This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/25/world/middleeast/israel-continues-to-sound-alarm-on-iranian-overture.html
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| As the New Iranian Leader Gets a Warm Reception, Israel Calls for Caution | As the New Iranian Leader Gets a Warm Reception, Israel Calls for Caution |
| (about 4 hours later) | |
| JERUSALEM — With the United States and other nations extending an increasingly warm welcome to the new president of Iran at the United Nations this week in New York, Israel finds itself in a bind: eager to unmask what it sees as an empty charm offensive, yet at risk of being seen as a spoiler unwilling to consider the possibility of change in Tehran’s nuclear policy. | JERUSALEM — With the United States and other nations extending an increasingly warm welcome to the new president of Iran at the United Nations this week in New York, Israel finds itself in a bind: eager to unmask what it sees as an empty charm offensive, yet at risk of being seen as a spoiler unwilling to consider the possibility of change in Tehran’s nuclear policy. |
| Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu ordered Israel’s delegation to boycott Tuesday’s appearance by Iran’s new president, Hassan Rouhani, at the United Nations General Assembly and later denounced Mr. Rouhani’s address there as “a cynical speech that was full of hypocrisy.” | |
| In a statement released after 2 a.m. Wednesday in Israel, Mr. Netanyahu said Iran’s strategy was “to talk and play for time in order to advance its ability to achieve nuclear weapons.” | |
| Earlier Tuesday Mr. Netanyahu expressed appreciation for President Obama’s statement in his United Nations address that “Iran’s conciliatory words will have to be matched by action that is transparent and verifiable.” Mr. Netanyahu said, “Israel would welcome a genuine diplomatic solution that truly dismantles Iran’s capacity to develop nuclear weapons.” But he said that so far Iran had offered only “cosmetic concessions.” | |
| “We will not be fooled by half-measures that merely provide a smoke screen for Iran’s continual pursuit of nuclear weapons,” Mr. Netanyahu told reporters in Tel Aviv hours before Mr. Rouhani spoke before the General Assembly. “And the world should not be fooled, either.” | “We will not be fooled by half-measures that merely provide a smoke screen for Iran’s continual pursuit of nuclear weapons,” Mr. Netanyahu told reporters in Tel Aviv hours before Mr. Rouhani spoke before the General Assembly. “And the world should not be fooled, either.” |
| Iran says its nuclear program is for civilian use, but Mr. Netanyahu and other Israeli officials point to Tehran’s recent installation of advanced centrifuges and its continued denial of access to its nuclear facilities as evidence that it is working toward such weapons. | |
| Israeli analysts have begun to worry that Mr. Netanyahu’s hard-line approach will leave him isolated by allies who want to test Mr. Rouhani’s seriousness, especially since Saudi Arabia and other Persian Gulf states that share Israel’s view have largely remained silent. | Israeli analysts have begun to worry that Mr. Netanyahu’s hard-line approach will leave him isolated by allies who want to test Mr. Rouhani’s seriousness, especially since Saudi Arabia and other Persian Gulf states that share Israel’s view have largely remained silent. |
| With Secretary of State John Kerry scheduled to meet Iran’s foreign minister on Thursday as part of the so-called P5-plus-1 group tackling the nuclear question, they said Mr. Netanyahu faced the tricky challenge of raising concerns without sounding like a prophet of doom. The P5-plus-1 powers are the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council — Britain, China, France, Russia and the United States — plus Germany. | With Secretary of State John Kerry scheduled to meet Iran’s foreign minister on Thursday as part of the so-called P5-plus-1 group tackling the nuclear question, they said Mr. Netanyahu faced the tricky challenge of raising concerns without sounding like a prophet of doom. The P5-plus-1 powers are the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council — Britain, China, France, Russia and the United States — plus Germany. |
| “It’s a very dangerous and very awkward situation for Netanyahu to be perceived as the only naysayer and warmonger,” said Dan Gillerman, a former Israeli ambassador to the United Nations. “He has to try and find the right balance between being cautious and warning the world that it should not fall for any of these ruses, but at the same time to be seen to give it a chance and to welcome it if it happens.” | “It’s a very dangerous and very awkward situation for Netanyahu to be perceived as the only naysayer and warmonger,” said Dan Gillerman, a former Israeli ambassador to the United Nations. “He has to try and find the right balance between being cautious and warning the world that it should not fall for any of these ruses, but at the same time to be seen to give it a chance and to welcome it if it happens.” |
| Dan Meridor, a veteran Israeli minister who was a moderating influence in Mr. Netanyahu’s previous cabinet, said a better strategy would be for Israel to “speak positively” about Iran’s new leadership, invoking a Hebrew phrase that means “respect him and suspect him.” | Dan Meridor, a veteran Israeli minister who was a moderating influence in Mr. Netanyahu’s previous cabinet, said a better strategy would be for Israel to “speak positively” about Iran’s new leadership, invoking a Hebrew phrase that means “respect him and suspect him.” |
| Efraim Halevy, a former chief of the Israeli intelligence agency Mossad and a former national security adviser, said the prime minister would do better not to “personalize” the situation, because “demeaning somebody doesn’t do anything useful.” | Efraim Halevy, a former chief of the Israeli intelligence agency Mossad and a former national security adviser, said the prime minister would do better not to “personalize” the situation, because “demeaning somebody doesn’t do anything useful.” |
| In some ways, the current dynamic echoes what some saw as an effective good cop/bad cop dynamic last year, when Mr. Netanyahu and his defense minister repeatedly raised the specter of an Israeli military strike on Iran’s nuclear facilities as the White House urged more time for diplomacy and sanctions to take effect. But after a year in which Jerusalem and Washington had been more aligned on Iran, some now worry that Mr. Rouhani’s diplomatic offensive and the relative embrace it has received could revive the momentum for a unilateral Israeli strike. | In some ways, the current dynamic echoes what some saw as an effective good cop/bad cop dynamic last year, when Mr. Netanyahu and his defense minister repeatedly raised the specter of an Israeli military strike on Iran’s nuclear facilities as the White House urged more time for diplomacy and sanctions to take effect. But after a year in which Jerusalem and Washington had been more aligned on Iran, some now worry that Mr. Rouhani’s diplomatic offensive and the relative embrace it has received could revive the momentum for a unilateral Israeli strike. |
| Instead, several experts suggested, Mr. Netanyahu could take credit for helping to bring Iran to the negotiating table. | Instead, several experts suggested, Mr. Netanyahu could take credit for helping to bring Iran to the negotiating table. |
| “The process was meant to be pressure; isolation, military and economic; until the day comes you will see the Iranian leadership trying to climb down from this track — maybe that’s what we’re seeing,” Mr. Meridor said. “Don’t be too positive, but welcome the open arms of the United States, not just to be nice and to hug, but to see whether they will take the ladder to step down. Don’t say no.” | “The process was meant to be pressure; isolation, military and economic; until the day comes you will see the Iranian leadership trying to climb down from this track — maybe that’s what we’re seeing,” Mr. Meridor said. “Don’t be too positive, but welcome the open arms of the United States, not just to be nice and to hug, but to see whether they will take the ladder to step down. Don’t say no.” |
| The challenge was made more difficult by the fact that Mr. Netanyahu on Tuesday was 5,000 miles away from United Nations headquarters. Mr. Netanyahu, himself a former United Nations ambassador who has made expert use of the General Assembly stage, chose not to attend the opening day of the annual session to avoid traveling during the Jewish holidays this week, Shemini Atzeret and Simhat Torah. He is scheduled to meet with Mr. Obama on Monday and address the United Nations on Tuesday. | The challenge was made more difficult by the fact that Mr. Netanyahu on Tuesday was 5,000 miles away from United Nations headquarters. Mr. Netanyahu, himself a former United Nations ambassador who has made expert use of the General Assembly stage, chose not to attend the opening day of the annual session to avoid traveling during the Jewish holidays this week, Shemini Atzeret and Simhat Torah. He is scheduled to meet with Mr. Obama on Monday and address the United Nations on Tuesday. |
