This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/devon/6994598.stm

The article has changed 14 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 9 Version 10
Whitear inquest raises questions Rachel 'may not have died alone'
(about 1 hour later)
Heroin-user Rachel Whitear could have been with someone else when she died, a jury at a second inquest into her death has concluded. Drug addict Rachel Whitear may not have given herself the injection which killed her, an inquest has concluded.
Jurors said she did die from a heroin overdose, but said they could not know whether she injected herself. A jury at the Devon hearing decided the 21-year-old died of a heroin overdose, ending seven years of uncertainty surrounding the cause of her death.
Miss Whitear, 21, was found dead at her flat in Exmouth, Devon, in May 2000. But Miss Whitear's mother Pauline Holcroft, from Herefordshire, condemned police who carried out the initial inquiry as "incompetent".
The inquest was adjourned on Thursday after a new witness came forward - but no fresh evidence emerged and the jury recorded a narrative verdict. Miss Whitear was found dead in an Exmouth flat in May 2000.
Family reaction We are sorry that Rachel's parents have had to suffer the anguish of a protracted investigation Devon and Cornwall Police Speaking at a press conference after the end of the five-day hearing in Exeter, Mrs Holcroft said: "The reason we are here at all is because of the incompetence of those officers from Devon and Cornwall Police who attended the scene when Rachel's body was discovered.
Exeter Coroner Ian Arrow said: "This death clearly attracted attention because the original medical cause of death was unascertained. We now have a medical cause of death." "We believe this was compounded by the outright negligence of the coroner, his office and the pathologist.
"The jury's findings just confirmed our greatest fear - that we may just never know who else was there when Rachel died."
Miss Whitear, a promising student at Bath Spa University, was found dead on the floor of her flat with a capped syringe in her hand.
Police at the time decided she has died of a heroin overdose and photographs of her body were used as part of an anti-drugs campaign.
An inquest in December 2000 had recorded an open verdict - but questions continued to haunt the case.
A second inquest was opened after Mss Whitear's family challenged the finding of the first hearing at the High Court.
'Attracted attention'
Exeter Coroner Ian Arrow said at the end of the latest inquest: "This death clearly attracted attention because the original medical cause of death was unascertained. We now have a medical cause of death."
He said many organisations had learned from the death of Miss Whitear and had modified procedures, which he hoped would help to promote better practices in future.He said many organisations had learned from the death of Miss Whitear and had modified procedures, which he hoped would help to promote better practices in future.
Speaking after the inquest Rachel's mother, Pauline Holcroft, said: "The jury's findings just confirmed our greatest fear - that we may just never know who else was there when Rachel died." Answering 10 questions put to them by the coroner the jury returned a narrative verdict which said Miss Whitear died from heroin intoxication and was in the habit of injecting the drug.
In the first inquest, held in 2000, the coroner recorded an open verdict. She had the necessary equipment to inject heroin but they did not know whether she was in possession of the drug or whether she injected herself with it.
The new inquest, with a different coroner, was ordered last year. If she did inject herself it happened at her bedsit in Pound Street in Exmouth on the evening of 10 May, 2000.
At a hearing in the High Court, Lord Justice Maurice Kay said the original coroner should not have released the body for burial before a post-mortem examination was carried out. If she did inject herself she did not intend to seriously injure herself, and they answered "no" to the question are you sure she intended to kill herself.
In answer to the final question, was Miss Whitear alone when she died the jury's answer was "we do not know".
Family's 'anguish'
Devon and Cornwall Police declined to comment on the criticism of its initial investigation which is being considered by police watchdog the IPCC after Wiltshire Police reinvestigated the case.
The force said in a statement: "We are sorry that Rachel's parents have had to suffer the anguish of a protracted investigation that at times must have been harrowing.
"It is our hope that today's verdict will be the start of the process that finally allows Rachel's family and friends to fully grieve her death."