This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/economics-blog/2013/may/30/eurozone-retreats-austerity
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Eurozone retreats from austerity - but only as far as 'austerity lite' | Eurozone retreats from austerity - but only as far as 'austerity lite' |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| The subway workers were on strike in Lisbon on Thursday. Next month it will be the turn of the teachers. Portugal's blue-collar trade unions are gearing up to bring almost a million workers out later in the summer as the country's protest against austerity intensifies. | |
| It is a similar story across large parts of the eurozone. There have been mass protests in Madrid, Dublin and Athens against policies designed to reduce budget deficits and bring about economic reform. Now, after six successive quarters of recession, it seems the protesters have something to cheer about. Austerity in the eurozone is in retreat. | It is a similar story across large parts of the eurozone. There have been mass protests in Madrid, Dublin and Athens against policies designed to reduce budget deficits and bring about economic reform. Now, after six successive quarters of recession, it seems the protesters have something to cheer about. Austerity in the eurozone is in retreat. |
| The European commission has told six countries – France, Spain, Portugal, Poland, the Netherlands and Slovenia – that they will have up to two extra years to put their public finances in order. In truth Brussels had little choice, because weak growth had reduced tax revenues and made it impossible for exacting budget targets to be met. | |
| What's more, the commission found that it was one thing to dictate terms to the small countries on the periphery of the eurozone, but quite another to lay down the law to France, where François Hollande's loss of popularity in his first year in office surpasses that of any previous president. | What's more, the commission found that it was one thing to dictate terms to the small countries on the periphery of the eurozone, but quite another to lay down the law to France, where François Hollande's loss of popularity in his first year in office surpasses that of any previous president. |
| Economists say the case for austerity was undermined just over a month ago, when it was revealed that basic research errors in an influential paper by two Harvard economists – Carmen Reinhart and Ken Rogoff – invalidated the claim that countries suffered a growth hit when public debt rose above 90% of national income. | |
| "Many politicians in favour of austerity have quoted their work in recent years to justify their positions," said Valentijn van Nieuwenhuijzen, the head of strategy at ING Investment Management. | |
| "With that support now almost eliminated and the fairytale of expansionary austerity [on the back of magically improved confidence] being completely contradicted by the facts on the ground over the last three years, the ability of those remaining austerians to 'sell' their story to the public has been seriously damaged." | |
| Jonathan Portes, the director of the National Institute for Economic and Social Research, said: "Clearly the balance of argument in academic circles has shifted somewhat. That's partly as a result of Reinhart-Rogoff but also as a result of seeing the facts on the ground. The continued depression in parts of the eurozone means that people think austerity on its own is a doomed strategy." | Jonathan Portes, the director of the National Institute for Economic and Social Research, said: "Clearly the balance of argument in academic circles has shifted somewhat. That's partly as a result of Reinhart-Rogoff but also as a result of seeing the facts on the ground. The continued depression in parts of the eurozone means that people think austerity on its own is a doomed strategy." |
| That is certainly the view of the International Monetary Fund, which has produced research showing that the impact of austerity is greater when countries have limited scope to offset the impact of tighter fiscal policy by cutting interest rates, and when a large number of countries are cutting back at the same time. | That is certainly the view of the International Monetary Fund, which has produced research showing that the impact of austerity is greater when countries have limited scope to offset the impact of tighter fiscal policy by cutting interest rates, and when a large number of countries are cutting back at the same time. |
| Both those conditions currently apply, which explains why the IMF – spurred on by an Obama regime deeply troubled by the depression in the eurozone – has been advising member governments to ease up. Its belief that Britain is one of the countries guilty of austerity overkill explains why the Washington-based organisation advised George Osborne to counter this year's planned £10bn fiscal tightening with higher infrastructure spending and tax cuts for business. | |
