This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/magazine/7115821.stm
The article has changed 10 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| What can't be named Muhammad? | What can't be named Muhammad? |
| (40 minutes later) | |
| WHO, WHAT, WHY? The Magazine answers... | WHO, WHAT, WHY? The Magazine answers... |
| A teddy on sale in SudanBritish teacher Gillian Gibbons stands accused of insulting Islam's Prophet after allowing her pupils in Sudan to name a teddy bear Muhammad. What are the rules on using the name? | A teddy on sale in SudanBritish teacher Gillian Gibbons stands accused of insulting Islam's Prophet after allowing her pupils in Sudan to name a teddy bear Muhammad. What are the rules on using the name? |
| The Arabic name Muhammad, with its 14 different spellings in English, is now the second most popular name for baby boys in Britain. | The Arabic name Muhammad, with its 14 different spellings in English, is now the second most popular name for baby boys in Britain. |
| Muslim families - of which there are an increasing number in the UK - often choose names which honour the Prophet or show a link to their religion in another way. | Muslim families - of which there are an increasing number in the UK - often choose names which honour the Prophet or show a link to their religion in another way. |
| THE ANSWER Opinion is dividedSome say Muhammad can only be given to boys, others are less strict But is it acceptable to name a toy Muhammad? The arrest of Ms Gibbons has sparked debate in Islamic circles. As is the case in so many religious matters, the question is open to interpretation. | THE ANSWER Opinion is dividedSome say Muhammad can only be given to boys, others are less strict But is it acceptable to name a toy Muhammad? The arrest of Ms Gibbons has sparked debate in Islamic circles. As is the case in so many religious matters, the question is open to interpretation. |
| The issue has been a vexed one for Muslims through the ages. Some believe that the name can only be given to boys - to give it to an object is idolatry. Others say that pets and toys can bear the name. | The issue has been a vexed one for Muslims through the ages. Some believe that the name can only be given to boys - to give it to an object is idolatry. Others say that pets and toys can bear the name. |
| Ibrahim Mogra, chairman of the interfaith Muslim Public Affairs Committee and an imam in Leicester, says the name should be reserved for boys. "Some of us believe we are assured of heaven if we name our children Muhammad." | Ibrahim Mogra, chairman of the interfaith Muslim Public Affairs Committee and an imam in Leicester, says the name should be reserved for boys. "Some of us believe we are assured of heaven if we name our children Muhammad." |
| But he says it's ridiculous that Ms Gibbons is being punished for a "miscalculation". | But he says it's ridiculous that Ms Gibbons is being punished for a "miscalculation". |
| Gillian Gibbons asked her class to name the bear "If someone clearly intends to insult and cause offence with a toy in the form of a pig, for example, and someone knowingly and intentionally names it Muhammad, we know exactly where they're going with it - the idea is to cause offence. If it's just a miscalculation, we don't need to go overboard." | Gillian Gibbons asked her class to name the bear "If someone clearly intends to insult and cause offence with a toy in the form of a pig, for example, and someone knowingly and intentionally names it Muhammad, we know exactly where they're going with it - the idea is to cause offence. If it's just a miscalculation, we don't need to go overboard." |
| Dilwar Hussain, of the Islamic Foundation, has no problem with a teddy bear called Muhammad. For some years, the Islamic Society sold a soft toy made for British Muslim children named Adam the Prayer Bear. "Adam is also the name of a Prophet." | Dilwar Hussain, of the Islamic Foundation, has no problem with a teddy bear called Muhammad. For some years, the Islamic Society sold a soft toy made for British Muslim children named Adam the Prayer Bear. "Adam is also the name of a Prophet." |
| Would it be acceptable to give a religious name to a pet? In much of the Muslim world, he says, animals are seen as functional and so are rarely given names. | Would it be acceptable to give a religious name to a pet? In much of the Muslim world, he says, animals are seen as functional and so are rarely given names. |
| Idolatry | Idolatry |
| But Adel Darwish, the political editor of The Middle East magazine, says that Muslim children - "like children everywhere" - give their pets the names of characters they liked, be it a religious figure, sports hero or pop singer. | But Adel Darwish, the political editor of The Middle East magazine, says that Muslim children - "like children everywhere" - give their pets the names of characters they liked, be it a religious figure, sports hero or pop singer. |
| WHO, WHAT, WHY? A regular part of the BBC News Magazine, Who, What, Why? aims to answer some of the questions behind the headlines "Millions of Muslim children in Muslim nations give their dolls, pets and teddies Muslim names of the Prophet and his mother, daughters and wives." | WHO, WHAT, WHY? A regular part of the BBC News Magazine, Who, What, Why? aims to answer some of the questions behind the headlines "Millions of Muslim children in Muslim nations give their dolls, pets and teddies Muslim names of the Prophet and his mother, daughters and wives." |
