This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/05/world/americas/mexico-passes-a-softened-bill-to-evaluate-teachers.html
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Mexico Passes a Weakened Bill to Evaluate Teachers | |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| MEXICO CITY — Mexico took a major step this week toward instituting evaluations of public schoolteachers and ending their practice of buying and inheriting their posts, but analysts said violent protests by teachers had led Congress to include provisions in the new legislation that might undermine the overhaul. | MEXICO CITY — Mexico took a major step this week toward instituting evaluations of public schoolteachers and ending their practice of buying and inheriting their posts, but analysts said violent protests by teachers had led Congress to include provisions in the new legislation that might undermine the overhaul. |
| Shoring up the flagging education system has been a pillar of President Enrique Peña Nieto’s efforts to advance the country economically and move more people into the middle class. Analysts had closely watched the progress of the legislation as a sign of his ability to move forward on revamping the telecommunications and energy industries. | Shoring up the flagging education system has been a pillar of President Enrique Peña Nieto’s efforts to advance the country economically and move more people into the middle class. Analysts had closely watched the progress of the legislation as a sign of his ability to move forward on revamping the telecommunications and energy industries. |
| The series of large-scale protests by radical factions of a teachers’ union in recent weeks paralyzed parts of the capital and sent lawmakers at one point scurrying from their chambers. | The series of large-scale protests by radical factions of a teachers’ union in recent weeks paralyzed parts of the capital and sent lawmakers at one point scurrying from their chambers. |
| The pressure resulted in a series of concessions that “diluted key aspects” of the original plan, the broad outlines of which were approved in December, said Sergio Cárdenas, an education expert at CIDE, a Mexico City research university. The bill that passed Wednesday specified how that plan was to be put in effect. | The pressure resulted in a series of concessions that “diluted key aspects” of the original plan, the broad outlines of which were approved in December, said Sergio Cárdenas, an education expert at CIDE, a Mexico City research university. The bill that passed Wednesday specified how that plan was to be put in effect. |
| For the first time, teachers would undergo mandatory periodic evaluations, for example, but the detailed results would remain confidential. When the overhaul was first drafted and submitted to Congress, it did not make it explicit that evaluation results would be confidential, leading experts and some lawmakers to believe that the results would be public. Analysts are calling the confidentiality clause significant because it would deny access to information in the midst of an effort to add transparency to the teaching process. | For the first time, teachers would undergo mandatory periodic evaluations, for example, but the detailed results would remain confidential. When the overhaul was first drafted and submitted to Congress, it did not make it explicit that evaluation results would be confidential, leading experts and some lawmakers to believe that the results would be public. Analysts are calling the confidentiality clause significant because it would deny access to information in the midst of an effort to add transparency to the teaching process. |
| In addition, fired teachers would be able to appeal their cases in court, something the administration wanted to avoid. | In addition, fired teachers would be able to appeal their cases in court, something the administration wanted to avoid. |
| Still, the legislation is intended to enforce existing but often dismissed provisions, including those that mandate firing a teacher who misses a certain number of days of work. The legislation would also force the state to provide free teacher and administrator training. | Still, the legislation is intended to enforce existing but often dismissed provisions, including those that mandate firing a teacher who misses a certain number of days of work. The legislation would also force the state to provide free teacher and administrator training. |
| Overall, “it’s a first step in trying to dismantle a corrupt system,” said Marco A. Fernández, research director of México Evalúa, a public policy research group. “Unfortunately, some of the changes incorporated to the original proposal as a result of the teacher mobilizations undermine the strength of these efforts.” | Overall, “it’s a first step in trying to dismantle a corrupt system,” said Marco A. Fernández, research director of México Evalúa, a public policy research group. “Unfortunately, some of the changes incorporated to the original proposal as a result of the teacher mobilizations undermine the strength of these efforts.” |
| Teachers have complained that the overhaul left them with no job security and did little to address shortages of materials and other needs in the classroom, especially in poor regions. Some of the more vigorous protests have taken place in southern and western Mexico, where poverty is highest. | Teachers have complained that the overhaul left them with no job security and did little to address shortages of materials and other needs in the classroom, especially in poor regions. Some of the more vigorous protests have taken place in southern and western Mexico, where poverty is highest. |
| “We do need a reform, but one that stems from our basic needs,” Irais Zárate, a 51-year-old teacher from Oaxaca State, said last weekend during one of the protests. | “We do need a reform, but one that stems from our basic needs,” Irais Zárate, a 51-year-old teacher from Oaxaca State, said last weekend during one of the protests. |
| Juan Carlos Romero Hicks, president of the education commission in Congress, said the evaluations of teachers would be based in part on tests of their knowledge as well as on how their students are performing. | Juan Carlos Romero Hicks, president of the education commission in Congress, said the evaluations of teachers would be based in part on tests of their knowledge as well as on how their students are performing. |
| The president is expected to sign the legislation. | The president is expected to sign the legislation. |