This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspondent/7041359.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Nicaragua's back street abortions | Nicaragua's back street abortions |
(5 days later) | |
By Jane Dreaper BBC News, Nicaragua | By Jane Dreaper BBC News, Nicaragua |
An estimated 20 million unsafe abortions are carried out every year around the world. | An estimated 20 million unsafe abortions are carried out every year around the world. |
They are a major cause of avoidable deaths among pregnant women, not least in Nicaragua where abortion is illegal. | They are a major cause of avoidable deaths among pregnant women, not least in Nicaragua where abortion is illegal. |
It is still the rainy season in the capital, Managua. Downpours are never far away, and the heat and humidity wrap around you like a blanket. | It is still the rainy season in the capital, Managua. Downpours are never far away, and the heat and humidity wrap around you like a blanket. |
Abortion became a crime for women in Nicaragua in November 2006 | Abortion became a crime for women in Nicaragua in November 2006 |
Managua is not your typical city. Ravaged by earthquakes, fire, flooding and a revolution, there are hardly any high-rise buildings, and no obvious central district. | Managua is not your typical city. Ravaged by earthquakes, fire, flooding and a revolution, there are hardly any high-rise buildings, and no obvious central district. |
Street names are non-existent, and addresses tend to be a list of directions, culminating in vital information such as "the house near the tree in the middle of the street". | Street names are non-existent, and addresses tend to be a list of directions, culminating in vital information such as "the house near the tree in the middle of the street". |
But Managua redeems itself with a beautiful green carpet of vegetation which stretches from the banks of its 40-mile-long lake up to the hills beyond. | But Managua redeems itself with a beautiful green carpet of vegetation which stretches from the banks of its 40-mile-long lake up to the hills beyond. |
Blanket ban | Blanket ban |
Nicaragua is one of Latin America's poorest countries and there is no doubt that life here is tough. | Nicaragua is one of Latin America's poorest countries and there is no doubt that life here is tough. |
There is a high rate of pregnancy among teenage girls and the health workers I spoke to mentioned significant levels of sexual abuse. | There is a high rate of pregnancy among teenage girls and the health workers I spoke to mentioned significant levels of sexual abuse. |
I had travelled here to find out about the impact of the latest restrictions on abortion in this predominantly Catholic country. | I had travelled here to find out about the impact of the latest restrictions on abortion in this predominantly Catholic country. |
A law passed a year ago makes Nicaragua one of just a handful of countries around the world with a blanket ban on abortion, even in cases of rape or when the pregnancy is endangering a woman's health. | A law passed a year ago makes Nicaragua one of just a handful of countries around the world with a blanket ban on abortion, even in cases of rape or when the pregnancy is endangering a woman's health. |
Pro-life campaigners see the law as a significant victory that illustrates what they can achieve elsewhere. | Pro-life campaigners see the law as a significant victory that illustrates what they can achieve elsewhere. |
Abortion rights activists, meanwhile, talk of the fear of prosecution among those doctors who are approached by a pregnant woman who may be suffering complications. | Abortion rights activists, meanwhile, talk of the fear of prosecution among those doctors who are approached by a pregnant woman who may be suffering complications. |
I wanted to hear about the experiences of these women. The new legislation, it appears, is not necessarily deterring those who feel they need to end their pregnancies. | I wanted to hear about the experiences of these women. The new legislation, it appears, is not necessarily deterring those who feel they need to end their pregnancies. |
I met some of the women in a suburban garden, filled with date palms, hibiscus and orange trees, the air resonating with the exotic cries and whoops of birdsong. | I met some of the women in a suburban garden, filled with date palms, hibiscus and orange trees, the air resonating with the exotic cries and whoops of birdsong. |
The surroundings may have been idyllic but I was listening to a series of increasingly grim stories. | The surroundings may have been idyllic but I was listening to a series of increasingly grim stories. |
Secrets and lies | Secrets and lies |
Twenty-year-old Carla discovered in the summer that she was pregnant again by the man who had already fathered her two-year-old. | Twenty-year-old Carla discovered in the summer that she was pregnant again by the man who had already fathered her two-year-old. |
"He drinks too much," she told me, adding that he had no sense of responsibility. | "He drinks too much," she told me, adding that he had no sense of responsibility. |
The abortion was carried out without anaesthetic and it hurt - it was like giving birth | The abortion was carried out without anaesthetic and it hurt - it was like giving birth |
Carla So she borrowed money from a friend and went to a private clinic. | Carla So she borrowed money from a friend and went to a private clinic. |
An illegal abortion can still be obtained in Nicaragua, if you can get your hands on $200 (£100). | An illegal abortion can still be obtained in Nicaragua, if you can get your hands on $200 (£100). |
