This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/01/world/asia/political-stumbling-leaves-an-indian-heir-less-apparent.html
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| An Uneasy Inheritance of India’s Political Dynasty | An Uneasy Inheritance of India’s Political Dynasty |
| (about 20 hours later) | |
| NEW DELHI — On a visit to the rural constituency that has sent him or his relatives to Parliament for decades, Rahul Gandhi, the scion of India’s most powerful political dynasty, was asked a simple question: Can you name five party workers from the area? | NEW DELHI — On a visit to the rural constituency that has sent him or his relatives to Parliament for decades, Rahul Gandhi, the scion of India’s most powerful political dynasty, was asked a simple question: Can you name five party workers from the area? |
| The question, asked in a pre-election review meeting two years ago by a party worker unhappy with Mr. Gandhi’s attitude toward politics, led Mr. Gandhi to shrug and admit that he could not name anyone, said a flabbergasted Shakeel Ahmad, 60, a second-generation Indian National Congress party leader in the politically vital state of Uttar Pradesh who was at the meeting. | The question, asked in a pre-election review meeting two years ago by a party worker unhappy with Mr. Gandhi’s attitude toward politics, led Mr. Gandhi to shrug and admit that he could not name anyone, said a flabbergasted Shakeel Ahmad, 60, a second-generation Indian National Congress party leader in the politically vital state of Uttar Pradesh who was at the meeting. |
| Mr. Gandhi has represented the area since 2004, “and he does not know a single name?” Mr. Ahmad asked. Politics is the Gandhi family’s business. The clan has produced three prime ministers, including India’s first, Jawaharlal Nehru. Mr. Gandhi, long groomed for high office, seems to have inherited few of the political skills for which his forebears were renowned, Mr. Ahmad said. | Mr. Gandhi has represented the area since 2004, “and he does not know a single name?” Mr. Ahmad asked. Politics is the Gandhi family’s business. The clan has produced three prime ministers, including India’s first, Jawaharlal Nehru. Mr. Gandhi, long groomed for high office, seems to have inherited few of the political skills for which his forebears were renowned, Mr. Ahmad said. |
| “Can you teach a fish to swim?” he asked. | “Can you teach a fish to swim?” he asked. |
| The question is being asked with increasing urgency among members of the Indian National Congress, the political party that Mr. Gandhi’s family has led since India’s independence in 1947. The party is staring down what recent polls have predicted will be a landslide for the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party, a Hindu nationalist organization led by Narendra Modi, one of the most controversial political figures in Indian history. | The question is being asked with increasing urgency among members of the Indian National Congress, the political party that Mr. Gandhi’s family has led since India’s independence in 1947. The party is staring down what recent polls have predicted will be a landslide for the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party, a Hindu nationalist organization led by Narendra Modi, one of the most controversial political figures in Indian history. |
| The results of the six-week election process are scheduled to be announced on May 16. The odds of Mr. Gandhi’s becoming the next prime minister have dropped so low that Mumbai bookies have stopped taking bets on him. | The results of the six-week election process are scheduled to be announced on May 16. The odds of Mr. Gandhi’s becoming the next prime minister have dropped so low that Mumbai bookies have stopped taking bets on him. |
| Mr. Gandhi appears poised to preside over the most devastating defeat in the history of the Congress party, which has governed India for much of the past six decades. Analysts who have watched Mr. Gandhi struggle against a vast political tide as well as his own seeming ambivalence find themselves comparing him to characters in works by Shakespeare and Vyasa, the great Hindu sage. | Mr. Gandhi appears poised to preside over the most devastating defeat in the history of the Congress party, which has governed India for much of the past six decades. Analysts who have watched Mr. Gandhi struggle against a vast political tide as well as his own seeming ambivalence find themselves comparing him to characters in works by Shakespeare and Vyasa, the great Hindu sage. |
| “It is a tragic drama just like ‘Hamlet,'” said Inder Malhotra, a political columnist. “It is the end of a dynasty because this fellow cannot make up his mind. He can’t even decide whether to be clean-shaven or have a beard.” | |
| Mr. Gandhi, 43, was for years India’s absentee crown prince, a member of Parliament who rarely spoke in public, disappeared from public view for long stretches and had a reputation for partying. He was expected to replace Manmohan Singh as prime minister, but his own ennui and poor political skills led to repeated delays in his elevation, said Sanjaya Baru, a former media adviser to Mr. Singh, echoing the comments of many others. | Mr. Gandhi, 43, was for years India’s absentee crown prince, a member of Parliament who rarely spoke in public, disappeared from public view for long stretches and had a reputation for partying. He was expected to replace Manmohan Singh as prime minister, but his own ennui and poor political skills led to repeated delays in his elevation, said Sanjaya Baru, a former media adviser to Mr. Singh, echoing the comments of many others. |
| In a recent memoir, Mr. Baru said that Mr. Singh ultimately failed as a prime minister because he allowed himself to be viewed as a seat warmer for Mr. Gandhi, even though Mr. Gandhi played almost no role in the government. | In a recent memoir, Mr. Baru said that Mr. Singh ultimately failed as a prime minister because he allowed himself to be viewed as a seat warmer for Mr. Gandhi, even though Mr. Gandhi played almost no role in the government. |
| “I was at the center of power for four and a half years, and Rahul was a no-show,” Mr. Baru said in an interview. “He was not a presence.” | “I was at the center of power for four and a half years, and Rahul was a no-show,” Mr. Baru said in an interview. “He was not a presence.” |
