This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/20/world/middleeast/iran-said-to-seek-a-nuclear-accord-to-end-sanctions.html
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Iran Said to Seek a Nuclear Accord to End Sanctions | Iran Said to Seek a Nuclear Accord to End Sanctions |
| (37 minutes later) | |
| TEHRAN — Iran’s leaders seized on perceived flexibility in a private letter from President Obama and have decided to gamble on forging a grand bargain over their nuclear program to end crippling sanctions, a prominent adviser to the Iranian leadership said on Thursday. | TEHRAN — Iran’s leaders seized on perceived flexibility in a private letter from President Obama and have decided to gamble on forging a grand bargain over their nuclear program to end crippling sanctions, a prominent adviser to the Iranian leadership said on Thursday. |
| The adviser, who participated in top-level discussions of the country’s diplomatic strategy, said that Mr. Obama’s letter, delivered to Iran’s new president, Hassan Rouhani, about three weeks ago, promised relief from sanctions if Tehran demonstrated a willingness to “cooperate with the international community, keep your commitments and remove ambiguities.” The text of the letter has not been made public but the adviser described its contents in an interview in his office on Thursday. | The adviser, who participated in top-level discussions of the country’s diplomatic strategy, said that Mr. Obama’s letter, delivered to Iran’s new president, Hassan Rouhani, about three weeks ago, promised relief from sanctions if Tehran demonstrated a willingness to “cooperate with the international community, keep your commitments and remove ambiguities.” The text of the letter has not been made public but the adviser described its contents in an interview in his office on Thursday. |
| The adviser and other officials and analysts said Iran was focused on getting quick relief from financial sanctions that have cut it off from the international banking system, possibly in exchange for curbs on the Iranian nuclear enrichment program. Some in the leadership are also worried that if nuclear talks do not yield quick results, Iran’s hard-line clerics and military men — currently sidelined — could attack Mr. Rouhani as a sellout and clip his political wings. | The adviser and other officials and analysts said Iran was focused on getting quick relief from financial sanctions that have cut it off from the international banking system, possibly in exchange for curbs on the Iranian nuclear enrichment program. Some in the leadership are also worried that if nuclear talks do not yield quick results, Iran’s hard-line clerics and military men — currently sidelined — could attack Mr. Rouhani as a sellout and clip his political wings. |
| A senior American official did not dispute the general outlines of the letter as described by Amir Mohebbian, an Iranian political expert and longtime adviser to Iran’s top leaders. But the official said Mr. Obama had not promised Iran quick relief from sanctions, insisting that they would be lifted only as a result of negotiations over Iran’s nuclear activities. | |
| The Iranian leadership was encouraged by what they said was Mr. Obama’s offer to conduct face-to-face talks, which they prefer to the more bureaucratic and lengthy negotiating process with a group of five major world powers, Mr. Mohebbian said. | The Iranian leadership was encouraged by what they said was Mr. Obama’s offer to conduct face-to-face talks, which they prefer to the more bureaucratic and lengthy negotiating process with a group of five major world powers, Mr. Mohebbian said. |
| The one-and-a-half-page letter, which the Iranian president answered with a letter of similar length, has kindled hopes that the international charm offensive Iran began after Mr. Rouhani’s election in June may produce a genuine diplomatic breakthrough. But the differing interpretations of Mr. Obama’s letter in Tehran and Washington are a reminder of the political hurdles and the legacy of mistrust that both sides will have to overcome in negotiating a deal. | The one-and-a-half-page letter, which the Iranian president answered with a letter of similar length, has kindled hopes that the international charm offensive Iran began after Mr. Rouhani’s election in June may produce a genuine diplomatic breakthrough. But the differing interpretations of Mr. Obama’s letter in Tehran and Washington are a reminder of the political hurdles and the legacy of mistrust that both sides will have to overcome in negotiating a deal. |
| The American official said Mr. Obama had congratulated Mr. Rouhani on his election, and characterized the vote as an opportunity for change. But the official was adamant that Mr. Obama made no promises about immediate, or even quick, relief from the sanctions. | The American official said Mr. Obama had congratulated Mr. Rouhani on his election, and characterized the vote as an opportunity for change. But the official was adamant that Mr. Obama made no promises about immediate, or even quick, relief from the sanctions. |
| The Iranians, he said, were inferring that from the president’s general pledge to resolve issues and move forward. And while Mr. Obama said he was open to direct talks, the official said, those talks would not necessarily be leader to leader. | The Iranians, he said, were inferring that from the president’s general pledge to resolve issues and move forward. And while Mr. Obama said he was open to direct talks, the official said, those talks would not necessarily be leader to leader. |