| Gill Lusk, the associate editor of Africa Confidential and a specialist on Sudan, says the incident will have offended many in the country. As Sudan is a place where religion is never mocked or satirised, it's "unthinkable" that a toy or pet could be given a religious name. | Gill Lusk, the associate editor of Africa Confidential and a specialist on Sudan, says the incident will have offended many in the country. As Sudan is a place where religion is never mocked or satirised, it's "unthinkable" that a toy or pet could be given a religious name. |
| "You're not supposed to give a religious name to any objects - it could be seen as idolatry." | "You're not supposed to give a religious name to any objects - it could be seen as idolatry." |
| But the majority of Sudanese people won't want to see Ms Gibbons in trouble for the naming of the teddy bear. | But the majority of Sudanese people won't want to see Ms Gibbons in trouble for the naming of the teddy bear. |
| "People are very forgiving of foreigners, particularly Europeans. Nobody would think she was trying to offend them - they would just think she was ignorant." | "People are very forgiving of foreigners, particularly Europeans. Nobody would think she was trying to offend them - they would just think she was ignorant." |
| Add your comments on this story, using the form below. | |
| This matter has been blown out of proportion, whilst some Muslims may be outraged, I attribute their outrage to narrow minded and misguided teaching. Why can this toy not be named, as was chosen by the school children? Muhammad is a common name in most Muslim communities; there was no intention to used the toy as a representation of the Prophet Muhammad, so the question of idolatry does not arise at all. | |
| Islam, like other religions, has been misused time and again by tyrants, unscrupulous politician and terrorists, but in fact the religion is, like all others, founded on the concept of fairness, openness, peace, and harmony, not oppression, closed mindedness, fighting, fear and discord. I sincerely hope this that matter is quickly and sensibly resolved and Ms.Gillian Gibbons is released unharmed and unconditionally. Abdul Karim, Seremban, Malaysia. | |
| Its a hard one. Its so obviously unintentional and it does seem like they have over-reacted but when you go to another country, you should live by their rules, however strict they may be. But saying that, how many people come here and live by our rules? Kelly Chandler, London, UK | |
| Without wishing to cause offence here, but am I missing something? I thought it was the children that named the teddy bear, not the teacher. I think that as it is highly unlikely that the teacher is/was responsible for the religous education of these children, then how can she be held responsible for their choice of name for the bear? If this choice of name is seen to be offensive, then surely is it the children's religous educators who are at fault?Laurence, Worcester | |
| What is ridiculous about this is that the children named the bear! If it was such an obvious taboo then why were the children not aware of it? And why the drama of an arrest? Surely a parent could have simply said something to the teacher or the school and it could have been easily resolved internally?Shelley Green, London | |
| This woman might have made a mistake, as you claimed, by allowing her pupils to name the teddy Muhammad. It's however not fair to say that her action is ok or permissible. We should know that what she's done is wrong even if she did it by mistake. We should therefore stop blaming those who arrested her but should convince them that she did it not with any bad intention.Ademola Mustapha, Ibadan, Nigeria | |
| This is utterly ridiculous. It goes to show the full extent of how primitive, medieval and wholly unacceptable many branches of Islam are. There is no place in the modern world for this kind of backwards thinking. It's a Teddy bear. The child named it. ID, London, UK | |
| I wish that those in the Muslim community who stand for moderation, reason and logic would stand up and be counted as oppposed to letting the extremists always have their voice Martin Reynolds, Dundalk | |
| I am a mid-thirties liberal Christian and yet I wonder how I would react if the teacher of my children named a toy bear Jesus. All innocence aside it just doesn't seem the right thing to do.Jonathon, Brisbane, Australia | |
| Im really not sure why this is such a big issue... In fact i think its getting to a slightly pathetic stage... not helped by the media frenzy around the topic as it gives them yet another opportunity to start screaming about fundamentalists... oh sorry cant use that now can we... BBC's favourite new term is Islamist..N Akram, London UK | |
| This is a sad indictment of the Muslim faith, and demonstrates precisely why this and other faiths attract fundamentalism. For intelligent grown adults to protest about a completely harmless action such as this is unfathomable. Clearly there is a lot of progress needed before the world becomes a truly global community which respects difference and is tolerant of others who do not conform.Eddie, Warrington | |
| "People are very forgiving of foreigners, particularly Europeans. Nobody would think she was trying to offend them - they would just think she was ignorant." How jolly good of them, woe betide us foolish, ignorant Europeans.Alex Hendy, Bristol | |