This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/06/syrian-presidency-instagram-banality-evil
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| The Syrian presidency's Instagram account shows the banality of evil | The Syrian presidency's Instagram account shows the banality of evil |
| (12 days later) | |
| Asma al-Assad looks poised and fragrant as she ladles food out of a vast silvery bowl to children who wait patiently for their portion. The first lady of Syria is dressed down for the occasion in a pale blue blouse, caught in an ethereal white light as she tends to the needs of her people. The woman is a saint. | Asma al-Assad looks poised and fragrant as she ladles food out of a vast silvery bowl to children who wait patiently for their portion. The first lady of Syria is dressed down for the occasion in a pale blue blouse, caught in an ethereal white light as she tends to the needs of her people. The woman is a saint. |
| In another photograph she sits on the ground with girls in Guide-like uniforms, and in another, she gives a little girl a new doll. She chats and smiles with grateful (and perhaps nervous) recipients of her bounty, in touchy-feely pictures that show her physically touching the poor and disabled. | In another photograph she sits on the ground with girls in Guide-like uniforms, and in another, she gives a little girl a new doll. She chats and smiles with grateful (and perhaps nervous) recipients of her bounty, in touchy-feely pictures that show her physically touching the poor and disabled. |
| These are some of the images from the daily rounds of the wife of president Bashar al-Assad that are puzzling a world riven by debate about claims that Assad used sarin gas in an attack on his people in the suburbs of Damascus on 21 August. While the Syrian regime's responsibilty for the attack is disputed by Russia, China, Ed Miliband and many more who refuse to accept US accusations at face value, reactions to these photographs have been pretty much a universal "ugh". From Israel's Haaretz to Britain's Daily Mail, the bland, Hello-like images of Asma al-Assad posing with little conviction as a friend of the people while her husband's civil war with rebels is devastating the country seem to strike most observers as "shameless" and grotesque. | These are some of the images from the daily rounds of the wife of president Bashar al-Assad that are puzzling a world riven by debate about claims that Assad used sarin gas in an attack on his people in the suburbs of Damascus on 21 August. While the Syrian regime's responsibilty for the attack is disputed by Russia, China, Ed Miliband and many more who refuse to accept US accusations at face value, reactions to these photographs have been pretty much a universal "ugh". From Israel's Haaretz to Britain's Daily Mail, the bland, Hello-like images of Asma al-Assad posing with little conviction as a friend of the people while her husband's civil war with rebels is devastating the country seem to strike most observers as "shameless" and grotesque. |
| The smiling, sun-kissed world of the Assads – while she does charity work, he holds decorous meetings with dignitaries – come from the Syrian presidency's Instagram account. The hugely popular photography site and app allows users to display and share pictures in a visually seductive way. You can see the temptation for Assad to use this benign tool for propaganda. But his Instagram smilorama appears to be backfiring: while argument rages over his alleged use of poison gas, his Instagram is drawing sneers. Perhaps the UN could even agree to condemn its bad taste. | The smiling, sun-kissed world of the Assads – while she does charity work, he holds decorous meetings with dignitaries – come from the Syrian presidency's Instagram account. The hugely popular photography site and app allows users to display and share pictures in a visually seductive way. You can see the temptation for Assad to use this benign tool for propaganda. But his Instagram smilorama appears to be backfiring: while argument rages over his alleged use of poison gas, his Instagram is drawing sneers. Perhaps the UN could even agree to condemn its bad taste. |
| It's no laughing matter. In a curious way, these pictures of Asma al-Assad reveal the truth about Syria. Their blatant phoney quality – the first lady serving hot lunches while in reality Assad's forces have been accused of targeting bakeries, and refugees are streaming hungry for the borders – allows us to recognise the embattled Syrian regime for what it is. They stir a sinister sense of recognition, for who has not heard of the banality of evil? | It's no laughing matter. In a curious way, these pictures of Asma al-Assad reveal the truth about Syria. Their blatant phoney quality – the first lady serving hot lunches while in reality Assad's forces have been accused of targeting bakeries, and refugees are streaming hungry for the borders – allows us to recognise the embattled Syrian regime for what it is. They stir a sinister sense of recognition, for who has not heard of the banality of evil? |