| Then last year, Mr. Gandhi became the vice president and official prime ministerial candidate of the Congress party. His mother, Sonia Gandhi, has said at rallies that she offered up her son to the nation’s service. | Then last year, Mr. Gandhi became the vice president and official prime ministerial candidate of the Congress party. His mother, Sonia Gandhi, has said at rallies that she offered up her son to the nation’s service. |
| But Mr. Gandhi has appeared reluctant to embrace political life. He refused to call himself a candidate for prime minister, and when pressed he suggested that the reason was the assassinations of his father and grandmother. | But Mr. Gandhi has appeared reluctant to embrace political life. He refused to call himself a candidate for prime minister, and when pressed he suggested that the reason was the assassinations of his father and grandmother. |
| “In my life I have seen my grandmother die, I have seen my father die, I have seen my grandmother go to jail, and I have actually been through a tremendous amount of pain as a child,” he said in a televised interview. | “In my life I have seen my grandmother die, I have seen my father die, I have seen my grandmother go to jail, and I have actually been through a tremendous amount of pain as a child,” he said in a televised interview. |
| Those sympathetic to Mr. Gandhi say that he will not be unhappy if his party loses the election. Rasheed Kidwai, who wrote a biography of Sonia Gandhi, said that Mr. Gandhi believed that his own father, Rajiv, became prime minister too early in life and made terrible mistakes as a result. | Those sympathetic to Mr. Gandhi say that he will not be unhappy if his party loses the election. Rasheed Kidwai, who wrote a biography of Sonia Gandhi, said that Mr. Gandhi believed that his own father, Rajiv, became prime minister too early in life and made terrible mistakes as a result. |
| “From Rahul’s point of view, he is not in a great deal of hurry to become prime minister,” Mr. Kidwai said. “I think in the back of his mind, the example of his father is always there.” | “From Rahul’s point of view, he is not in a great deal of hurry to become prime minister,” Mr. Kidwai said. “I think in the back of his mind, the example of his father is always there.” |
| The Gandhi family’s latest decade-long reign atop India’s government was bound to create some anti-incumbency feelings, Mr. Gandhi said in another television interview. But the governing coalition also gave voters plenty of other reasons to want change, including a sputtering economy, a host of corruption scandals, and a weak prime minister. | The Gandhi family’s latest decade-long reign atop India’s government was bound to create some anti-incumbency feelings, Mr. Gandhi said in another television interview. But the governing coalition also gave voters plenty of other reasons to want change, including a sputtering economy, a host of corruption scandals, and a weak prime minister. |
| Congress party insiders said in interviews that to win, the party needed to tar the opposition as an unacceptable and even dangerous alternative. | Congress party insiders said in interviews that to win, the party needed to tar the opposition as an unacceptable and even dangerous alternative. |
| With Mr. Modi as the principal opponent, this strategy should have been fairly easy to execute, they said. Mr. Modi was the chief minister of Gujarat, a state in western India, when more than 1,000 people died in riots in 2002, and he has been linked through a top aide to murders of Muslims by a police assassination squad. | With Mr. Modi as the principal opponent, this strategy should have been fairly easy to execute, they said. Mr. Modi was the chief minister of Gujarat, a state in western India, when more than 1,000 people died in riots in 2002, and he has been linked through a top aide to murders of Muslims by a police assassination squad. |
| But Mr. Gandhi has until recently shied away from mounting a frontal attack on Mr. Modi’s record. He scolded Congress party leaders when they criticized Mr. Modi too sharply, and in an interview he avoided discussing the 2002 riots despite being prompted several times. | But Mr. Gandhi has until recently shied away from mounting a frontal attack on Mr. Modi’s record. He scolded Congress party leaders when they criticized Mr. Modi too sharply, and in an interview he avoided discussing the 2002 riots despite being prompted several times. |
| Leaders of the Bharatiya Janata Party can scarcely believe their good fortune. | Leaders of the Bharatiya Janata Party can scarcely believe their good fortune. |
| “We thought he was the natural inheritor,” Arun Jaitley, the leader of the opposition in Parliament’s upper house, said laughingly of Mr. Gandhi in a televised interview. “But I don’t think that’s how things are working out to be.” | “We thought he was the natural inheritor,” Arun Jaitley, the leader of the opposition in Parliament’s upper house, said laughingly of Mr. Gandhi in a televised interview. “But I don’t think that’s how things are working out to be.” |
| In recent days, with most of the nation’s voting already completed, Mr. Gandhi and his mother changed tack and finally started attacking Mr. Modi directly. But many analysts say the change has come far too late. | In recent days, with most of the nation’s voting already completed, Mr. Gandhi and his mother changed tack and finally started attacking Mr. Modi directly. But many analysts say the change has come far too late. |
| Despite the disorder in the Congress party, few are ready to write the Gandhi family’s political obituary. Indian politics are difficult to predict, and polls are often wrong. The Gandhis have long relied on votes from India’s vast numbers of rural poor, and some believe that those voters — especially the women — will still turn out in force for them. At a recent rally in Mr. Gandhi’s constituency, Amethi, a huge share of those gathered to shower him and his sister, Priyanka Vadra, with rose petals were women, which is unusual in northern Indian political gatherings. | |
| And in a culture in which many politicians serve into their 80s, Mr. Gandhi has decades to reinvent himself. | And in a culture in which many politicians serve into their 80s, Mr. Gandhi has decades to reinvent himself. |
| “Indian politics is like an unending cricket match,” said Shekhar Gupta, the editor in chief of The Indian Express. “There are always new innings.” | “Indian politics is like an unending cricket match,” said Shekhar Gupta, the editor in chief of The Indian Express. “There are always new innings.” |