This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk/6101098.stm
The article has changed 8 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Reviews for pathologist's cases | Reviews for pathologist's cases |
(30 minutes later) | |
Convictions in nine murder and manslaughter cases involving a former Home Office pathologist are being reviewed, the BBC has learned. | Convictions in nine murder and manslaughter cases involving a former Home Office pathologist are being reviewed, the BBC has learned. |
The Criminal Cases Review Commission is looking into the cases involving Dr Michael Heath, who quit after criticism from the forensic pathology watchdog. | The Criminal Cases Review Commission is looking into the cases involving Dr Michael Heath, who quit after criticism from the forensic pathology watchdog. |
One case is that of Michael Stone, serving life for the murders of Lin and Megan Russell. | One case is that of Michael Stone, serving life for the murders of Lin and Megan Russell. |
The attorney general has ruled out a wholesale review of Mr Heath's cases. | The attorney general has ruled out a wholesale review of Mr Heath's cases. |
Lord Goldsmith said normal procedures "should be sufficient". | Lord Goldsmith said normal procedures "should be sufficient". |
Detailed investigation | Detailed investigation |
The commission, which refers convictions to the Court of Appeal when it suspects there may have been a miscarriage of justice, trawled through about 50 homicide cases involving Dr Heath. | The commission, which refers convictions to the Court of Appeal when it suspects there may have been a miscarriage of justice, trawled through about 50 homicide cases involving Dr Heath. |
Five convictions have given officials cause for concern and are to be investigated in more detail. | Five convictions have given officials cause for concern and are to be investigated in more detail. |
Four others are already being considered, including that of Stone. | Four others are already being considered, including that of Stone. |
His solicitors have asked the commission to examine Dr Heath's post-mortem examination findings, though this evidence forms only one part of their submission. | His solicitors have asked the commission to examine Dr Heath's post-mortem examination findings, though this evidence forms only one part of their submission. |
I can assure you, I spent 10 years within a lifer system in England and Scotland and the biggest majority of lifers admit their guilt Victor Boreman | I can assure you, I spent 10 years within a lifer system in England and Scotland and the biggest majority of lifers admit their guilt Victor Boreman |
Last June, the convictions of Victor Boreman - a 38-year-old from Scotland accused of murdering a man at a flat in Plumstead, in London, in 1996 - and that of two other men were quashed after a judge ruled Dr Heath's evidence was "discredited". | |
In his evidence Dr Heath said the victim died after drowning in his own blood because of injuries to his head and lips. | In his evidence Dr Heath said the victim died after drowning in his own blood because of injuries to his head and lips. |
But this was undermined by reports from other pathologists as it could not be determined whether his 51-year-old victim had died from injuries caused by the assault or from fumes caused by a fire in the flat. | |
Mr Boreman told BBC News: "People think that every prisoner protests their innocence. | Mr Boreman told BBC News: "People think that every prisoner protests their innocence. |
"I can assure you, I spent 10 years within a lifer system in England and Scotland and the biggest majority of lifers admit their guilt. | "I can assure you, I spent 10 years within a lifer system in England and Scotland and the biggest majority of lifers admit their guilt. |
"They accept it; they might not like it but they move on." | "They accept it; they might not like it but they move on." |
Dr Heath, who was appointed to his role in 1991, resigned from the register last month after a disciplinary panel ruled that his post-mortem examinations on two women led to their partners' murder trials. Both men were eventually cleared. | Dr Heath, who was appointed to his role in 1991, resigned from the register last month after a disciplinary panel ruled that his post-mortem examinations on two women led to their partners' murder trials. Both men were eventually cleared. |
Dr Heath has conducted hundreds of examinations since being appointed to his role in 1991. | Dr Heath has conducted hundreds of examinations since being appointed to his role in 1991. |