"The abortion was carried out without anaesthetic and it hurt. It was like giving birth," she said. | "The abortion was carried out without anaesthetic and it hurt. It was like giving birth," she said. |
Jessica, a computer student, had a similarly painful experience. She said the doctor had seemed as scared as her. | Jessica, a computer student, had a similarly painful experience. She said the doctor had seemed as scared as her. |
Jessica lives with her father, and kept her abortion a secret from him. | Jessica lives with her father, and kept her abortion a secret from him. |
She has talked it through with a counsellor, and tries to campaign for other women now, while pursuing her own education and career aspirations. | She has talked it through with a counsellor, and tries to campaign for other women now, while pursuing her own education and career aspirations. |
I am used to interviewees sometimes being reticent about speaking into my microphone. But these women - with their neat hair, sparkly tops and fashionable jeans - relived their experiences calmly and confidently. | I am used to interviewees sometimes being reticent about speaking into my microphone. But these women - with their neat hair, sparkly tops and fashionable jeans - relived their experiences calmly and confidently. |
Gema works as a volunteer with women's rights organisations | Gema works as a volunteer with women's rights organisations |
Only afterwards I learned that they were worried that I would judge them for what had happened. | Only afterwards I learned that they were worried that I would judge them for what had happened. |
Then Gema, who works for a women's group, stepped forward to tell me about a girl who had approached her group for help several weeks earlier. | Then Gema, who works for a women's group, stepped forward to tell me about a girl who had approached her group for help several weeks earlier. |
The woman was nervous, her hands shaking. She was pregnant after being assaulted by her uncle, a drug addict. | The woman was nervous, her hands shaking. She was pregnant after being assaulted by her uncle, a drug addict. |
Ethical objections | Ethical objections |
She turned to the group in desperation, but they advised her they could not help her with an abortion because of the law. | She turned to the group in desperation, but they advised her they could not help her with an abortion because of the law. |
Her reaction was to pummel her stomach with clenched fists. | Her reaction was to pummel her stomach with clenched fists. |
Several days later, she was found dead from an overdose. | Several days later, she was found dead from an overdose. |
They know it is the wrong thing to do Dr Rafael Cabrera | They know it is the wrong thing to do Dr Rafael Cabrera |
Gema spoke of this woman's case with barely controlled anger, not least because her suicide would not be recorded as having any relation to the abortion issue. | Gema spoke of this woman's case with barely controlled anger, not least because her suicide would not be recorded as having any relation to the abortion issue. |
Earlier I had interviewed Nicaragua's leading pro-life activist, Dr Rafael Cabrera, who is also an obstetrician and gynaecologist. | Earlier I had interviewed Nicaragua's leading pro-life activist, Dr Rafael Cabrera, who is also an obstetrician and gynaecologist. |
I had put it to him that women would continue seeking abortions, whatever the law said. | I had put it to him that women would continue seeking abortions, whatever the law said. |
"But they know it is the wrong thing to do," he said. | "But they know it is the wrong thing to do," he said. |
His concern was for protecting the unborn. | His concern was for protecting the unborn. |
Was it his Catholic faith that deterred him from dispensing contraception? I asked. | Was it his Catholic faith that deterred him from dispensing contraception? I asked. |
He said it was more an ethical and scientific viewpoint and quoted studies about long-term damage from taking the pill, telling me that contraception damages a woman's maternal instincts. | He said it was more an ethical and scientific viewpoint and quoted studies about long-term damage from taking the pill, telling me that contraception damages a woman's maternal instincts. |
I tried to reflect on the bitter arguments surrounding abortion as I had a look around Managua's cathedral. | I tried to reflect on the bitter arguments surrounding abortion as I had a look around Managua's cathedral. |
A strikingly modern building, natural light pours in through a series of domes. | A strikingly modern building, natural light pours in through a series of domes. |
As a communion service was taking place inside, someone outside set off a series of fireworks, sending loud crackles through the air and breaking up the peaceful atmosphere. | As a communion service was taking place inside, someone outside set off a series of fireworks, sending loud crackles through the air and breaking up the peaceful atmosphere. |
I could not help but feel that the tensions of these fierce divisions being played out between church, state, and a poverty-stricken people were going to haunt Nicaragua for a long time to come. | I could not help but feel that the tensions of these fierce divisions being played out between church, state, and a poverty-stricken people were going to haunt Nicaragua for a long time to come. |
From Our Own Correspondent was broadcast on Saturday 13 October, 2007 at 1130 BST on BBC Radio 4. Please check the class="inlineText" href="http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspondent/3187926.stm">programme schedules for World Service transmission times. |
Previous version
1
Next version