This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/scotland/6079026.stm
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
McConnell warning on extra powers | McConnell warning on extra powers |
(about 6 hours later) | |
First Minister Jack McConnell is expected to warn that Holyrood will "subside into inertia" if MSPs continue to obsess about gaining new powers. | First Minister Jack McConnell is expected to warn that Holyrood will "subside into inertia" if MSPs continue to obsess about gaining new powers. |
Delivering a lecture on Tuesday, he will strongly endorse the existing devolved settlement. | Delivering a lecture on Tuesday, he will strongly endorse the existing devolved settlement. |
However, two leading economists have argued that the Scottish Parliament must gain more control over tax. | However, two leading economists have argued that the Scottish Parliament must gain more control over tax. |
Their report comes in the wake of the SNP, the Conservatives and the Lib Dems lobbying for more tax-varying powers. | |
Mr McConnell will argue in his speech at the annual JP Mackintosh lecture in Haddington, East Lothian, that devolution has already made a difference and that Holyrood has substantial powers related to the economy and public services. | |
He will say that MSPs should focus on those things instead of persistently demanding more powers. | He will say that MSPs should focus on those things instead of persistently demanding more powers. |
The tide of change has now engulfed the arguments for the status quo Jim Mather SNP enterprise spokesman | The tide of change has now engulfed the arguments for the status quo Jim Mather SNP enterprise spokesman |
Mr McConnell believes that otherwise the devolution settlement will sink into political paralysis. | Mr McConnell believes that otherwise the devolution settlement will sink into political paralysis. |
But the case for more tax-varying powers was being made on Tuesday by Glasgow University economist, Professor Ronald MacDonald and an American colleague, Professor Paul Hallwood, of the University of Connecticut. | |
They said that, under the current block grant from Westminster, Holyrood has no incentive to grow the economy or control spending. | |
'Better off without London' | 'Better off without London' |
The SNP believes there is enough evidence to claim that Labour is the only party which does not believe that Scotland should have control over its own revenues and spending. | The SNP believes there is enough evidence to claim that Labour is the only party which does not believe that Scotland should have control over its own revenues and spending. |
Last week a think-tank set up by the Conservatives called for Holyrood to be handed greater powers on tax-raising. | Last week a think-tank set up by the Conservatives called for Holyrood to be handed greater powers on tax-raising. |
A commission has recommended to the Lib Dems that Holyrood be responsible for raising the money it spends. | A commission has recommended to the Lib Dems that Holyrood be responsible for raising the money it spends. |
SNP enterprise spokesman Jim Mather said the paper by Prof MacDonald and Prof Hallwood heightened the case for independence. | SNP enterprise spokesman Jim Mather said the paper by Prof MacDonald and Prof Hallwood heightened the case for independence. |
The Scottish Executive gets block grant funding from Westminster | The Scottish Executive gets block grant funding from Westminster |
The academics' report in the Fraser of Allander Institute Quarterly Economic Commentary restates their case for more powers, after an earlier paper this year came in for criticism. | The academics' report in the Fraser of Allander Institute Quarterly Economic Commentary restates their case for more powers, after an earlier paper this year came in for criticism. |
The paper criticised the current funding system for not serving Scotland's economic and financial interests. | The paper criticised the current funding system for not serving Scotland's economic and financial interests. |
Mr Mather said: "The tide of change has now engulfed the arguments for the status quo. | Mr Mather said: "The tide of change has now engulfed the arguments for the status quo. |
"More and more people believe that Scotland and Scottish families will be better off without London government holding their purse strings." | "More and more people believe that Scotland and Scottish families will be better off without London government holding their purse strings." |
Think tank | Think tank |
Former Holyrood Presiding Officer Lord Steel said that a commission under his chairmanship had recommended to the Lib Dems that Holyrood be responsible for raising the money it spends. | Former Holyrood Presiding Officer Lord Steel said that a commission under his chairmanship had recommended to the Lib Dems that Holyrood be responsible for raising the money it spends. |
He said: "We were greatly influenced by the experience of Ireland in boosting their economy with taxation policies markedly different from those of Westminster." | He said: "We were greatly influenced by the experience of Ireland in boosting their economy with taxation policies markedly different from those of Westminster." |
The Conservative think tank on the issue included both Tory and non-Tory figures and was chaired by Douglas Osler, former HM senior chief inspector of education in Scotland. | The Conservative think tank on the issue included both Tory and non-Tory figures and was chaired by Douglas Osler, former HM senior chief inspector of education in Scotland. |
Its report said: "Lowering tax rates would result in higher tax income and encourages investment and innovation." | Its report said: "Lowering tax rates would result in higher tax income and encourages investment and innovation." |