This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-27217198
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Co-op Bank and Britannia merger 'should never have happened' | |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| The Co-operative Bank's merger with the Britannia building society in 2009 should never have happened, a major review of the organisation has said. | The Co-operative Bank's merger with the Britannia building society in 2009 should never have happened, a major review of the organisation has said. |
| Sir Christopher Kelly's report blames the deal for the bank's near-collapse last year. | Sir Christopher Kelly's report blames the deal for the bank's near-collapse last year. |
| His report states both companies had problems that were exacerbated by the merger. | His report states both companies had problems that were exacerbated by the merger. |
| It also points to failings in management and governance "on many levels". | It also points to failings in management and governance "on many levels". |
| Sir Christopher added the deal might have worked had the organisation received first-class leadership, but "sadly it did not". | Sir Christopher added the deal might have worked had the organisation received first-class leadership, but "sadly it did not". |
| Sir Christopher told the BBC's Radio 4 Today programme: "It is the merger [between the Co-op Bank and the Britannia], not the Britannia itself that caused the problems." | Sir Christopher told the BBC's Radio 4 Today programme: "It is the merger [between the Co-op Bank and the Britannia], not the Britannia itself that caused the problems." |
| He said both organisations brought problems to the deal. | He said both organisations brought problems to the deal. |
| In Britannia's case, it was the vast size and unwieldiness of its commercial property loan book. | In Britannia's case, it was the vast size and unwieldiness of its commercial property loan book. |
| But the Co-op Bank had several problems of its own, including its approach to risk when lending money to customers and a large IT project that was already under way, which the merger "vastly complicated". | But the Co-op Bank had several problems of its own, including its approach to risk when lending money to customers and a large IT project that was already under way, which the merger "vastly complicated". |
| Sir Christopher added that the Co-op Bank "had a legacy of mis-selling payment protection insurance (PPI), which was not unusual at the time, but is particularly disappointing for an ethical bank". | Sir Christopher added that the Co-op Bank "had a legacy of mis-selling payment protection insurance (PPI), which was not unusual at the time, but is particularly disappointing for an ethical bank". |
| Financial crisis | Financial crisis |
| Among other reasons for the near-collapse of the bank identified by the report are the economic environment following the 2008 financial crisis and the demand from financial regulators for banks to hold increased levels of capital that followed. | Among other reasons for the near-collapse of the bank identified by the report are the economic environment following the 2008 financial crisis and the demand from financial regulators for banks to hold increased levels of capital that followed. |
| Niall Booker, chief executive of the Co-operative Bank said he broadly accepted the findings of the report, which he admitted would "make difficult reading for our customers". | Niall Booker, chief executive of the Co-operative Bank said he broadly accepted the findings of the report, which he admitted would "make difficult reading for our customers". |
| But Mr Booker added: "We do believe there are many more positive aspects of the Co-operative Bank's culture that are not reflected in the report - for example, not enough credit is given to the service ethic and empathy of our employees." | But Mr Booker added: "We do believe there are many more positive aspects of the Co-operative Bank's culture that are not reflected in the report - for example, not enough credit is given to the service ethic and empathy of our employees." |
| He apologised again for "past failings" and reiterated his commitment to "restoring the bank to financial health". | He apologised again for "past failings" and reiterated his commitment to "restoring the bank to financial health". |
| Richard Pennycook, interim group chief executive of the Co-operative Group, said: "Following the wake-up call of our recently announced £2.5bn loss, Sir Christopher Kelly's report today lays bare the failings of management and governance that caused it. | Richard Pennycook, interim group chief executive of the Co-operative Group, said: "Following the wake-up call of our recently announced £2.5bn loss, Sir Christopher Kelly's report today lays bare the failings of management and governance that caused it. |
| "It is a sobering assessment which shows clearly that the Co-operative Group's loss of control of its bank could have been avoided." | "It is a sobering assessment which shows clearly that the Co-operative Group's loss of control of its bank could have been avoided." |
| Profits hit | |
| The report added that the financial crisis and the response to it by regulators and policymakers were the only factors outside the Co-op Bank's control. | |
| Unlike a number of other financial institutions, before the merger, the Co-operative Bank obtained most of funding from its own customers' deposits. | |
| As a result, it was not adversely affected when the international money markets dried up during the financial crisis and considered itself as having "weathered the crisis well". | |
| But the bank was hurt by the prolonged period of low interest rates introduced by the Bank of England, which depressed its net margins and profitability. | |
| The bank's problems were further complicated by the fact that some of its customers ran into difficulties, particularly business customers involved in commercial real estate - a market that itself all but collapsed following the financial crisis. | |
| That depressed the value of the bank's assets and made it more difficult for its clients to refinance, limiting the Co-op Bank's ability to reduce its own heavily concentrated exposure to the sector. | |
| The commercial loan book that the Co-op Bank inherited as part of its merger with Britannia stood at £3.7bn and accounted for as much as half of its lending and a greater proportion of its regulatory capital, the report added. | |
| The Co-op Bank wanted Britannia's personal customers and retail branches. But in acquiring them, it was also saddled with a "substantial volume of assets well outside its risk appetite in terms of type, loan-to-value or concentration risk". | |
| Equally troubling, for the bank and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) alike, the regulator admitted to the bank's board in July 2011 that it did not believe Britannia would have survived, had it not been for its takeover by the Co-op. |