This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/northern_ireland/7061592.stm
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 2 | Version 3 |
---|---|
Building law stays despite ruling | Building law stays despite ruling |
(about 1 hour later) | |
The controversial planning law limiting building in the countryside, PPS 14, is to stay in place, despite being ruled unlawful by a High Court judge. | The controversial planning law limiting building in the countryside, PPS 14, is to stay in place, despite being ruled unlawful by a High Court judge. |
Mr Justice Gillen ruled it was unlawful as it was introduced by the Department of Regional Development which did not have the power to do so. | Mr Justice Gillen ruled it was unlawful as it was introduced by the Department of Regional Development which did not have the power to do so. |
However, the judge decided not to overturn the law. | However, the judge decided not to overturn the law. |
Environment Minister Arlene Foster later told the assembly her department would now assume responsibility for it. | Environment Minister Arlene Foster later told the assembly her department would now assume responsibility for it. |
As a result, she said it would continue as present until it is changed in a review proposed for later this year. | As a result, she said it would continue as present until it is changed in a review proposed for later this year. |
This move had been anticipated after the High Court decision. | This move had been anticipated after the High Court decision. |
It is not clear yet what will happen to planning applications made in the period when PPS 14 was deemed to have been unlawful. | It is not clear yet what will happen to planning applications made in the period when PPS 14 was deemed to have been unlawful. |
Some or all of them may get their fees returned. | Some or all of them may get their fees returned. |
PPS 14 was introduced by the direct rule miniser Lord Rooker last year. | PPS 14 was introduced by the direct rule miniser Lord Rooker last year. |
The challenge against it was brought by Omagh District Council. | The challenge against it was brought by Omagh District Council. |
After Thursday's ruling, chairman Bert Wilson, said: "We have been fully vindicated in our decision to take this matter to court." | After Thursday's ruling, chairman Bert Wilson, said: "We have been fully vindicated in our decision to take this matter to court." |
'Opportunity' | 'Opportunity' |
"Today's declaration that the introduction of PPS 14 was unlawful now provides the opportunity for the Executive to develop a planning policy appropriate to the needs of rural communities. | "Today's declaration that the introduction of PPS 14 was unlawful now provides the opportunity for the Executive to develop a planning policy appropriate to the needs of rural communities. |
"I would urge that this opportunity is now grasped by ministers," Mr Wilson said. | "I would urge that this opportunity is now grasped by ministers," Mr Wilson said. |
He said he wanted to see all the planning applications which were "illegally" refused or withdrawn - believed to be close on 20,000 - reviewed as a matter of urgency. | He said he wanted to see all the planning applications which were "illegally" refused or withdrawn - believed to be close on 20,000 - reviewed as a matter of urgency. |
However, Friends of the Earth said it was difficult to see what the challenge had achieved. | |
"The judge has not challenged the substance of PPS 14. He has simply decided that the wrong department drafted it," the group's John Woods said. | |
"There is a growing consensus that the rapid suburbanisation of Northern Ireland's countryside is in no-one's interest." | |
Last month the High Court made a similiar ruling on PPS 14. Thursday's ruling represents its final decision. | Last month the High Court made a similiar ruling on PPS 14. Thursday's ruling represents its final decision. |