This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/sep/16/independent-scotland-nhs-budget-cuts-alistair-darling
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Independent Scotland will face NHS budget cuts, says Alistair Darling | Independent Scotland will face NHS budget cuts, says Alistair Darling |
| (8 months later) | |
| Voting no to independence is critical to the future of the health service in Scotland, Alistair Darling has said, in a direct challenge to one of the yes campaign's most successful arguments with voters. | Voting no to independence is critical to the future of the health service in Scotland, Alistair Darling has said, in a direct challenge to one of the yes campaign's most successful arguments with voters. |
| The leader of the pro-union Better Together campaign said new powers for the Scottish parliament, which would be set in train the day after a no vote, would result in a stronger, more secure health service. Those powers would enable Holyrood to raise extra money to spend on the NHS as well as borrow more to build hospitals and facilities for the elderly. | The leader of the pro-union Better Together campaign said new powers for the Scottish parliament, which would be set in train the day after a no vote, would result in a stronger, more secure health service. Those powers would enable Holyrood to raise extra money to spend on the NHS as well as borrow more to build hospitals and facilities for the elderly. |
| Speaking on BBC Radio Scotland, Darling attacked what has been one of the main planks of the pro-independence campaign in recent weeks, that a yes vote is the only way the protect the NHS in Scotland from Westminster's cuts and privatisation. | Speaking on BBC Radio Scotland, Darling attacked what has been one of the main planks of the pro-independence campaign in recent weeks, that a yes vote is the only way the protect the NHS in Scotland from Westminster's cuts and privatisation. |
| Referring to confidential papers passed to the BBC which suggest the NHS in Scotland is facing a funding gap of more than £400m and that sweeping cuts will be needed for health boards to break even, Darling said: "Today we learned that [Scottish National party leader and deputy] Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon have been deceiving us. I find that quite appalling. | Referring to confidential papers passed to the BBC which suggest the NHS in Scotland is facing a funding gap of more than £400m and that sweeping cuts will be needed for health boards to break even, Darling said: "Today we learned that [Scottish National party leader and deputy] Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon have been deceiving us. I find that quite appalling. |
| "After all these scare stories [about privatisation] they've known that these cuts are coming along, but we weren't going to be told about it until after the polls had closed," he told the Good Morning Scotland show. | "After all these scare stories [about privatisation] they've known that these cuts are coming along, but we weren't going to be told about it until after the polls had closed," he told the Good Morning Scotland show. |
| The papers were passed to the BBC by a senior NHS whistleblower, who said they had become frustrated by claims from the yes campaign that the greatest threat to the NHS came from the UK government. | The papers were passed to the BBC by a senior NHS whistleblower, who said they had become frustrated by claims from the yes campaign that the greatest threat to the NHS came from the UK government. |
| Darling was speaking after the leaders of the UK's three main political parties signed a pledge to give more powers to Scotland if it rejects independence. The prime minister, David Cameron, his deputy, Nick Clegg, and the Labour leader, Ed Miliband, signed a letter that appeared on the front page of Tuesday's Daily Record newspaper. The letter also guaranteed the continuation of the Barnett funding formula. | |
| Asked if it was possible to trust the pledge when Westminster priorities could change after the next general election, and in particular if Clegg could be believed after his U-turn on his university tuition fees pledge, Darling said the same arguments were made in 1997 around the formation of the Scottish parliament and had proved to be without foundation. | Asked if it was possible to trust the pledge when Westminster priorities could change after the next general election, and in particular if Clegg could be believed after his U-turn on his university tuition fees pledge, Darling said the same arguments were made in 1997 around the formation of the Scottish parliament and had proved to be without foundation. |
| Speaking on the same programme, Salmond said it was "absolutely untrue" that there would be cuts to the NHS budget in Scotland, describing Darling's argument as "totally mythical, totally made up and meant to misrepresent the situation". | Speaking on the same programme, Salmond said it was "absolutely untrue" that there would be cuts to the NHS budget in Scotland, describing Darling's argument as "totally mythical, totally made up and meant to misrepresent the situation". |
| Asked directly about the cuts suggested in the leaked papers, Salmond insisted that the figures referred to efficiency savings that would be ploughed back into the health service. | Asked directly about the cuts suggested in the leaked papers, Salmond insisted that the figures referred to efficiency savings that would be ploughed back into the health service. |
| "This paper makes the point that we've been making throughout the campaign. Unless we control the overall finances of the health service we'll be left with the invidious position that even increasing health service spending in real terms, we're faced with this appalling choice of having to increase taxation to fund the health service instead of making a real choice not to waste billions on nuclear weapons." | "This paper makes the point that we've been making throughout the campaign. Unless we control the overall finances of the health service we'll be left with the invidious position that even increasing health service spending in real terms, we're faced with this appalling choice of having to increase taxation to fund the health service instead of making a real choice not to waste billions on nuclear weapons." |
| He said a yes vote would mean Scotland would control its own finances "to enable us to protect our health service not only in real terms but meet these funding pressures for the future". | He said a yes vote would mean Scotland would control its own finances "to enable us to protect our health service not only in real terms but meet these funding pressures for the future". |
| Last week the Institute for Fiscal Studies published an analysis which revealed that the Scottish government was planning to make cuts in health spending even though NHS budgets were rising in England. It showed planned cuts of 1.2% in Scotland in 2015-16, compared with an increase of 4.4% in England, despite overall public spending cuts of 13%. |