| Compared with the eurozone, however, Britain has been a model of flexibility. The chancellor has pushed back the date when the UK's debt-to-GDP ratio will peak by two years, and he has allowed the economy's automatic stabilisers to work. Unlike some fellow European finance ministers, Osborne has not sought extra cuts to make good the drop in tax revenues caused by the weakness of growth, and he announced measures in the budget to support the housing market. | Compared with the eurozone, however, Britain has been a model of flexibility. The chancellor has pushed back the date when the UK's debt-to-GDP ratio will peak by two years, and he has allowed the economy's automatic stabilisers to work. Unlike some fellow European finance ministers, Osborne has not sought extra cuts to make good the drop in tax revenues caused by the weakness of growth, and he announced measures in the budget to support the housing market. |
| Frances O'Grady, the general secretary of the TUC, said: "I think it's very clear. Everybody now is talking about jobs and growth. Do I believe that's because there's been a massive change of heart? No. I think it's because they have to." | Frances O'Grady, the general secretary of the TUC, said: "I think it's very clear. Everybody now is talking about jobs and growth. Do I believe that's because there's been a massive change of heart? No. I think it's because they have to." |
| The eurozone may be coming to a similar conclusion, caused by a combination of recession, social unrest and political necessity. | The eurozone may be coming to a similar conclusion, caused by a combination of recession, social unrest and political necessity. |
| Dhaval Joshi, an economist at BCA Research, said the link between growth and austerity was clear, with a strong correlation between falling real incomes per head between 2009 and 2012 and the degree of fiscal tightening. | Dhaval Joshi, an economist at BCA Research, said the link between growth and austerity was clear, with a strong correlation between falling real incomes per head between 2009 and 2012 and the degree of fiscal tightening. |
| "Politically, austerity is no longer feasible. Well before the Italian elections in February, the Dutch government collapsed in April 2012 largely because of a disagreement over budget cuts. In France President Hollande's popularity is tanking while his grip on leftwing parliamentarians is eroding, threatening governability in the country. The opposition party in Germany, the Social Democratic Party, is pressuring Angela Merkel for concessions on austerity ahead of the September general elections." | |
| Portes is unconvinced that there has been a sea change. "What we have in the eurozone now is austerity lite. What they are doing is better than it was but it is not nearly good enough. Intellectually they just don't get it." | Portes is unconvinced that there has been a sea change. "What we have in the eurozone now is austerity lite. What they are doing is better than it was but it is not nearly good enough. Intellectually they just don't get it." |
| Simon Tilford, the chief economist at the Centre for European Reform, agreed. "I don't think anything has fundamentally changed in Europe as yet, although it probably will at some point. All they have done is take into account that when economies grow much more slowly there are obvious implications for tax revenues. They haven't moved from a pro-cyclical fiscal stance to a neutral one, let alone a counter-cyclical position." | |
| Eventually, Tilford added, the eurozone's economic predicament will force change. "Europe is in a very dangerous place. It is hard to see how a meaningful economic recovery will take place in the foreseeable future … I doubt whether democratic countries can maintain the necessary public support for this sort of strategy indefinitely. There is no light at the end of the tunnel. | |
| "There will come a time when relations in the eurozone become more confrontational. There will be a standoff between the French, Spanish and Italians on one side and the Germans and other core countries on the other. How that standoff plays out will determine the future of the eurozone." | |
| Job crisis worsens | |
| The number of jobless people in France rose by nearly 40,000 (1.2%) in April, to hit an all-time high.The increase took the number of registered jobseekers in mainland France to 3,264,400, the worst since records began in 1996, marking two uninterrupted years of monthly rises, official figures revealed. | |
| Looking at the last five years, it was the 53rd month out of 61 showing a rise, highlighting France's chronic job crisis as the economy fell back into recession in the first quarter and jobless figures were driven up by industrial layoffs. | |
| The new record is a blow to President François Hollande, who is sticking to a pledge to reverse the unemployment trend by the end of the year, despite multiple forecasts to the contrary. |