This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/7179579.stm
The article has changed 23 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 20 | Version 21 |
|---|---|
| New nuclear plants get go-ahead | New nuclear plants get go-ahead |
| (about 6 hours later) | |
| A new generation of nuclear power stations in the UK has been given formal backing by the government. | A new generation of nuclear power stations in the UK has been given formal backing by the government. |
| Business Secretary John Hutton told MPs they would give a "safe and affordable" way of securing the UK's future energy supplies while fighting climate change. | Business Secretary John Hutton told MPs they would give a "safe and affordable" way of securing the UK's future energy supplies while fighting climate change. |
| He said any plants would be built at or near existing reactors by private firms and said he hoped the first one would be completed "well before 2020". | He said any plants would be built at or near existing reactors by private firms and said he hoped the first one would be completed "well before 2020". |
| Critics say new reactors will be expensive, dirty and dangerous. | Critics say new reactors will be expensive, dirty and dangerous. |
| The government will not be building any reactors itself - but it says it will take steps, such as streamlining the planning process and identifying likely sites, to encourage private operators to build them. | The government will not be building any reactors itself - but it says it will take steps, such as streamlining the planning process and identifying likely sites, to encourage private operators to build them. |
| GOVERNMENT PLANS Speed up planning process to make it easier to build plantsNo public subsidies for nuclear except in emergenciesNo limit to amount of electricity generated by nuclear powerNew independent body to monitor decommissioning costsTrebling of investment in wind and wave powerStore nuclear waste at 'interim' facility until suitable underground site found Guide to nuclear powerQ&A: Nuclear power plansAnalysis: Job done? | GOVERNMENT PLANS Speed up planning process to make it easier to build plantsNo public subsidies for nuclear except in emergenciesNo limit to amount of electricity generated by nuclear powerNew independent body to monitor decommissioning costsTrebling of investment in wind and wave powerStore nuclear waste at 'interim' facility until suitable underground site found Guide to nuclear powerQ&A: Nuclear power plansAnalysis: Job done? |
| Mr Hutton conceded that no nuclear plant had been built anywhere in the world without public money - but he insisted there would be no subsidies from the UK government. | Mr Hutton conceded that no nuclear plant had been built anywhere in the world without public money - but he insisted there would be no subsidies from the UK government. |
| "It is a matter for the power companies to bring forward proposals on the basis that there will be no public subsidies," he told BBC Radio 4's The World at One. | "It is a matter for the power companies to bring forward proposals on the basis that there will be no public subsidies," he told BBC Radio 4's The World at One. |
| Public funds would only be provided in the "very unlikely circumstances of an emergency at a nuclear plant," added Mr Hutton. | Public funds would only be provided in the "very unlikely circumstances of an emergency at a nuclear plant," added Mr Hutton. |
| According to its white paper, the government will not offer extra incentives to invest in nuclear power, but some tax advantages may be available to firms hit by decommissioning costs to ensure a "level fiscal playing field" with other forms of electricity generation. | According to its white paper, the government will not offer extra incentives to invest in nuclear power, but some tax advantages may be available to firms hit by decommissioning costs to ensure a "level fiscal playing field" with other forms of electricity generation. |
| The government has also yet to decide how much new nuclear operators should pay towards the cost of building underground caverns as a permanent storage site for Britain's nuclear waste. | The government has also yet to decide how much new nuclear operators should pay towards the cost of building underground caverns as a permanent storage site for Britain's nuclear waste. |
| Until a suitable site can be found, waste will continue to be stockpiled above ground at "interim" facilities at Sellafield, in Cumbria, it has said. | |
| Mr Hutton rejected calls to find a permanent storage site before giving the green light to new nuclear plants. | Mr Hutton rejected calls to find a permanent storage site before giving the green light to new nuclear plants. |
| 'Tried and tested' | 'Tried and tested' |
| French energy giant EDF has already said it plans to build four nuclear plants in the UK by 2017, without subsidies, following the government's announcement. | French energy giant EDF has already said it plans to build four nuclear plants in the UK by 2017, without subsidies, following the government's announcement. |
| Chief executive Vincent De Rivaz said: "We have made it clear that once the right frameworks are in place, we will be in a position to move fast, move first and move safe." | Chief executive Vincent De Rivaz said: "We have made it clear that once the right frameworks are in place, we will be in a position to move fast, move first and move safe." |
| German power company E.On and British Gas parent Centrica also expressed interest in building nuclear plants in the UK, following the government's announcement. | German power company E.On and British Gas parent Centrica also expressed interest in building nuclear plants in the UK, following the government's announcement. |
| I can't decide whether new nuclear is a white elephant or a red herring Steve WebbLiberal Democrats Nuclear no answer - Lib DemsNo nuclear subsidies - ToriesIn quotes: Nuclear plans | I can't decide whether new nuclear is a white elephant or a red herring Steve WebbLiberal Democrats Nuclear no answer - Lib DemsNo nuclear subsidies - ToriesIn quotes: Nuclear plans |
