This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-28283991
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Scottish independence: Law Society calls for answers in referendum campaign | Scottish independence: Law Society calls for answers in referendum campaign |
(about 11 hours later) | |
Important questions on Scotland's future remain unanswered ahead of the independence referendum, the Law Society of Scotland has said. | Important questions on Scotland's future remain unanswered ahead of the independence referendum, the Law Society of Scotland has said. |
The professional body for solicitors called on pro-independence campaigners to provide more information on the economy, currency and EU membership. | The professional body for solicitors called on pro-independence campaigners to provide more information on the economy, currency and EU membership. |
And it pressed the main pro-UK parties to spell out when more powers would be devolved to Scotland. | And it pressed the main pro-UK parties to spell out when more powers would be devolved to Scotland. |
The Society said it had a "firmly non-partisan role in the debate". | The Society said it had a "firmly non-partisan role in the debate". |
Law Society president Alistair Morris said: "It is essential that everyone is equipped with the right information so each person can make up their mind and collectively deliver a decisive result. | Law Society president Alistair Morris said: "It is essential that everyone is equipped with the right information so each person can make up their mind and collectively deliver a decisive result. |
"Yet despite much debate, a major White Paper, devolution commission reports, analysis papers and a draft Independence Bill, many of us believe important questions on Scotland's future remain unanswered. | "Yet despite much debate, a major White Paper, devolution commission reports, analysis papers and a draft Independence Bill, many of us believe important questions on Scotland's future remain unanswered. |
Joint declaration | Joint declaration |
"There continues to be uncertainty on fundamental issues including the currency we would use, EU membership, how our economy would succeed and what taxes we would pay. | "There continues to be uncertainty on fundamental issues including the currency we would use, EU membership, how our economy would succeed and what taxes we would pay. |
"There are also questions over how further devolution can and would be delivered in the event of a 'No' vote." | |
In November 2013 the Scottish government published a White Paper setting out a blueprint for an independence Scotland. | In November 2013 the Scottish government published a White Paper setting out a blueprint for an independence Scotland. |
It followed this with proposals for a draft constitution last month. | It followed this with proposals for a draft constitution last month. |
Meanwhile the Conservatives, Labour and the Liberal Democrats have set out individual proposals to devolve more powers to the Scottish Parliament if voters reject independence. | |
The parties made a joint declaration that more powers would be devolved but have not agreed a common position on what those powers would be. | |
In its own paper on Scotland's future, the Law Society argued that many questions remain to be answered by all sides in the debate, including: | In its own paper on Scotland's future, the Law Society argued that many questions remain to be answered by all sides in the debate, including: |
The Law Society also called for more information on how independence might affect Scotland's legal system and the legal profession. | The Law Society also called for more information on how independence might affect Scotland's legal system and the legal profession. |
The Scottish government has insisted that EU membership can be negotiated from within the UK before Scotland became independent 18 months after a "Yes" vote, while UK ministers have argued that membership would not be guaranteed and could take several years. | |
The finance spokesmen of the main UK parties have all said they would not share the pound in a currency union with an independent Scotland, while Scottish ministers insist their UK counterparts are bluffing. | The finance spokesmen of the main UK parties have all said they would not share the pound in a currency union with an independent Scotland, while Scottish ministers insist their UK counterparts are bluffing. |
Lib Dem MP and QC Sir Menzies Campbell, commenting on behalf of the pro-Union Better Together campaign, said: "Respected organisations, like the Law Society of Scotland, are seeing through the paper thin case for separation. | Lib Dem MP and QC Sir Menzies Campbell, commenting on behalf of the pro-Union Better Together campaign, said: "Respected organisations, like the Law Society of Scotland, are seeing through the paper thin case for separation. |
'Found wanting' | 'Found wanting' |
"On the facts and the big questions the nationalists have been found wanting - on currency, the EU, jobs and pensions. | "On the facts and the big questions the nationalists have been found wanting - on currency, the EU, jobs and pensions. |
"The only way to keep the pound and to continue to enjoy the benefits of being together is to say 'No Thanks' to separation in September." | "The only way to keep the pound and to continue to enjoy the benefits of being together is to say 'No Thanks' to separation in September." |
Joanna Cherry QC, from pro-independence group Lawyers for Yes, said: "In the White Paper and the Scottish Independence Bill and consultation on an interim constitution for Scotland, the Scottish government have provided considerable detail on their proposals. | Joanna Cherry QC, from pro-independence group Lawyers for Yes, said: "In the White Paper and the Scottish Independence Bill and consultation on an interim constitution for Scotland, the Scottish government have provided considerable detail on their proposals. |
"This is in contrast to the UK government's refusal to engage in any meaningful contingency planning, its bullying tactics over the currency and its scare stories over a range of issues. | "This is in contrast to the UK government's refusal to engage in any meaningful contingency planning, its bullying tactics over the currency and its scare stories over a range of issues. |
"In many areas, such as the currency and EU membership, we believe that the outcome of negotiations will be as much a matter of realpolitik as of law and is likely to favour the position taken by the Scottish government once there has been a 'Yes' vote." |
Previous version
1
Next version