This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/health/7087019.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Agreement reached in IVF claim | Agreement reached in IVF claim |
(4 days later) | |
A high-profile IVF doctor has reached an agreement over a libel complaint against the fertility watchdog. | A high-profile IVF doctor has reached an agreement over a libel complaint against the fertility watchdog. |
Mohamed Taranissi has been fighting suggestions that he offered ineffective treatments and that figures on his success rates were incorrect. | Mohamed Taranissi has been fighting suggestions that he offered ineffective treatments and that figures on his success rates were incorrect. |
In a High Court statement, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority said he was doing nothing wrong in offering such treatments. | In a High Court statement, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority said he was doing nothing wrong in offering such treatments. |
The suggestions were broadcast as part of a Panorama investigation. | The suggestions were broadcast as part of a Panorama investigation. |
Mr Taranissi also complained about material on the HFEA website about its refusal to publish the clinic's success rate figures. | Mr Taranissi also complained about material on the HFEA website about its refusal to publish the clinic's success rate figures. |
The HFEA accepts that Mr Taranissi is committed to providing the best possible outcome for his patients | The HFEA accepts that Mr Taranissi is committed to providing the best possible outcome for his patients |
The HFEA confirmed that figures showing the clinic had the highest success rate in the UK for babies born through fertility treatment were correct. | The HFEA confirmed that figures showing the clinic had the highest success rate in the UK for babies born through fertility treatment were correct. |
And added that it did not intend to criticise Mr Taranissi's clinical standards, treatment or patient care. | And added that it did not intend to criticise Mr Taranissi's clinical standards, treatment or patient care. |
Raids | Raids |
The HFEA had also carried out raids on Mr Taranissi's clinics - the Assisted Reproduction and Gynaecology Centre (ARGC) and Reproductive Genetics Institute (RGI). | The HFEA had also carried out raids on Mr Taranissi's clinics - the Assisted Reproduction and Gynaecology Centre (ARGC) and Reproductive Genetics Institute (RGI). |
In June, the High Court ruled the searches were "unlawful". | In June, the High Court ruled the searches were "unlawful". |
On the issue of reproductive immunology - the therapy that had been questioned - the HFEA statement said: "There is no conclusive evidence to show that these treatments are either beneficial or ineffective. | On the issue of reproductive immunology - the therapy that had been questioned - the HFEA statement said: "There is no conclusive evidence to show that these treatments are either beneficial or ineffective. |
"However, some doctors genuinely believe that they offer benefits for their patients, and they are doing nothing wrong in providing such tests and treatments." | "However, some doctors genuinely believe that they offer benefits for their patients, and they are doing nothing wrong in providing such tests and treatments." |
The statement added: "The HFEA accepts that Mr Taranissi is committed to providing the best possible outcome for his patients." | The statement added: "The HFEA accepts that Mr Taranissi is committed to providing the best possible outcome for his patients." |
The lawyer for Mr Taranissi welcomed the agreement and said he hoped it would lead to a better working relationship with the regulator. | The lawyer for Mr Taranissi welcomed the agreement and said he hoped it would lead to a better working relationship with the regulator. |
But an issue over the licensing of Mr Taranissi's clinics is ongoing, a HFEA spokesperson confirmed. | But an issue over the licensing of Mr Taranissi's clinics is ongoing, a HFEA spokesperson confirmed. |
In July, he was barred from being the "person responsible" for ensuring the clinics abide by the law. Mr Taranissi is appealing that decision, and retains his "person responsible" pending that appeal. | |
But he is still allowed to treat patients. | But he is still allowed to treat patients. |
Mr Taranissi is suing the BBC for libel saying that the allegations made in the Panorama programme were inaccurate. | Mr Taranissi is suing the BBC for libel saying that the allegations made in the Panorama programme were inaccurate. |
Previous version
1
Next version