This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/world/europe/7194443.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Czech anger at caged beds report | Czech anger at caged beds report |
(4 days later) | |
A Czech minister has questioned claims that cage-like beds are still being used for children in social care homes a year after being banned. | A Czech minister has questioned claims that cage-like beds are still being used for children in social care homes a year after being banned. |
An undercover BBC team found children kept in high-bar beds in five homes. | An undercover BBC team found children kept in high-bar beds in five homes. |
Social affairs minister Petr Necas told Czech media the beds were "cots" not cages and "completely normal" if a doctor and guardian agreed to them. | Social affairs minister Petr Necas told Czech media the beds were "cots" not cages and "completely normal" if a doctor and guardian agreed to them. |
But Council of Europe human rights commissioner Thomas Hammarberg called for a more child-oriented approach. | But Council of Europe human rights commissioner Thomas Hammarberg called for a more child-oriented approach. |
They have to have an overall clear policy that they shouldn't use beds that have a psychological impact of being imprisoned Thomas HammarbergCommissioner for Human Rights, Council of Europe Q&A: Cage beds | They have to have an overall clear policy that they shouldn't use beds that have a psychological impact of being imprisoned Thomas HammarbergCommissioner for Human Rights, Council of Europe Q&A: Cage beds |
Mr Necas was quoted by the Aktualne.cz website as saying that his children were in a cot with bars until they were three years old and "it does not matter whether a client is 20, their mental age makes the difference". | |
A ministry spokesman, quoted by Czech media, said that the alternative to side rails was increasing the dosage of tranquillisers. | A ministry spokesman, quoted by Czech media, said that the alternative to side rails was increasing the dosage of tranquillisers. |
In the ministry's opinion it was felt that strong medicine was far worse. | In the ministry's opinion it was felt that strong medicine was far worse. |
Child safety | |
But Mr Hammarberg told the BBC News website that arguments about the safety of the child were second to the effect on the child's mental state. | But Mr Hammarberg told the BBC News website that arguments about the safety of the child were second to the effect on the child's mental state. |
"The psychological impact of having such a bed is negative and that's why anyone concerned with the rights of the child would recommend very highly against it." | "The psychological impact of having such a bed is negative and that's why anyone concerned with the rights of the child would recommend very highly against it." |
In the BBC report, a girl with severe mental disabilities is shown in a bed, locked behind bars that rise up six feet from the floor. | In the BBC report, a girl with severe mental disabilities is shown in a bed, locked behind bars that rise up six feet from the floor. |
Jan Fiala of the Mental Disability Advocacy Centre said that the beds shown were cages and could not be considered cots | Jan Fiala of the Mental Disability Advocacy Centre said that the beds shown were cages and could not be considered cots |
"In a cot a child can't climb out, but cots aren't so high that carers cannot reach them," he said. | "In a cot a child can't climb out, but cots aren't so high that carers cannot reach them," he said. |
A ministry spokesman said only a small percentage of children were placed in such "cots" and he added that the BBC report had been unprofessional. | |
The report, he said, should have had a response from a care home director and included only one comment from a lengthy interview with the man who drafted the new law for the ministry of social affairs, Martin Zarsky. | |
Inspection team | |
In his comment, Mr Zarsky told the BBC that an inspection team would be sent immediately. | |
The human rights commissioner said the decision to have another look at the care homes in question was a positive step. | The human rights commissioner said the decision to have another look at the care homes in question was a positive step. |
"They have to have an overall clear policy that they shouldn't use beds that have a psychological impact of being imprisoned," Mr Hammarberg said. | "They have to have an overall clear policy that they shouldn't use beds that have a psychological impact of being imprisoned," Mr Hammarberg said. |
"Hopefully they'll have a child-rights-oriented approach in the future." | "Hopefully they'll have a child-rights-oriented approach in the future." |
Previous version
1
Next version