| The Iranian reaction to the letter provides critical insight into a decisive and unexpected shift in strategy by the moderate new president as Iran struggles to restore vitality to its economy and undo years of hostile relations with most of the world under the former president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. | The Iranian reaction to the letter provides critical insight into a decisive and unexpected shift in strategy by the moderate new president as Iran struggles to restore vitality to its economy and undo years of hostile relations with most of the world under the former president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. |
| The overtures to the United States are part of a flurry of steps altering the trajectory of the Iranian state, including domestic liberalizations and the return of the politically powerful military back to the barracks — for now. Those concrete actions, along with the changed tone of its diplomacy, have convinced some analysts that the changes are more than cosmetic. | The overtures to the United States are part of a flurry of steps altering the trajectory of the Iranian state, including domestic liberalizations and the return of the politically powerful military back to the barracks — for now. Those concrete actions, along with the changed tone of its diplomacy, have convinced some analysts that the changes are more than cosmetic. |
| Mr. Rouhani will present Iran’s new face to world next week with an address to the United Nations General Assembly, an evening speech to the Council on Foreign Relations and the Asia Society, and a television interview with Charlie Rose. | Mr. Rouhani will present Iran’s new face to world next week with an address to the United Nations General Assembly, an evening speech to the Council on Foreign Relations and the Asia Society, and a television interview with Charlie Rose. |
| Skeptics were quick to point out that Mr. Obama has reached out to Iran before. Having promised as a candidate to extend an olive branch to old enemies, he sent a letter early in his first term to Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, proposing a new diplomatic chapter. Mr. Khamenei sent a reply, but failed to take Mr. Obama up on his offer. | |
| Their correspondence was cut short after Iran’s disputed presidential election in June 2009 unleashed a popular uprising. The ensuing bloody crackdown all but snuffed out diplomacy for the next year. Mr. Ahmadinejad, re-elected as president, wrote a lengthy letter to Mr. Obama in 2010, but it did nothing to break the diplomatic ice. | Their correspondence was cut short after Iran’s disputed presidential election in June 2009 unleashed a popular uprising. The ensuing bloody crackdown all but snuffed out diplomacy for the next year. Mr. Ahmadinejad, re-elected as president, wrote a lengthy letter to Mr. Obama in 2010, but it did nothing to break the diplomatic ice. |
| This time Mr. Obama’s letter found a receptive audience, which apparently, and crucially, includes for the first time Ayatollah Khamenei. Mr. Mohebbian said he had been present at an official meeting of the leadership at which the letter was read aloud and discussed by someone from “the highest levels” of Iran’s political establishment, terminology that usually describes the office of the supreme leader. . | This time Mr. Obama’s letter found a receptive audience, which apparently, and crucially, includes for the first time Ayatollah Khamenei. Mr. Mohebbian said he had been present at an official meeting of the leadership at which the letter was read aloud and discussed by someone from “the highest levels” of Iran’s political establishment, terminology that usually describes the office of the supreme leader. . |
| Mr. Mohebbian, who often acts as a political commentator for foreign media, published parts of the letter on Tuesday on one of the 20 Web sites he runs in Iran, called secretnews.ir. | Mr. Mohebbian, who often acts as a political commentator for foreign media, published parts of the letter on Tuesday on one of the 20 Web sites he runs in Iran, called secretnews.ir. |
| Mr. Mohebbian said the Iranian leadership was generally receptive to the letter except for one line in which Mr. Obama complimented President Rouhani as “the representative of the Iranian people, not of the totalitarian leaders.” | Mr. Mohebbian said the Iranian leadership was generally receptive to the letter except for one line in which Mr. Obama complimented President Rouhani as “the representative of the Iranian people, not of the totalitarian leaders.” |
| This is the first time Mr. Obama has written directly to an Iranian president, and not the supreme leader, suggesting that the White House believes Ayatollah Khamenei has empowered Mr. Rouhani to seek an opening with the West. | This is the first time Mr. Obama has written directly to an Iranian president, and not the supreme leader, suggesting that the White House believes Ayatollah Khamenei has empowered Mr. Rouhani to seek an opening with the West. |
| In a sharp break with previous letter exchanges both presidents have publicly lauded their correspondence. Mr. Rouhani said in an NBC News interview broadcast on Wednesday that the tone of Mr. Obama’s letter was “positive and constructive.” He added, “It could be subtle and tiny steps for a very important future.” | In a sharp break with previous letter exchanges both presidents have publicly lauded their correspondence. Mr. Rouhani said in an NBC News interview broadcast on Wednesday that the tone of Mr. Obama’s letter was “positive and constructive.” He added, “It could be subtle and tiny steps for a very important future.” |
| Mr. Obama, speaking to the Spanish-language network Telemundo on Tuesday, said there were indications that Mr. Rouhani “is somebody who is looking to open dialogue with the West and with the United States, in a way that we haven’t seen in the past. And so we should test it.” | Mr. Obama, speaking to the Spanish-language network Telemundo on Tuesday, said there were indications that Mr. Rouhani “is somebody who is looking to open dialogue with the West and with the United States, in a way that we haven’t seen in the past. And so we should test it.” |