| Israel’s delegation in New York was instructed to skip Mr. Rouhani’s speech because of what the prime minister’s office described as Iran’s denial of the Holocaust and calls for Israel’s destruction. That prompted criticism from Israel’s centrist finance minister, Yair Lapid, who said it was “reminiscent of the way Arab states behave toward Israel” and cautioned, “Israel shouldn’t be portrayed as a serial objector to negotiations uninterested in peaceful solutions,” according to Ynet, an Israeli news Web site. | Israel’s delegation in New York was instructed to skip Mr. Rouhani’s speech because of what the prime minister’s office described as Iran’s denial of the Holocaust and calls for Israel’s destruction. That prompted criticism from Israel’s centrist finance minister, Yair Lapid, who said it was “reminiscent of the way Arab states behave toward Israel” and cautioned, “Israel shouldn’t be portrayed as a serial objector to negotiations uninterested in peaceful solutions,” according to Ynet, an Israeli news Web site. |
| Separately, Israeli officials urged a charismatic rabbi and mystic who had been asked by an American businessman to meet with the Iranian president this week not to do so, according to Yossi Elituv, an Israeli journalist who works with the rabbi, Yoshiyahu Yosef Pinto. The Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported Monday that a group of Iranian-American Jews had also rebuffed an invitation to meet the Iranian president and foreign minister. | Separately, Israeli officials urged a charismatic rabbi and mystic who had been asked by an American businessman to meet with the Iranian president this week not to do so, according to Yossi Elituv, an Israeli journalist who works with the rabbi, Yoshiyahu Yosef Pinto. The Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported Monday that a group of Iranian-American Jews had also rebuffed an invitation to meet the Iranian president and foreign minister. |
| Supporters of Mr. Netanyahu’s approach said it was important not to get caught up in the theater of Mr. Rouhani’s New York tour, and to focus instead on the situation in Iran. They pointed to reports by the International Atomic Energy Agency showing continued uranium enrichment, moves toward plutonium development and research on warheads, as well as a military parade where Mr. Rouhani spoke. | Supporters of Mr. Netanyahu’s approach said it was important not to get caught up in the theater of Mr. Rouhani’s New York tour, and to focus instead on the situation in Iran. They pointed to reports by the International Atomic Energy Agency showing continued uranium enrichment, moves toward plutonium development and research on warheads, as well as a military parade where Mr. Rouhani spoke. |
| “The notion of Rouhani as a breath of fresh air does not fit with the continuing Iranian concealment efforts,” said Dore Gold, another former Israeli ambassador to the United Nations, who now heads the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs. “You have to tell the truth, and that’s what the prime minister of Israel does: he tells the truth about what’s going on in Iran.” | “The notion of Rouhani as a breath of fresh air does not fit with the continuing Iranian concealment efforts,” said Dore Gold, another former Israeli ambassador to the United Nations, who now heads the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs. “You have to tell the truth, and that’s what the prime minister of Israel does: he tells the truth about what’s going on in Iran.” |
| But Ari Shavit, a Haaretz columnist who was in the United States this week, said there was a wide gap in perception between the United States and Israel. Mr. Shavit, who has written extensively about the issue, said that while Mr. Netanyahu had “intellectually won the debate” over Iran’s nuclear ambitions, “he totally lost the world.” | But Ari Shavit, a Haaretz columnist who was in the United States this week, said there was a wide gap in perception between the United States and Israel. Mr. Shavit, who has written extensively about the issue, said that while Mr. Netanyahu had “intellectually won the debate” over Iran’s nuclear ambitions, “he totally lost the world.” |
| “Being perceived as in a bunkerlike mentality does not persuade people,” he said. “He should say the truth, but he should really find a way of giving it a new color so people would listen.” | “Being perceived as in a bunkerlike mentality does not persuade people,” he said. “He should say the truth, but he should really find a way of giving it a new color so people would listen.” |
Isabel Kershner contributed reporting. | Isabel Kershner contributed reporting. |