This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/devon/6994598.stm
The article has changed 14 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 12 | Version 13 |
---|---|
Rachel 'may not have died alone' | Rachel 'may not have died alone' |
(20 minutes later) | |
Drug addict Rachel Whitear may not have given herself the injection which killed her, an inquest has concluded. | Drug addict Rachel Whitear may not have given herself the injection which killed her, an inquest has concluded. |
A jury at the Devon hearing decided the 21-year-old died of a heroin overdose, ending seven years of uncertainty surrounding the cause of her death. | A jury at the Devon hearing decided the 21-year-old died of a heroin overdose, ending seven years of uncertainty surrounding the cause of her death. |
But Miss Whitear's mother Pauline Holcroft, from Herefordshire, condemned police who carried out the initial inquiry as "incompetent". | But Miss Whitear's mother Pauline Holcroft, from Herefordshire, condemned police who carried out the initial inquiry as "incompetent". |
Miss Whitear was found dead in an Exmouth flat in May 2000. | Miss Whitear was found dead in an Exmouth flat in May 2000. |
We are sorry that Rachel's parents have had to suffer the anguish of a protracted investigation Devon and Cornwall Police Speaking at a press conference after the end of the five-day hearing in Exeter, Mrs Holcroft said: "The reason we are here at all is because of the incompetence of those officers from Devon and Cornwall Police who attended the scene when Rachel's body was discovered. | We are sorry that Rachel's parents have had to suffer the anguish of a protracted investigation Devon and Cornwall Police Speaking at a press conference after the end of the five-day hearing in Exeter, Mrs Holcroft said: "The reason we are here at all is because of the incompetence of those officers from Devon and Cornwall Police who attended the scene when Rachel's body was discovered. |
"We believe this was compounded by the outright negligence of the coroner, his office and the pathologist. | "We believe this was compounded by the outright negligence of the coroner, his office and the pathologist. |
"Devon and Cornwall Police made one massive assumption. They treated Rachel's death very simply as an inconsequential drugs related statistic." | "Devon and Cornwall Police made one massive assumption. They treated Rachel's death very simply as an inconsequential drugs related statistic." |
She added: "The jury's findings just confirmed our greatest fear - that we may just never know who else was there when Rachel died." | She added: "The jury's findings just confirmed our greatest fear - that we may just never know who else was there when Rachel died." |
Questions posed by death 'Modern tragedy' of Rachel | |
Miss Whitear, who had dropped out of Bath Spa University, was found dead on the floor of her flat with a capped syringe in her hand. | Miss Whitear, who had dropped out of Bath Spa University, was found dead on the floor of her flat with a capped syringe in her hand. |
Police at the time decided she had died of a heroin overdose and photographs of her body were used as part of an anti-drugs campaign. | Police at the time decided she had died of a heroin overdose and photographs of her body were used as part of an anti-drugs campaign. |
An inquest in December 2000 had recorded an open verdict after being told tests showed she did not have enough heroin in her blood to kill her. | An inquest in December 2000 had recorded an open verdict after being told tests showed she did not have enough heroin in her blood to kill her. |
But questions continued to haunt the case. | But questions continued to haunt the case. |
A second inquest was opened after Miss Whitear's family challenged the findings of the first hearing at the High Court. | A second inquest was opened after Miss Whitear's family challenged the findings of the first hearing at the High Court. |
'Attracted attention' | 'Attracted attention' |
Exeter Coroner Ian Arrow said at the end of the latest inquest: "This death clearly attracted attention because the original medical cause of death was unascertained. We now have a medical cause of death." | Exeter Coroner Ian Arrow said at the end of the latest inquest: "This death clearly attracted attention because the original medical cause of death was unascertained. We now have a medical cause of death." |
He said many organisations had learned from the death of Miss Whitear and had modified procedures, which he hoped would help to promote better practices in future. | He said many organisations had learned from the death of Miss Whitear and had modified procedures, which he hoped would help to promote better practices in future. |
Answering 10 questions put to them by the coroner the jury returned a narrative verdict which said Miss Whitear died from heroin intoxication and was in the habit of injecting the drug. | Answering 10 questions put to them by the coroner the jury returned a narrative verdict which said Miss Whitear died from heroin intoxication and was in the habit of injecting the drug. |
She had the necessary equipment to inject heroin but they did not know whether she was in possession of the drug or whether she injected herself with it. | She had the necessary equipment to inject heroin but they did not know whether she was in possession of the drug or whether she injected herself with it. |
If she did inject herself it happened at her bedsit in Pound Street in Exmouth on the evening of 10 May, 2000. | If she did inject herself it happened at her bedsit in Pound Street in Exmouth on the evening of 10 May, 2000. |
If she did inject herself she did not intend to seriously injure herself, and they answered "no" to the question are you sure she intended to kill herself. | If she did inject herself she did not intend to seriously injure herself, and they answered "no" to the question are you sure she intended to kill herself. |
Family's 'anguish' | Family's 'anguish' |
In answer to the final question, was Miss Whitear alone when she died the jury's answer was "we do not know". | In answer to the final question, was Miss Whitear alone when she died the jury's answer was "we do not know". |
Devon and Cornwall Police declined to comment on the criticism of its initial investigation which is being considered by police watchdog the IPCC after Wiltshire Police reinvestigated the case. | Devon and Cornwall Police declined to comment on the criticism of its initial investigation which is being considered by police watchdog the IPCC after Wiltshire Police reinvestigated the case. |
The force said in a statement: "We are sorry that Rachel's parents have had to suffer the anguish of a protracted investigation that at times must have been harrowing. | The force said in a statement: "We are sorry that Rachel's parents have had to suffer the anguish of a protracted investigation that at times must have been harrowing. |
"It is our hope that today's verdict will be the start of the process that finally allows Rachel's family and friends to fully grieve her death." | "It is our hope that today's verdict will be the start of the process that finally allows Rachel's family and friends to fully grieve her death." |