| The war in Syria has been made easier for Bashar al-Assad by powerfully enforced reporting restrictions. The death of the renowned war reporter Marie Colvin in Homs in February 2012 sent out a powerful message (it is unclear whether she and the other reporters killed or injured with her were deliberately targeted) about how hard it would be to get the truth from this killing zone. Many images of horror have come out of Syria since, but have to be examined carefully. Was a video that surfaced on YouTube early in the war, in which the cameraman observes a sniper at work until he is shot himself as the gun turns on him, an authentic piece of citizen reporting? | The war in Syria has been made easier for Bashar al-Assad by powerfully enforced reporting restrictions. The death of the renowned war reporter Marie Colvin in Homs in February 2012 sent out a powerful message (it is unclear whether she and the other reporters killed or injured with her were deliberately targeted) about how hard it would be to get the truth from this killing zone. Many images of horror have come out of Syria since, but have to be examined carefully. Was a video that surfaced on YouTube early in the war, in which the cameraman observes a sniper at work until he is shot himself as the gun turns on him, an authentic piece of citizen reporting? |
| Reality has proved easy to destroy in Syria. Facts are hard to come by and have to be peered at through a bloody fog. The old adage that truth is the first casualty of war has never been more brutally proven – because Bashar al-Assad attacked truth from the start. As the civil war – we called it a rebellion then – started in 2011, he simply banned most foreign journalists from Syria. This is such a familiar fact it may seem obtuse to restate it. Yet it is no coincidence that two years into the conflict, international onlookers are debating fundamental issues of fact and evidence, with many people giving Assad the benefit of the doubt on last month's chemical attack. | Reality has proved easy to destroy in Syria. Facts are hard to come by and have to be peered at through a bloody fog. The old adage that truth is the first casualty of war has never been more brutally proven – because Bashar al-Assad attacked truth from the start. As the civil war – we called it a rebellion then – started in 2011, he simply banned most foreign journalists from Syria. This is such a familiar fact it may seem obtuse to restate it. Yet it is no coincidence that two years into the conflict, international onlookers are debating fundamental issues of fact and evidence, with many people giving Assad the benefit of the doubt on last month's chemical attack. |
| Amid this uneasy global debate, Assad's Instagram comes as a luminous portrait of the ruler, his marriage and lifestyle. It is a glittering triumph of banality. The Assads really seem to believe that they are the perfect couple, the dashing man of power and his beautiful and gracious first lady. | Amid this uneasy global debate, Assad's Instagram comes as a luminous portrait of the ruler, his marriage and lifestyle. It is a glittering triumph of banality. The Assads really seem to believe that they are the perfect couple, the dashing man of power and his beautiful and gracious first lady. |
| It's too simplistic to describe these images as "propaganda". Propaganda for whom? Can the regime really think pictures of Asma al-Assad meeting the people will efface dead bodies, blasted cities and homeless children? It can only appear monstrous to outsiders to see this myth of a sanitised Syria promoted by a government at war with a large part of its own people. | It's too simplistic to describe these images as "propaganda". Propaganda for whom? Can the regime really think pictures of Asma al-Assad meeting the people will efface dead bodies, blasted cities and homeless children? It can only appear monstrous to outsiders to see this myth of a sanitised Syria promoted by a government at war with a large part of its own people. |
| Yet the Syrian president must think the pictures have purchase, that he can smile his way to success – and this can only be because he and his supporters drug themselves with such images. Dictators don't just fool the people. They fool themselves first. Dictators' private lives are often kitsch fantasy worlds that enable a ruler to believe in a myth that is then projected outwards and buttressed by violence. The Assad Instagram world of glossy magazine glamour is just another such self-empowering fantasy. | Yet the Syrian president must think the pictures have purchase, that he can smile his way to success – and this can only be because he and his supporters drug themselves with such images. Dictators don't just fool the people. They fool themselves first. Dictators' private lives are often kitsch fantasy worlds that enable a ruler to believe in a myth that is then projected outwards and buttressed by violence. The Assad Instagram world of glossy magazine glamour is just another such self-empowering fantasy. |
| It has something in common with the photo albums found when Libyans stormed Muammar Gaddafi's family compound. Pictures of the dictator and his children posing with pet camels mingled with Gaddafi's pictures of Condoleezza Rice. These albums – like the desert-disco decor of the Gaddafi residences – were not intended for public consumption. They were not "propaganda". The dictator himself liked to look at images of his private life that strengthened his sense of identity. | It has something in common with the photo albums found when Libyans stormed Muammar Gaddafi's family compound. Pictures of the dictator and his children posing with pet camels mingled with Gaddafi's pictures of Condoleezza Rice. These albums – like the desert-disco decor of the Gaddafi residences – were not intended for public consumption. They were not "propaganda". The dictator himself liked to look at images of his private life that strengthened his sense of identity. |