| In his reply to Mr. Obama, Mr. Rouhani said that public opinion in Iran did not favor talks, Mr. Mohebbian said. Iran’s president urged Mr. Obama to “prepare the grounds for successful negotiations” with a gesture of good faith. | In his reply to Mr. Obama, Mr. Rouhani said that public opinion in Iran did not favor talks, Mr. Mohebbian said. Iran’s president urged Mr. Obama to “prepare the grounds for successful negotiations” with a gesture of good faith. |
| The American official said that while Mr. Rouhani was frank about policy differences with the United States, his letter, too, had a different tone — less the list of grievances that he said characterized letters from Mr. Khamenei or Mr. Ahmadinejad. | The American official said that while Mr. Rouhani was frank about policy differences with the United States, his letter, too, had a different tone — less the list of grievances that he said characterized letters from Mr. Khamenei or Mr. Ahmadinejad. |
| Iran’s leaders are apparently convinced that the next six months, before campaigning begins for parliamentary elections in March, represent the best opportunity to reach a nuclear agreement in over a decade, Mr. Mohebbian said. | Iran’s leaders are apparently convinced that the next six months, before campaigning begins for parliamentary elections in March, represent the best opportunity to reach a nuclear agreement in over a decade, Mr. Mohebbian said. |
| The leaders considered the tone of Mr. Obama’s letter a very promising sign, and paradoxically, they view what they see as America’s declining regional influence as a positive. Mr. Rouhani has publicly applauded Mr. Obama’s decision to refrain from striking Syria for its poison gas attack on its own civilians. | The leaders considered the tone of Mr. Obama’s letter a very promising sign, and paradoxically, they view what they see as America’s declining regional influence as a positive. Mr. Rouhani has publicly applauded Mr. Obama’s decision to refrain from striking Syria for its poison gas attack on its own civilians. |
| Mr. Mohebbian said Ayatollah Khamenei had been growing concerned about the future of the revolution, with so many of its founders aging. In particular, he wants to settle the nuclear issue and ease tensions with the United States. | Mr. Mohebbian said Ayatollah Khamenei had been growing concerned about the future of the revolution, with so many of its founders aging. In particular, he wants to settle the nuclear issue and ease tensions with the United States. |
| “It is the leader who decides on the possibility, scope and extent of potential talks with the U.S.,” said Mr. Mohebbian. He stressed that Ayatollah Khamenei was in excellent health, “But we need him to reach consensus within our system, he feels this is the moment to try and solve this problem.” | “It is the leader who decides on the possibility, scope and extent of potential talks with the U.S.,” said Mr. Mohebbian. He stressed that Ayatollah Khamenei was in excellent health, “But we need him to reach consensus within our system, he feels this is the moment to try and solve this problem.” |
| The leadership is also desperate to escape the withering financial sanctions imposed in recent years, particularly the ban on Iranian money transfers through the Swift system. It can live without oil sales, analysts have said, but not without the ability to transfer money. | The leadership is also desperate to escape the withering financial sanctions imposed in recent years, particularly the ban on Iranian money transfers through the Swift system. It can live without oil sales, analysts have said, but not without the ability to transfer money. |
| Mr. Mohebbian said Iran is hoping the White House will lift some sanctions as a gesture to show its seriousness about the talks. “We particularly want to be readmitted to the Swift system,” he said. | Mr. Mohebbian said Iran is hoping the White House will lift some sanctions as a gesture to show its seriousness about the talks. “We particularly want to be readmitted to the Swift system,” he said. |
| He and other analysts warned that while Iran’s political establishment is currently in full agreement that talks are worth a try, the consensus could break down within months if there are no results. | He and other analysts warned that while Iran’s political establishment is currently in full agreement that talks are worth a try, the consensus could break down within months if there are no results. |
| “The world must know that time is not unlimited for solving the nuclear problem,” Mr. Rouhani said in his first live TV interview on Iranian state television, on September 10. | “The world must know that time is not unlimited for solving the nuclear problem,” Mr. Rouhani said in his first live TV interview on Iranian state television, on September 10. |
| At the White House, where Mr. Obama has long sought a rapprochement with Iran but been repeatedly frustrated, officials share the sense that this time may be different. | At the White House, where Mr. Obama has long sought a rapprochement with Iran but been repeatedly frustrated, officials share the sense that this time may be different. |
| “Rouhani is sending signals he wants to deal,” said Dennis B. Ross, a former adviser to Mr. Obama on Iran. “He wants to end the sanctions and knows he does not have a lot of time to deliver — Iranian presidents have some space in their first year and then it declines.” | “Rouhani is sending signals he wants to deal,” said Dennis B. Ross, a former adviser to Mr. Obama on Iran. “He wants to end the sanctions and knows he does not have a lot of time to deliver — Iranian presidents have some space in their first year and then it declines.” |
Thomas Erdbrink reported from Tehran, and Mark Landler from Washington. | Thomas Erdbrink reported from Tehran, and Mark Landler from Washington. |