This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk/7173599.stm
The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
Bishop warns of 'Islamic areas' | Bishop warns of 'Islamic areas' |
(about 3 hours later) | |
A Church of England bishop has said Islamic extremism has turned some communities into no-go areas for people of a different faith or race. | A Church of England bishop has said Islamic extremism has turned some communities into no-go areas for people of a different faith or race. |
The Bishop of Rochester, the Right Reverend Dr Michael Nazir-Ali, said non-Muslims may find it difficult to live or work in some places. | |
He said there was "hostility" in those areas and described the government's multicultural policies as divisive. | |
Muslims and some politicians have accused the bishop of scaremongering. | |
But other politicians agreed with the bishop - saying he had highlighted a real problem. | |
'Christian cause' | 'Christian cause' |
Writing in the Sunday Telegraph, Dr Nazir-Ali said there had been a worldwide resurgence of Islamic extremism, leading to young people growing up alienated from the country they live in. | |
Not only locally, but at the national level also the establishment of the Church of England is being eroded Dr Michael Nazir-AliBishop of Rochester class="" href="/1/hi/uk/7173759.stm">Profile: Michael Nazir-Ali | |
It had also turned "already separate communities into 'no-go' areas". | It had also turned "already separate communities into 'no-go' areas". |
He said there had been attempts to "impose an 'Islamic' character on certain areas", for example, by amplifying the call to prayer from mosques. | He said there had been attempts to "impose an 'Islamic' character on certain areas", for example, by amplifying the call to prayer from mosques. |
Apart from issues about noise levels, Dr Nazir-Ali said it also raised questions about "whether non-Muslims wish to be told the creed of a particular faith five times a day on the loudspeaker". | Apart from issues about noise levels, Dr Nazir-Ali said it also raised questions about "whether non-Muslims wish to be told the creed of a particular faith five times a day on the loudspeaker". |
The Muslim Council of Britain said the mosque call was no different from church bells ringing. | The Muslim Council of Britain said the mosque call was no different from church bells ringing. |
Dr Nazir-Ali warned of a multi-faith "mish mash" as the government promotes its integration policy. He said it was "an agenda which still lacks the underpinning of a moral and spiritual vision". | |
He said the role of chaplains in such places as hospitals, prisons and educational establishments was in jeopardy "either because of financial cuts or because the authorities want 'multi-faith' provision, without regard to the distinctively Christian character of the nation's laws, values, customs and culture". | He said the role of chaplains in such places as hospitals, prisons and educational establishments was in jeopardy "either because of financial cuts or because the authorities want 'multi-faith' provision, without regard to the distinctively Christian character of the nation's laws, values, customs and culture". |
If there is no evidence he can put forward then it boils down to simple scaremongering Ibrahim MograMuslim Council of Britain | If there is no evidence he can put forward then it boils down to simple scaremongering Ibrahim MograMuslim Council of Britain |
"Not only locally, but at the national level also the establishment of the Church of England is being eroded," Dr Nazir-Ali said. | "Not only locally, but at the national level also the establishment of the Church of England is being eroded," Dr Nazir-Ali said. |
He added: "If it had not been for the black majority churches and the recent arrival of people from central and eastern Europe, the Christian cause in many of our cities would have looked a lost one." | He added: "If it had not been for the black majority churches and the recent arrival of people from central and eastern Europe, the Christian cause in many of our cities would have looked a lost one." |
'Gross caricature' | |
The new leader of the Liberal Democrats, Nick Clegg, was highly critical of the bishop's claims, describing them as "a gross caricature of reality". | |
He told Sky News: "I strongly disagree with him. I don't think he has produced any evidence that there are really no-go areas - that is an extraordinarily inflammatory way of putting it." | |
He added: "That is not to say that there is not a legitimate debate to be had within our Muslim communities about the identity of modern Islam in modern Britain. | |
"Clearly there is a legitimate debate to be had there, because of the rise of extremism, particularly for young men in these communities." | |
But Conservative home affairs spokesman David Davis said the bishop had rightly drawn attention to a "deeply serious problem". | |
He said: "The government's confused and counter-productive approach risks creating a number of closed societies instead of one open cohesive one." | |
He said Labour's support for multiculturalism risked creating a situation of "voluntary apartheid". | |
Scaremongering | |
Ibrahim Mogra, of the Muslim Council of Britain's inter-faith relations committee, described the bishop's comments as "alarming". | Ibrahim Mogra, of the Muslim Council of Britain's inter-faith relations committee, described the bishop's comments as "alarming". |
He said: "If there is no evidence he can put forward then it boils down to simple scaremongering. | He said: "If there is no evidence he can put forward then it boils down to simple scaremongering. |
"It is very worrying if parts of our country become no-go areas for anybody, and it is not acceptable. | "It is very worrying if parts of our country become no-go areas for anybody, and it is not acceptable. |
"To suggest that a handful of people are beginning to create such areas where nobody else can go unless they are Muslim needs evidence to back such claims." | "To suggest that a handful of people are beginning to create such areas where nobody else can go unless they are Muslim needs evidence to back such claims." |
Akbar Ali, a Muslim community leader in Liverpool, said Dr Nazir-Ali was not being helpful. | Akbar Ali, a Muslim community leader in Liverpool, said Dr Nazir-Ali was not being helpful. |
He told BBC News: "This is something new I'm hearing. I'm sure when the Bishop of Rochester says something he has done his initial research to make such a pronouncement. | He told BBC News: "This is something new I'm hearing. I'm sure when the Bishop of Rochester says something he has done his initial research to make such a pronouncement. |
"But I would have thought that giving publicity to such radical views really makes the situation worse rather than better." | "But I would have thought that giving publicity to such radical views really makes the situation worse rather than better." |