UK and North Korea. | |
John Rentoul, Independent on Sunday columnist, said Mr Brown had weakened his argument with "exaggeration". | |
But the New Statesman's political editor, George Eaton, said that beyond the hyperbolic North Korea comparison "there is much wisdom" in the former PM's argument. | |
Mr Cameron wants to renegotiate Britain's membership of the EU if he remains prime minister after May, to win back powers in areas such as welfare and immigration - and put it to a public vote. | Mr Cameron wants to renegotiate Britain's membership of the EU if he remains prime minister after May, to win back powers in areas such as welfare and immigration - and put it to a public vote. |
Labour has said the prospect of an EU exit is creating uncertainty and risk for British businesses. | Labour has said the prospect of an EU exit is creating uncertainty and risk for British businesses. |
The party has said it will only sanction a referendum if further powers are handed from the UK to Brussels requiring a fundamental change to existing treaties. | The party has said it will only sanction a referendum if further powers are handed from the UK to Brussels requiring a fundamental change to existing treaties. |
The Liberal Democrats remain committed to staying in the EU, while the UK Independence Party wants Britain to leave. | The Liberal Democrats remain committed to staying in the EU, while the UK Independence Party wants Britain to leave. |