| Speaking earlier in the Commons, Mr Hutton said the government had concluded nuclear power was a "tried and tested", and safe, technology which had a role to play "in this country's future energy mix alongside other low-carbon sources". | Speaking earlier in the Commons, Mr Hutton said the government had concluded nuclear power was a "tried and tested", and safe, technology which had a role to play "in this country's future energy mix alongside other low-carbon sources". |
| Analysis of future gas and carbon prices showed nuclear was "affordable and provides one of the cheapest electricity options available to reduce our carbon emissions". | Analysis of future gas and carbon prices showed nuclear was "affordable and provides one of the cheapest electricity options available to reduce our carbon emissions". |
| Waste storage | Waste storage |
| An independent body, the Nuclear Liabilities Financing Assurances Board, will look at the potential clean-up costs - including any impact on electricity bills - and a review of potential sites for new reactors will report next year. | An independent body, the Nuclear Liabilities Financing Assurances Board, will look at the potential clean-up costs - including any impact on electricity bills - and a review of potential sites for new reactors will report next year. |
| Mr Hutton assured MPs that private operators would be expected to meet the full cost of building nuclear plants, decommissioning and disposing of waste. | Mr Hutton assured MPs that private operators would be expected to meet the full cost of building nuclear plants, decommissioning and disposing of waste. |
| But he said no "artificial cap" would be put on the proportion of electricity to be generated from nuclear power or any other source of "low carbon energy". Existing nuclear power stations produce about 20% of the UK's electricity. | But he said no "artificial cap" would be put on the proportion of electricity to be generated from nuclear power or any other source of "low carbon energy". Existing nuclear power stations produce about 20% of the UK's electricity. |
| Conservative spokesman Alan Duncan welcomed the government's commitment to nuclear power. | |
| But he warned: "On no account should there be any kind of subsidy for nuclear power." | But he warned: "On no account should there be any kind of subsidy for nuclear power." |
| Steve Webb, for the Liberal Democrats, attacked the decision, warning the country faced being locked into a technology "for the best part of a century, when other technologies like carbon capture and storage, like renewables, are evolving practically every day". | Steve Webb, for the Liberal Democrats, attacked the decision, warning the country faced being locked into a technology "for the best part of a century, when other technologies like carbon capture and storage, like renewables, are evolving practically every day". |
| He added: "I can't decide whether new nuclear is a white elephant or a red herring. But very clearly what it isn't is the answer to the energy problems we face today." | He added: "I can't decide whether new nuclear is a white elephant or a red herring. But very clearly what it isn't is the answer to the energy problems we face today." |
| Legal challenge | Legal challenge |
| Ministers say a decision on nuclear power is necessary now, as many nuclear and coal-fired power stations are due to close within 20 years. | Ministers say a decision on nuclear power is necessary now, as many nuclear and coal-fired power stations are due to close within 20 years. |
| The nuclear industry believes it can get the first new plant on-stream by 2017. | The nuclear industry believes it can get the first new plant on-stream by 2017. |
| HAVE YOUR SAY If we are serious about reducing CO2 and we don't want to live in the dark, what other choice do we realistically have? Nick Davy, UK Send us your commentsLiving near Sizewell | HAVE YOUR SAY If we are serious about reducing CO2 and we don't want to live in the dark, what other choice do we realistically have? Nick Davy, UK Send us your commentsLiving near Sizewell |
| The government is also publishing an Energy Bill designed to reduce carbon emissions and secure the UK's power supplies. | The government is also publishing an Energy Bill designed to reduce carbon emissions and secure the UK's power supplies. |
| But its nuclear plans could be still be subject to a legal challenge from Greenpeace, which successfully challenged an earlier government review backing nuclear power in the High Court. | But its nuclear plans could be still be subject to a legal challenge from Greenpeace, which successfully challenged an earlier government review backing nuclear power in the High Court. |
| It claims research shows that even 10 new reactors would cut the UK's carbon emissions by only about 4% some time after 2025. | It claims research shows that even 10 new reactors would cut the UK's carbon emissions by only about 4% some time after 2025. |
| Greenpeace executive director John Sauven said: "This is bad news for Britain's energy security and bad news for our efforts to beat climate change." | Greenpeace executive director John Sauven said: "This is bad news for Britain's energy security and bad news for our efforts to beat climate change." |
| Although energy policy is not devolved, Scottish ministers have control of the planning system and also have to give consent under the Electricity Act to the construction of new power stations above a certain size. | Although energy policy is not devolved, Scottish ministers have control of the planning system and also have to give consent under the Electricity Act to the construction of new power stations above a certain size. |
| Scotland's First Minister Alex Salmond has said there is "no chance" of more nuclear power stations being built in Scotland. | Scotland's First Minister Alex Salmond has said there is "no chance" of more nuclear power stations being built in Scotland. |
| But Mr Hutton he believed the Scottish government was making a "mistake" by ruling out nuclear and it was "entirely possible" that Scottish consumers would rely on electricity generated in England in the future. | But Mr Hutton he believed the Scottish government was making a "mistake" by ruling out nuclear and it was "entirely possible" that Scottish consumers would rely on electricity generated in England in the future. |