This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-28190261
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
The rot in India's primary education | The rot in India's primary education |
(about 5 hours later) | |
When authorities in India's Bihar state began a mass recruitment of primary school teachers in 2003, many believed it would lead to an improvement in the quality of education. | When authorities in India's Bihar state began a mass recruitment of primary school teachers in 2003, many believed it would lead to an improvement in the quality of education. |
Bihar's primary schools did not have enough teachers, so the new recruits were welcomed. | Bihar's primary schools did not have enough teachers, so the new recruits were welcomed. |
To fill in the hundreds of thousands of vacancies, the appointment rules were relaxed - the teachers were hired on presentation of degree certificates verified by the city or village council officials and they did not have to write any competitive examination. | |
Known as "contract teachers", these new recruits are paid just 25% of a regular teacher's salary of 40,000 rupees ($666; £389) a month. | Known as "contract teachers", these new recruits are paid just 25% of a regular teacher's salary of 40,000 rupees ($666; £389) a month. |
More than a decade later, things look relatively better on paper - some 417,000 teachers, a majority of them (362,000) hired in the last decade, are employed with 73,000 primary schools. | More than a decade later, things look relatively better on paper - some 417,000 teachers, a majority of them (362,000) hired in the last decade, are employed with 73,000 primary schools. |
But the reality is much grimmer: news washed up recently that more than 20,000 of the new recruits had forged their degree certificates to get their jobs. Authorities have already dismissed 779 teachers after investigation. | But the reality is much grimmer: news washed up recently that more than 20,000 of the new recruits had forged their degree certificates to get their jobs. Authorities have already dismissed 779 teachers after investigation. |
Senior education department official Ram Sharnagat told the BBC that they had received complaints against 52,000 teachers for submitting fake certificates. | Senior education department official Ram Sharnagat told the BBC that they had received complaints against 52,000 teachers for submitting fake certificates. |
"We will conduct a thorough probe and those who have forged their certificates will lose their jobs," state Education Minister Brishen Patel said. | "We will conduct a thorough probe and those who have forged their certificates will lose their jobs," state Education Minister Brishen Patel said. |
Rising corruption | Rising corruption |
This is not the first time that such a scandal has hit school education in Bihar: some 15,000 teachers were dismissed in December 2008 for providing forged certificates. | This is not the first time that such a scandal has hit school education in Bihar: some 15,000 teachers were dismissed in December 2008 for providing forged certificates. |
That's not all. Education in Bihar is beset with several other problems too. Consider this: | That's not all. Education in Bihar is beset with several other problems too. Consider this: |
No wonder, say experts, Bihar has the lowest literacy rate in India - 63% against the country's average of 74%. It also has a poor teacher-student ratio with one teacher for every 63 students, against the recommended national average of one teacher for 40 students. | No wonder, say experts, Bihar has the lowest literacy rate in India - 63% against the country's average of 74%. It also has a poor teacher-student ratio with one teacher for every 63 students, against the recommended national average of one teacher for 40 students. |
Meanwhile, the contract teachers have threatened protest demonstrations if their dismissed colleagues are not reinstated. They say the government should have checked their degree certificates before hiring them. | Meanwhile, the contract teachers have threatened protest demonstrations if their dismissed colleagues are not reinstated. They say the government should have checked their degree certificates before hiring them. |
Unpaid teachers | Unpaid teachers |
"How can you sack somebody after four to five years of service for submitting forged documents," asks Puran Kumar, who heads an association of contract teachers. | "How can you sack somebody after four to five years of service for submitting forged documents," asks Puran Kumar, who heads an association of contract teachers. |
Mr Kumar said 85,000 teachers had not been paid their salaries since March. | Mr Kumar said 85,000 teachers had not been paid their salaries since March. |
Educationists say authorities should hire teachers through rigorous examinations, and not by looking at their certificates alone. | Educationists say authorities should hire teachers through rigorous examinations, and not by looking at their certificates alone. |
"Teachers must be appointed after much scrutiny of their educational qualification and talent," says Srikant, director of the Jagjivan Ram Institute for Social Research and Parliamentary Studies. | "Teachers must be appointed after much scrutiny of their educational qualification and talent," says Srikant, director of the Jagjivan Ram Institute for Social Research and Parliamentary Studies. |
"In a state like Bihar anyone can get a degree certificate by paying bribes to colleges and universities." | "In a state like Bihar anyone can get a degree certificate by paying bribes to colleges and universities." |
No wonder then that a primary school teacher in Samastipur district was caught on camera by a local news channel a few years ago telling students that there were 360 days in a year and that Patna - the capital of Bihar - was the Indian capital. | No wonder then that a primary school teacher in Samastipur district was caught on camera by a local news channel a few years ago telling students that there were 360 days in a year and that Patna - the capital of Bihar - was the Indian capital. |
She also spelt January as Junuary, apple as Apil, and education as adukesun. | She also spelt January as Junuary, apple as Apil, and education as adukesun. |
Previous version
1
Next version