This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/world/europe/7059186.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
French parliament adopts DNA bill | French parliament adopts DNA bill |
(about 17 hours later) | |
France's parliament has passed a new bill that introduces tighter curbs on foreigners hoping to join relatives in France - including possible DNA tests. | |
The controversial bill was passed in both the country's National Assembly and in the Senate. | The controversial bill was passed in both the country's National Assembly and in the Senate. |
Supporters say it will speed up the process for genuine applicants and cite similar laws in other European nations. | Supporters say it will speed up the process for genuine applicants and cite similar laws in other European nations. |
Critics have attacked the law as racist and questioned the use of genetics as a basis for being allowed into France. | |
The bill passed by 282 votes to 235 in the lower National Assembly and by 185 votes to 136 in the upper Senate. | The bill passed by 282 votes to 235 in the lower National Assembly and by 185 votes to 136 in the upper Senate. |
It offers prospective migrants DNA tests to prove their link to relatives already living in France. | |
It also requires hopeful incomers to take a language test and show they are familiar with French values. | |
Relatives of prospective immigrants living in France must show they have adequate income to support the newcomer. | |
Court challenge | |
The bill has been hugely controversial, prompting thousands of people to take part in street protests across the country last weekend. | The bill has been hugely controversial, prompting thousands of people to take part in street protests across the country last weekend. |
The plan to offer DNA testing to would-be migrants has been the most controversial element of the new law, drawing criticism from civil rights groups and several African leaders. | |
Immigration Minister Brice Hortefeux dismissed the fears, saying 12 other European countries - including Denmark and the Netherlands - already had similar DNA testing procedures. | |
French opponents of the tests say they are reminiscent of the country's policies under Nazi occupation, which discriminated against the Jews. | |
The bill's proposals for DNA testing have already been diluted in response to some of the criticism. | |
Under the modified version passed by parliament, DNA tests will only be used in cases where children are applying to join mothers in France. | |
The tests will be voluntary rather than mandatory and will be paid for by the French government rather than by the migrant. | |
French test | |
Opponents of the bill say genetic testing is nonetheless likely to be regarded as mandatory for immigrants from certain poorer countries. | |
Civil rights groups warn that the DNA tests offered to prospective immigrants may effectively equate them with criminals, whose genetic records are already kept on police databases. | |
The opposition Socialists say human rights principles, not genetics, should determine who can get visas, and vowed to challenge the measure in the Constitutional Court. | The opposition Socialists say human rights principles, not genetics, should determine who can get visas, and vowed to challenge the measure in the Constitutional Court. |
Socialist deputy Arnaud Montebourg said: "This law violates the fundamental principles of the republic which do not define family and affiliation by biology." | Socialist deputy Arnaud Montebourg said: "This law violates the fundamental principles of the republic which do not define family and affiliation by biology." |
Communist lawmaker Patrick Braouezec said the law was "institutionalising xenophobia". | |
An opinion poll in the daily Le Parisien showed 49% supported the bill and 43% were opposed. | An opinion poll in the daily Le Parisien showed 49% supported the bill and 43% were opposed. |
Previous version
1
Next version