Fifa ticket official says Ray Whelan arrest was case of mistaken identity

http://www.theguardian.com/football/2014/jul/21/fifa-tickets-ray-whelan-arrest

Version 0 of 1.

The chairman of Fifa’s World Cup ticket and hospitality partner, Match, has described the accusations against his company’s chief executive, Ray Whelan, now languishing in a Brazilian prison as part of an investigation into a $100m touting operation, as without foundation.

In an interview with the Guardian Jaime Byrom, who is also Whelan’s brother-in-law, suggested police in Rio de Janeiro may have a case of mistaken identity in their evidence against him.

Whelan is alleged to have been part of an operation involved in the illegal resale of hospitality tickets and VIP passes for matches at the World Cup and is being held in Bangu prison in Rio after surrendering himself to a judge in the city last week. Rio police had described Whelan as a fugitive after he allegedly fled his luxury hotel following his initial arrest.

Police said they recorded 900 calls between Whelan and the Algerian ticket broker Lamine Fofana from the start of the World Cup on 12 June and that virtually all of them referred to the selling of tickets. Fofana is one of 12 people accused by Rio state prosecutors of engaging in criminal activity relating to ticket touting.

Byrom has offered a different version of events. Most significantly he has disputed claims that Whelan was involved in the phone calls with Fofana on the basis that the police have said that the individual concerned resides in Geneva and speaks French.

A phone recording released to the Brazilian media had the 64-year-old Whelan, speaking in English, trying to sell a package of corporate tickets to Fofana. Byrom claimed there is nothing wrong with the resale of hospitality tickets through official channels.

“What’s interesting is the one recording we have heard of any conversation alleged to have been taken between Ray and Mr Fofana,” Byrom said. “In that conversation the only thing it shows is the authorities thought that would incriminate Ray when in fact it does not do so. On the contrary it shows that Ray is attempting to sell a standard programme under standard terms of business to Mr Fofana. That is basically it.

“The continued assertion by the authorities that Ray had 900 calls with Mr Fofana failed to explain why it is that Ray would be the person they consider as part of these discussions when, as I say, Ray has not been in Switzerland for 18 months, Ray does not speak French and even in that conversation between Mr Fofana and Ray, it is conducted in English. You hear very clearly the nature of that discussion.

“If the police is right in saying there is an individual who resides in Geneva, speaks French or has had 900 calls with Mr Fofana, presumably to do with tickets, it cannot be Ray for the simple reason that he has not been there and he does not speak French.”

Byrom, who created Match with his brother Enrique, questioned why the authorities have not released their evidence when doing so would allow his company to aid the investigation and he feels there has been so much attention on Whelan because of the high-profile nature of the case.

“You may recall that when they arrested Ray they referred to the 82 tickets they found in his bedroom,” Byrom said. “If you look at the 82 tickets, you find that some were for matches that had already taken place. All of them, whether for previous matches or for future matches, were the property of Ray, Match Hospitality or Match Services. They are tickets we can prove belonged to either Ray or the company. They were very specific tickets. They were tickets for the Match Hospitality private suite which we kept at the Maracanã for family members as well as for directors and shareholders of the company.

“They have mentioned the number, which was correct, but they have not provided the details of the specific tickets. Had the police made a statement as to the specific tickets that they have collected, we would have been able to provide the seat references that link it to a purchase that was provided by Match Hospitality and Match Services, relating to this contract between Match Services and Match Hospitality.”

The investigation has the potential to be embarrassing for Fifa. Match Hospitality has a number of shareholders including Infront Sports & Media, whose chief executive is the nephew of the Fifa president, Sepp Blatter. Fifa sold hospitality rights for the 2010 and 2014 World Cups to Match for $240m and has a $300m deal in place with them for the next two tournaments as well.

“Our relationship with Fifa goes back over 20 years,” Byrom said. “We have worked for Fifa for 20 years. Not once has there been any indication or any incident that would compromise our relationship with Fifa, especially in the area of ticketing.

“If there was ever an instance when someone within Match was involved in unauthorised activities and if we had failed to identify such an activity, then certainly I would not need to be asked by Fifa to stop being responsible for enforcement. A ticketing company in the position Fifa has placed us in needs above all to have integrity.”