| Adolf Hitler, similarly, worked on a private fantasy of who he was. He did not conduct his affair with Eva Braun in the public eye – her existence was a secret from most Germans. Yet plenty of photographs record their relationship and celebrate the leisure life of the Führer in Bavaria and Berlin. Braun and his dog feature heavily in these eerie pictures. Both appear to have been props in his own self-image. Hitler's real relationship with Braun is a mystery – observers said he was awkward in her company. | Adolf Hitler, similarly, worked on a private fantasy of who he was. He did not conduct his affair with Eva Braun in the public eye – her existence was a secret from most Germans. Yet plenty of photographs record their relationship and celebrate the leisure life of the Führer in Bavaria and Berlin. Braun and his dog feature heavily in these eerie pictures. Both appear to have been props in his own self-image. Hitler's real relationship with Braun is a mystery – observers said he was awkward in her company. |
| No one would doubt that the Assads have a "real" marriage – but what is real in the life of dictators? In the glory days of the Arab spring, the image of dictatorship as a corrupt, abusive form of rule was widely excoriated across the Middle East and in the west. It was easy for all parties to join in portraying Gaddafi as a tyrant reminiscent of Caligula or Nero. Today, so soon, disillusionment is such that even calling Assad a "dictator" may be seen as a caricature legitimating US aggression. But the Instagram says it all. Here is a ruler just as deluded as Gaddafi, just as intoxicated with his own myth. To live in this false world is the nature of absolute rulers. | No one would doubt that the Assads have a "real" marriage – but what is real in the life of dictators? In the glory days of the Arab spring, the image of dictatorship as a corrupt, abusive form of rule was widely excoriated across the Middle East and in the west. It was easy for all parties to join in portraying Gaddafi as a tyrant reminiscent of Caligula or Nero. Today, so soon, disillusionment is such that even calling Assad a "dictator" may be seen as a caricature legitimating US aggression. But the Instagram says it all. Here is a ruler just as deluded as Gaddafi, just as intoxicated with his own myth. To live in this false world is the nature of absolute rulers. |
| The ancient Romans knew that. Their historians describe with terse fury the madness of Tiberius, hiding from the public gaze at his villa on Capri among his young sex slaves, and Nero, setting fire to Rome to clear land for a new palace. | The ancient Romans knew that. Their historians describe with terse fury the madness of Tiberius, hiding from the public gaze at his villa on Capri among his young sex slaves, and Nero, setting fire to Rome to clear land for a new palace. |
| In the 20th century Hannah Arendt, witnessing the trial of Adolf Eichmann, one of the architects of the Holocaust, coined that phrase "the banality of evil" to describe the strange emptiness and unsatisfying lumpenness of history's criminals. Assad's Instagram world is supremely banal. Rather than a Nero fiddling while Rome burns or a Hitler dreaming of architectural follies in his last days in the bunker, the Syrian president in these pictures just wants to come across as a great guy with a lovely wife. But the space between these images and the stench of war is so manifest that it reveals a true dictator's loss of touch with reality. | In the 20th century Hannah Arendt, witnessing the trial of Adolf Eichmann, one of the architects of the Holocaust, coined that phrase "the banality of evil" to describe the strange emptiness and unsatisfying lumpenness of history's criminals. Assad's Instagram world is supremely banal. Rather than a Nero fiddling while Rome burns or a Hitler dreaming of architectural follies in his last days in the bunker, the Syrian president in these pictures just wants to come across as a great guy with a lovely wife. But the space between these images and the stench of war is so manifest that it reveals a true dictator's loss of touch with reality. |
| The smiling fantasy of Assad's Instagram is blandly psychotic. It reveals a terrible gulf between reality and the ruler's fictional self-image. Banality may not be in itself a proof of evil. But in the psychology these pictures reveal, what lies are not possible? The mind that can believe in these pictures might easily order a war crime then go home to kiss his beloved wife. | The smiling fantasy of Assad's Instagram is blandly psychotic. It reveals a terrible gulf between reality and the ruler's fictional self-image. Banality may not be in itself a proof of evil. But in the psychology these pictures reveal, what lies are not possible? The mind that can believe in these pictures might easily order a war crime then go home to kiss his beloved wife. |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. | Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. |
Previous version
1
Next version