This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-23323269
The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
Trident replacement options to be published | Trident replacement options to be published |
(35 minutes later) | |
A Liberal Democrat review set up to help resolve coalition differences over replacing the UK's Trident nuclear deterrent is being published later. | A Liberal Democrat review set up to help resolve coalition differences over replacing the UK's Trident nuclear deterrent is being published later. |
The Lib Dems favour halving the number of Vanguard missile-carrying submarines to two, but the Conservatives say this would be "reckless". | |
The review has examined alternative options to like-for-like replacement. | The review has examined alternative options to like-for-like replacement. |
Its findings come as a group of former defence secretaries and military chiefs said Trident should not be downgraded. | Its findings come as a group of former defence secretaries and military chiefs said Trident should not be downgraded. |
In a letter to the Daily Telegraph, former Conservative defence secretaries Liam Fox and Sir Malcolm Rifkind, Labour's Bob Ainsworth, Lord Reid of Cardowan and Lord Robertson, together with ex-chiefs of defence staff Lord Boyce and Lord Stirrup, set out their support for like-for-like replacement by saying the government should not "take risks with our security" by downgrading Trident in an "uncertain world". | In a letter to the Daily Telegraph, former Conservative defence secretaries Liam Fox and Sir Malcolm Rifkind, Labour's Bob Ainsworth, Lord Reid of Cardowan and Lord Robertson, together with ex-chiefs of defence staff Lord Boyce and Lord Stirrup, set out their support for like-for-like replacement by saying the government should not "take risks with our security" by downgrading Trident in an "uncertain world". |
Defence Secretary Philip Hammond will present the findings of Lib Dem cabinet minister Danny Alexander's Trident Alternatives Review at 11:00 BST. | Defence Secretary Philip Hammond will present the findings of Lib Dem cabinet minister Danny Alexander's Trident Alternatives Review at 11:00 BST. |
MPs will debate them on Wednesday. | MPs will debate them on Wednesday. |
'No conclusions' | 'No conclusions' |
The UK has had a continuous at-sea nuclear deterrent, with at least one submarine on patrol at any given time, for more than 40 years and has used the Trident system since the early 1980s. | The UK has had a continuous at-sea nuclear deterrent, with at least one submarine on patrol at any given time, for more than 40 years and has used the Trident system since the early 1980s. |
The current four-submarine fleet will reach the end of its lifespan in the 2020s. | The current four-submarine fleet will reach the end of its lifespan in the 2020s. |
A final decision on whether to renew it has been delayed until 2016 amid differences between the coalition partners. | A final decision on whether to renew it has been delayed until 2016 amid differences between the coalition partners. |
The review results from a compromise reached by the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats in the 2010 coalition agreement. | The review results from a compromise reached by the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats in the 2010 coalition agreement. |
The Conservatives, who support like-for-like renewal, and the Lib Dems, who have long been sceptical, agreed to the value-for-money review to look into other options, including alternative delivery systems and a slimmed-down version of the current system. | The Conservatives, who support like-for-like renewal, and the Lib Dems, who have long been sceptical, agreed to the value-for-money review to look into other options, including alternative delivery systems and a slimmed-down version of the current system. |
But BBC defence correspondent Jonathan Beale says the review does not draw conclusions nor make specific recommendations and will sharpen the divide between the parties. | But BBC defence correspondent Jonathan Beale says the review does not draw conclusions nor make specific recommendations and will sharpen the divide between the parties. |
Critics have questioned whether the UK can continue to pay for Trident in its current form. The government estimates renewal costs will be between £15bn and £20bn but anti-nuclear campaigners say the figure will be much higher. | Critics have questioned whether the UK can continue to pay for Trident in its current form. The government estimates renewal costs will be between £15bn and £20bn but anti-nuclear campaigners say the figure will be much higher. |
The Ministry of Defence says the current cost of operating the Trident fleet is about 5% of the annual £34bn defence budget. | The Ministry of Defence says the current cost of operating the Trident fleet is about 5% of the annual £34bn defence budget. |
Mr Hammond, a Conservative, has said all possible alternatives to Trident would be "less capable, less credible and more expensive" and would not provide the same "level of protection" from external aggression. | Mr Hammond, a Conservative, has said all possible alternatives to Trident would be "less capable, less credible and more expensive" and would not provide the same "level of protection" from external aggression. |
'Nuclear ladder' | 'Nuclear ladder' |
But Lib Dem former defence minister Nick Harvey told the BBC it was time to "take some steps down the nuclear ladder" following the end of the Cold War. | But Lib Dem former defence minister Nick Harvey told the BBC it was time to "take some steps down the nuclear ladder" following the end of the Cold War. |
The review will not have any direct impact on the policy of the coalition government, which affirmed its commitment to Trident in its programme for government in 2010. | The review will not have any direct impact on the policy of the coalition government, which affirmed its commitment to Trident in its programme for government in 2010. |
But it will inform debate on future spending priorities and on Lib Dem policy in the run-up to the next election. | But it will inform debate on future spending priorities and on Lib Dem policy in the run-up to the next election. |
The Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament said cancelling Trident would bring "strategic and economic benefits" and for the government not to consider this seriously would be an "abdication of responsibility". | The Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament said cancelling Trident would bring "strategic and economic benefits" and for the government not to consider this seriously would be an "abdication of responsibility". |
Publishing an alternative review, which it says has the backing of a number of Lib Dem and Labour MPs, its general secretary Kate Hudson said not proceeding could save £100bn and give the UK "moral leadership" in global disarmament talks. | Publishing an alternative review, which it says has the backing of a number of Lib Dem and Labour MPs, its general secretary Kate Hudson said not proceeding could save £100bn and give the UK "moral leadership" in global disarmament talks. |
The letter from the former defence secretaries and defence chiefs warns the UK cannot "foresee what threats will develop over the next 30 years. Reducing our submarine-based Trident capability would weaken our national security for the sake of a very small fraction of the defence budget". | The letter from the former defence secretaries and defence chiefs warns the UK cannot "foresee what threats will develop over the next 30 years. Reducing our submarine-based Trident capability would weaken our national security for the sake of a very small fraction of the defence budget". |
They say: "It is our view that if Britain is to remain a leading global power with strong defences, nothing less than a continuous-at-sea deterrent will do." | They say: "It is our view that if Britain is to remain a leading global power with strong defences, nothing less than a continuous-at-sea deterrent will do." |