This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-23595388
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Why drone attacks in Yemen are like 'trying to hit a ghost' | Why drone attacks in Yemen are like 'trying to hit a ghost' |
(12 days later) | |
US drone strikes have been effective in killing senior al-Qaeda leaders in Yemen but innocent civilians have also died, raising tensions in the impoverished and fragile country. | US drone strikes have been effective in killing senior al-Qaeda leaders in Yemen but innocent civilians have also died, raising tensions in the impoverished and fragile country. |
The streets of the coastal town of Zinjibar in southern Yemen are reduced to rubble. Buildings are bombed out. | The streets of the coastal town of Zinjibar in southern Yemen are reduced to rubble. Buildings are bombed out. |
This town was on the front line of a battle between the Yemeni army and al-Qaeda in June 2012. | This town was on the front line of a battle between the Yemeni army and al-Qaeda in June 2012. |
Government forces prevailed and one of al-Qaeda's most dangerous offshoots - al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) - slunk into the shadows. | Government forces prevailed and one of al-Qaeda's most dangerous offshoots - al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) - slunk into the shadows. |
But it remains dangerous. Al-Qaeda cells still operate here and there is also the risk of bandits who rob and kidnap. | But it remains dangerous. Al-Qaeda cells still operate here and there is also the risk of bandits who rob and kidnap. |
'They think we're rats' | 'They think we're rats' |
In a safe house with guards stationed outside, Mohammed Ahmad Bagash, a mechanic from the nearby town of Jaar, tells me his story. | In a safe house with guards stationed outside, Mohammed Ahmad Bagash, a mechanic from the nearby town of Jaar, tells me his story. |
During the fighting, al Qaeda fighters stored ammunition in the local hospital against the wishes of the doctors. | During the fighting, al Qaeda fighters stored ammunition in the local hospital against the wishes of the doctors. |
After the hospital was hit by a missile strike, Mohammed and his two children ran to a school and hid in the basement. | After the hospital was hit by a missile strike, Mohammed and his two children ran to a school and hid in the basement. |
But then the school was hit in a suspected drone strike. | But then the school was hit in a suspected drone strike. |
"It was as if everyone was burning. It was all dark," said Mr Bagash. | "It was as if everyone was burning. It was all dark," said Mr Bagash. |
"When the smoke cleared, I saw my son's leg was bleeding, and my daughter was hit on the back of the head," he said. | "When the smoke cleared, I saw my son's leg was bleeding, and my daughter was hit on the back of the head," he said. |
He carried both children out. His son survived but his eight-year-old daughter bled to death on the way to the hospital. | He carried both children out. His son survived but his eight-year-old daughter bled to death on the way to the hospital. |
"As she bled, she went yellow. She actually started to shrink in my arms," he said. | "As she bled, she went yellow. She actually started to shrink in my arms," he said. |
Several other children were injured in the attack. | Several other children were injured in the attack. |
Mr Bagash has a question for the person who ordered the drone strike: "What did my daughter ever do to them? She was only eight years old." | Mr Bagash has a question for the person who ordered the drone strike: "What did my daughter ever do to them? She was only eight years old." |
And then a bleak observation. | And then a bleak observation. |
"They think we're rats. We're not. We're human beings." | "They think we're rats. We're not. We're human beings." |
Fighting a 'ghost' | Fighting a 'ghost' |
There is little public support for al-Qaeda on the streets of Zinjibar, but plenty of anger over the strategy used to fight them. | There is little public support for al-Qaeda on the streets of Zinjibar, but plenty of anger over the strategy used to fight them. |
"Show the world. Show the world what the government has done," said one man. | "Show the world. Show the world what the government has done," said one man. |
"They bomb here but they're trying to hit a ghost." | "They bomb here but they're trying to hit a ghost." |
And then another man joins the conversation. I ask him who he blames for the destruction of his town. | And then another man joins the conversation. I ask him who he blames for the destruction of his town. |
"Al-Qaeda are responsible for this and the nations that fund them," he said. | "Al-Qaeda are responsible for this and the nations that fund them," he said. |
"But also the drones, they are killing our people, killing our children and destroying our homes. The drones don't differentiate between people. They kill people." | "But also the drones, they are killing our people, killing our children and destroying our homes. The drones don't differentiate between people. They kill people." |
Locals like Mr Bagash are caught in the middle of a battle for the heart and soul of Yemen. | Locals like Mr Bagash are caught in the middle of a battle for the heart and soul of Yemen. |
The Yemeni government, with US support, wants to eradicate al-Qaeda but since the militants live among the people, innocent civilians are also at risk. | The Yemeni government, with US support, wants to eradicate al-Qaeda but since the militants live among the people, innocent civilians are also at risk. |
Facts and figures are hard to come by as the US does not comment publicly on its drone policy, but according to the New America Foundation, a US think tank, the number of US drone strikes tripled in Yemen between 2011 and 2012. | Facts and figures are hard to come by as the US does not comment publicly on its drone policy, but according to the New America Foundation, a US think tank, the number of US drone strikes tripled in Yemen between 2011 and 2012. |
In 2012, the US carried out more drone strikes in Yemen than anywhere else. | In 2012, the US carried out more drone strikes in Yemen than anywhere else. |
