National service? I'll fight to prevent my son being forced to do it

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/sep/24/national-service-son-philip-hollobone

Version 0 of 1.

As an art teacher I understand the difficulty of painting a picture with one brush, yet this is what Philip Hollobone MP is asking us to do by introducing a bill that proposes compulsory national service for all young people aged 18-26.

He is saying that all young people are out of work, getting into trouble, have no respect for themselves or others, are illiterate and lacking basic education. They can neither cook, nor look smart nor handle their finances or even understand basic laws.

He is telling us that we need to threaten these young people with a criminal record if they don't complete a one-year service that has compulsory residential requirements, away from home, their jobs, responsibilities and families. He thinks they need to be forced to do "good" deeds like charity work or to work for the NHS, emergency services or the military.

As a mother of a six-year-old son, I find it unbelievable that a representative of our government could discriminate against such a large percentage of our population, with this one-size-fits-all approach. That is why I launched a petition to stop the national service bill in its tracks.

My main concern is the 700,000 young carers who will not be exempt from the bill. Who will care for their relative while they serve, with social services cut dramatically and disability benefits cut by more than 20%?

What happens to pregnant mothers, also not exempt, or to children, if both young parents have to serve at the same time, or to those of single parents? They could be left with no choice but to rely on the system to care for their children, a system that is at breaking point because of cuts, with the possibility of losing their child to the system.

And what about those young people who will not be exempt on grounds of mental health or disability exemption but might still have significant disabilities. Will the support be in place to accommodate these people?

And what about the bill's lack of exemption for those in full-time education or in work, meaning some young people may have to leave a well-paid jobs to do minimum-wage work, or leave university or college to comply, potentially having a devastating effect on their carer paths and prospects.

Some argue that we need compulsory national service to tackle youth unemployment, but unemployment is highest among 16- and 17-year-olds, and the bill doesn't include them. Much of the proposed "help" this bill offers, such as educational support, finance and cooking skills can and should be taught at home and in school. The idea that self-respect, respect for others, and discipline can be enforced through this is absurd. The freedoms that this bill tramples over, from equality to many of the articles of the Human Rights Act, seem to have been completely ignored.

If a compulsory national service comes in, my son may one day be expected to abandon his chosen carer path, job, children and family life, to spend time taking a paid job in the NHS, the emergency services or military.

Thankfully I have the support of more than 30,000 people who have so far signed my petition.

Unfortunately, Hollobone has suggested that his supporters now sign it too to try to secure a debate in parliament. If my petition reaches 100,000 signatures, he believes it will give his a bill a three-hour debate. Otherwise he fears it won't be debated because there isn't not enough parliamentary time.

This seems underhand and devious. I'm really disappointed that an MP would try to undermine my democratic voice in this debate. I started something in good faith and he is running scared, but I'm sticking to my guns. The comments on the petition are unanimous that national service is a terrible idea, so it doesn't look his supporters, if he has any, are flocking to say otherwise.

• This article was commissioned following a suggestion made by PaulJB. If there's a subject you'd like to see covered on Comment is free, please visit our You Tell Us page

Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning.