This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-north-east-orkney-shetland-30671988
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
Free school meals for primary one to three pupils in Scotland | Free school meals for primary one to three pupils in Scotland |
(about 1 hour later) | |
All school children from primary one to three are now entitled to a free school meal, the Scottish government has announced. | All school children from primary one to three are now entitled to a free school meal, the Scottish government has announced. |
The £95m initiative covering state schools is expected to save families at least £330 a year. | The £95m initiative covering state schools is expected to save families at least £330 a year. |
First Minister Nicola Sturgeon launched the policy at her old primary school in Ayrshire. | |
She said making free school meals available on a universal basis was the "right thing to do". | |
The policy has been supported by unions and poverty campaigners. | The policy has been supported by unions and poverty campaigners. |
The Scottish government said the policy - for 135,000 children - would benefit pupils and their families alike. | |
Universal benefit? | Universal benefit? |
Jamie McIvor, education correspondent | Jamie McIvor, education correspondent |
The move enjoys broad support within Scotland but some are bound to wonder whether providing free meals to children from comfortably off families - and not just to those from families who will notice the saving - is really the best use of scarce resources. | The move enjoys broad support within Scotland but some are bound to wonder whether providing free meals to children from comfortably off families - and not just to those from families who will notice the saving - is really the best use of scarce resources. |
This touches on the wider debate about so-called universal benefits - whether money should be targeted only at those who need a service the most or spent providing a service which is free at the point of use for all who want it. | This touches on the wider debate about so-called universal benefits - whether money should be targeted only at those who need a service the most or spent providing a service which is free at the point of use for all who want it. |
The same broad argument covers issues as diverse as free bus travel for pensioners and the abolition of prescription charges four years ago. | The same broad argument covers issues as diverse as free bus travel for pensioners and the abolition of prescription charges four years ago. |
The challenge is to demonstrate to sceptics that there is a benefit to society as a whole from the policy. | The challenge is to demonstrate to sceptics that there is a benefit to society as a whole from the policy. |
One argument for extending free school meals was that it would abolish any stigma for children from low income families. | One argument for extending free school meals was that it would abolish any stigma for children from low income families. |
In practice, cashless payment systems have helped to do this already and the debate has moved into other areas, especially the benefits to public health and children's education. | In practice, cashless payment systems have helped to do this already and the debate has moved into other areas, especially the benefits to public health and children's education. |
Supporters argue that children with a regular healthy meal were more likely to be able to concentrate, get better academic results and were less likely to be obese. | Supporters argue that children with a regular healthy meal were more likely to be able to concentrate, get better academic results and were less likely to be obese. |
The government is giving councils extra money to help cover the cost of the extra free meals. | The government is giving councils extra money to help cover the cost of the extra free meals. |
But as the money is not ring-fenced, critics will be watching closely to make sure the cash actually goes on the meals. Their fear would be that free meals either prove a drain on other parts of the local budget - or that the commitment is met in letter but not in spirit with some of the money going elsewhere. | But as the money is not ring-fenced, critics will be watching closely to make sure the cash actually goes on the meals. Their fear would be that free meals either prove a drain on other parts of the local budget - or that the commitment is met in letter but not in spirit with some of the money going elsewhere. |
Speaking on BBC Radio Scotland's Good Morning Scotland programme, Ms Sturgeon said: "The cost is £70.5m in revenue terms over the next two years and we have also made just short of £25m available to local authorities in capital to enable them to make changes to their dining room facilities and such like." | |
The first minister defended the fact that children from wealth-off backgrounds would be entitled to a free lunch. | |
"By removing the stigma created by means testing you increase uptake amongst children from the poorest families," she said. | |
"We also know there is a significant increase in child poverty amongst families who are not on benefits, are in work but are struggling to make ends meet." | |
She said a policy "of a universal nature" would also help these families. | |
She added: "Then there's the link with learning and attainment. The evaluation of our pilot project says that free school meals had a positive impact on all aspects of a child's schooling." | |
Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Willie Rennie said: "The new year will set off to a great start for the 135,000 pupils who will benefit from a healthy and nourishing free school meal each and every day of the school week. | Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Willie Rennie said: "The new year will set off to a great start for the 135,000 pupils who will benefit from a healthy and nourishing free school meal each and every day of the school week. |
"This move, delivered as a result of Liberal Democrats in the UK government, will put more money back in parents' pockets and give kids a healthy lunch in the social environment of the school canteen." | "This move, delivered as a result of Liberal Democrats in the UK government, will put more money back in parents' pockets and give kids a healthy lunch in the social environment of the school canteen." |