It is a remote automated war for the United States where the strikes have been successful in taking out al-Qaeda's leadership. | It is a remote automated war for the United States where the strikes have been successful in taking out al-Qaeda's leadership. |
But for Yemenis, it is terror from the air. | But for Yemenis, it is terror from the air. |
Questions of legitimacy | Questions of legitimacy |
And a young Yemeni democracy campaigner has a worrying message for Washington. | And a young Yemeni democracy campaigner has a worrying message for Washington. |
"The US thinks it understands Yemen but the drones have been one of the most effective tools for AQAP to succeed in Yemen," said Farea al-Muslimi. | "The US thinks it understands Yemen but the drones have been one of the most effective tools for AQAP to succeed in Yemen," said Farea al-Muslimi. |
"A big part of al-Qaeda power at the moment is convincing Yemenis that they are in a war with America, (that) America is attacking the sovereignty of Yemen and this government is non-legitimate." | "A big part of al-Qaeda power at the moment is convincing Yemenis that they are in a war with America, (that) America is attacking the sovereignty of Yemen and this government is non-legitimate." |
Mr al-Muslimi testified in front of a US Senate committee in a personal capacity after his own village was struck by a drone. | |
He thinks the US is wrong to stay silent when civilians are being killed in targeted strikes. | He thinks the US is wrong to stay silent when civilians are being killed in targeted strikes. |
"You're killing civilians for no reason," said Mr al-Muslimi. "And you're not even going to say sorry after that or admit it, or issue an apology, or pay compensation?" | |
One man waiting for an apology is Ahmed al-Sabooly from Radda in southern Yemen. | One man waiting for an apology is Ahmed al-Sabooly from Radda in southern Yemen. |
After saying goodbye to his father, mother and sister as they left to visit the local health clinic last September, he headed out to work in the fields. | After saying goodbye to his father, mother and sister as they left to visit the local health clinic last September, he headed out to work in the fields. |
At 3pm, he heard a buzzing noise in the sky and says he saw a drone. | At 3pm, he heard a buzzing noise in the sky and says he saw a drone. |
"There was a big blast. There was another big blast and I saw dust rising in the air." | "There was a big blast. There was another big blast and I saw dust rising in the air." |
Seeking justice | Seeking justice |
He jumped on his motorbike to go see what had happened. When he got there, he found that two missiles had hit a truck. | He jumped on his motorbike to go see what had happened. When he got there, he found that two missiles had hit a truck. |
"The car was upside down and on fire. I looked in the car and I saw my mum, dad and sister," he said. | "The car was upside down and on fire. I looked in the car and I saw my mum, dad and sister," he said. |
"They were burned so badly I could see their bones. My sister was still in my mother's arms." | "They were burned so badly I could see their bones. My sister was still in my mother's arms." |
The target was probably a local al-Qaeda leader who had been seen earlier travelling on the same stretch of road. | The target was probably a local al-Qaeda leader who had been seen earlier travelling on the same stretch of road. |
Thirteen civilians were killed. | Thirteen civilians were killed. |
"My sister was so excited about going out that morning so she wore a brand new dress," said Mr al-Sabooly. | "My sister was so excited about going out that morning so she wore a brand new dress," said Mr al-Sabooly. |
"I never thought it would be the last time I saw her." | "I never thought it would be the last time I saw her." |
He blames the US government for the drone strikes. | He blames the US government for the drone strikes. |
"They're the ones who have these weapons. They're the ones who have drones hovering over our village." | "They're the ones who have these weapons. They're the ones who have drones hovering over our village." |
And Mr al-Sabooly wants justice. | And Mr al-Sabooly wants justice. |
"I want a trial and I want them prosecuted for the crimes they've committed," he said. | "I want a trial and I want them prosecuted for the crimes they've committed," he said. |
US officials conceded that Radda was a US strike in an off-the-record quote given to the Washington Post. | US officials conceded that Radda was a US strike in an off-the-record quote given to the Washington Post. |
But there was no apology and in its absence, the Yemeni government paid $75,000 in blood money to the families. | But there was no apology and in its absence, the Yemeni government paid $75,000 in blood money to the families. |
'No alternative' | 'No alternative' |
Yemen's government says all means are necessary to root out al-Qaeda, even if the US drone strikes are rallying support for the militant group. | Yemen's government says all means are necessary to root out al-Qaeda, even if the US drone strikes are rallying support for the militant group. |
"I've heard this argument, there might be some truth to it," said Foreign Minister Abu Bakr al-Qirbi. | "I've heard this argument, there might be some truth to it," said Foreign Minister Abu Bakr al-Qirbi. |
"But if your targets are al-Qaeda leaders and if they are endangering the security of your country, there's no alternative." | "But if your targets are al-Qaeda leaders and if they are endangering the security of your country, there's no alternative." |
And it seems there is no alternative for Mr Bagash or Mr al-Sabooly. | And it seems there is no alternative for Mr Bagash or Mr al-Sabooly. |
They must go about their daily lives in southern Yemen as the US tries to target the al-Qaeda militants in their midst. | They must go about their daily lives in southern Yemen as the US tries to target the al-Qaeda militants in their midst. |
"We have been living in constant fear, fear from the drone strikes, and fear from the air strikes," said Mr Bagash. | "We have been living in constant fear, fear from the drone strikes, and fear from the air strikes," said Mr Bagash. |
"You never know when your house will be hit." | "You never know when your house will be hit." |
Previous version
1
Next version