This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/7161177.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Malaysia court rejects Hindu bid | Malaysia court rejects Hindu bid |
(about 1 hour later) | |
A Malaysian Hindu woman has failed in an attempt to stop her husband - a new convert to Islam - divorcing her in an Islamic court. | A Malaysian Hindu woman has failed in an attempt to stop her husband - a new convert to Islam - divorcing her in an Islamic court. |
Subashini Rajasingam also failed to persuade the federal court her husband should be banned from converting their four-year-old son to Islam. | Subashini Rajasingam also failed to persuade the federal court her husband should be banned from converting their four-year-old son to Islam. |
The court rejected the appeal on a technicality but added that she would be able to try again in a few months. | The court rejected the appeal on a technicality but added that she would be able to try again in a few months. |
Religious rights are a sensitive issue in Malaysia which is 60% Muslim. | Religious rights are a sensitive issue in Malaysia which is 60% Muslim. |
But there are also large Hindu, Christian and Buddhist communities - mainly drawn from the ethnic Indian and Chinese minorities - who fear for their rights. | |
Giving ground? | Giving ground? |
Malaysian law leaves family matters to Islamic Sharia courts when both parties are Muslim. Non-Muslim matters are dealt with by civil courts. | Malaysian law leaves family matters to Islamic Sharia courts when both parties are Muslim. Non-Muslim matters are dealt with by civil courts. |
But there has been a series of cases in recent months where civil courts have appeared to give ground to Sharia courts. | But there has been a series of cases in recent months where civil courts have appeared to give ground to Sharia courts. |
The latest case started when Subashini's husband - then called Saravanan Thangthoray - announced last year that he was converting to Islam. | The latest case started when Subashini's husband - then called Saravanan Thangthoray - announced last year that he was converting to Islam. |
This has created some confusion. We don't know what impact this will have K. Shanmuga, lawyer | This has created some confusion. We don't know what impact this will have K. Shanmuga, lawyer |
He said he wanted to divorce her in a Sharia court, which he would also ask to rule which parent their sons, aged four and two, should live with. | He said he wanted to divorce her in a Sharia court, which he would also ask to rule which parent their sons, aged four and two, should live with. |
Subashini wanted the matter dealt with by a civil court instead, and asked the federal court to step in. | Subashini wanted the matter dealt with by a civil court instead, and asked the federal court to step in. |
The court declined to give a ruling, saying she should have waited until three months after her husband's conversion before making her application. Her lawyers say she will now do so again. | The court declined to give a ruling, saying she should have waited until three months after her husband's conversion before making her application. Her lawyers say she will now do so again. |
Lawyers are still puzzling over the ramifications of the judgement, which some are calling contradictory. | Lawyers are still puzzling over the ramifications of the judgement, which some are calling contradictory. |
The judges said that in principle, this case should still be dealt with by the civil courts. But they also said that as a Muslim, the husband had the right to apply to a Sharia court. | The judges said that in principle, this case should still be dealt with by the civil courts. But they also said that as a Muslim, the husband had the right to apply to a Sharia court. |
They also said that the two types of court have equal status in Malaysia. | They also said that the two types of court have equal status in Malaysia. |
"This has created some confusion. We don't know what impact this will have," said Subashini's lawyer K. Shanmuga. | "This has created some confusion. We don't know what impact this will have," said Subashini's lawyer K. Shanmuga. |
Previous version
1
Next version