This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-22699473

The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 2 Version 3
UK confirms extended detentions of up to 90 Afghans UK confirms extended detentions of up to 90 Afghans
(44 minutes later)
British forces are detaining 80 to 90 Afghan nationals in a holding facility at Camp Bastion, Defence Secretary Philip Hammond has confirmed.British forces are detaining 80 to 90 Afghan nationals in a holding facility at Camp Bastion, Defence Secretary Philip Hammond has confirmed.
UK lawyers acting for eight of the men said they had been held for up to 14 months without charge in what could amount to unlawful detention.UK lawyers acting for eight of the men said they had been held for up to 14 months without charge in what could amount to unlawful detention.
They compared it to when the public became aware of Guantanamo Bay and want the UK High Court to free the men.They compared it to when the public became aware of Guantanamo Bay and want the UK High Court to free the men.
But Mr Hammond said their release would put British troops at risk.But Mr Hammond said their release would put British troops at risk.
British forces in Afghanistan are allowed to detain suspects for 96 hours.British forces in Afghanistan are allowed to detain suspects for 96 hours.
However, in "exceptional circumstances" - to gather critical intelligence, for example - they can hold them for longer. However, in "exceptional circumstances" to gather critical intelligence, for example - they can hold them for longer.
'Patently absurd''Patently absurd'
Documents seen by the BBC suggest 85 suspected insurgents are being held at Camp Bastion.
UK lawyers acting for eight of the men being detained said their clients were arrested by British soldiers in raids in villages in Helmand and Kandahar provinces and have been held for between eight and 14 months without charge.UK lawyers acting for eight of the men being detained said their clients were arrested by British soldiers in raids in villages in Helmand and Kandahar provinces and have been held for between eight and 14 months without charge.
But the defence secretary dismissed claims that the UK is operating a secret facility in Afghanistan as "patently absurd".But the defence secretary dismissed claims that the UK is operating a secret facility in Afghanistan as "patently absurd".
Mr Hammond told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that Parliament had been informed by this government and the previous one about the detention of Afghan suspects.Mr Hammond told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that Parliament had been informed by this government and the previous one about the detention of Afghan suspects.
He declined to say how long some had been held and said the precise number of detainees fluctuated.He declined to say how long some had been held and said the precise number of detainees fluctuated.
General Zahir Azimi, a spokesman for the Afghan Ministry of Defence, said the detentions were illegal and inhumane.General Zahir Azimi, a spokesman for the Afghan Ministry of Defence, said the detentions were illegal and inhumane.
"The prisoners must be handed over to the Afghan authorities," he said. "After their handover to us, they will be dealt with according to our judicial laws, and the agreements reached with the international community.""The prisoners must be handed over to the Afghan authorities," he said. "After their handover to us, they will be dealt with according to our judicial laws, and the agreements reached with the international community."
'Secret facility''Secret facility'
Lawyers for the men, whom the BBC has chosen not to name over fears for their safety, launched habeas corpus applications at the High Court in London on 18 April, with a full hearing due in late July.Lawyers for the men, whom the BBC has chosen not to name over fears for their safety, launched habeas corpus applications at the High Court in London on 18 April, with a full hearing due in late July.
"The UK could have trained the Afghan authorities to detain people lawfully with proper standards and making sure that they are treated humanely," Phil Shiner, of Public Interest Lawyers, told the BBC."The UK could have trained the Afghan authorities to detain people lawfully with proper standards and making sure that they are treated humanely," Phil Shiner, of Public Interest Lawyers, told the BBC.
"They could have then monitored that, including with ad hoc inspections, to make sure that the Afghans were obeying the law. They have chosen not to do so.""They could have then monitored that, including with ad hoc inspections, to make sure that the Afghans were obeying the law. They have chosen not to do so."
He said the UK was acting in an "entirely unconstitutional" way and that "Parliament has not been told that we have this secret facility".He said the UK was acting in an "entirely unconstitutional" way and that "Parliament has not been told that we have this secret facility".
Mr Hammond told Parliament in December that British forces were "holding significant numbers of detainees" who, for legal reasons, could not "be transferred into the Afghan system".Mr Hammond told Parliament in December that British forces were "holding significant numbers of detainees" who, for legal reasons, could not "be transferred into the Afghan system".
BBC legal affairs correspondent Clive Coleman said the detentions pose extremely awkward questions for the government about the lawfulness of a policy of detention that until now seemed to be little known. The BBC's legal affairs correspondent Clive Coleman said the government was in a bind. He said there was a dilemma about what to with people who are believed to be actively involved in the insurgency, whom the Army can hold for only 96 hours, and who cannot be transferred to the Afghan authorities.
In preparatory legal arguments at the High Court on 22 April, Mr Justice Collins told the government that the case raised serious questions about the British army's power to hold suspects in Afghanistan.In preparatory legal arguments at the High Court on 22 April, Mr Justice Collins told the government that the case raised serious questions about the British army's power to hold suspects in Afghanistan.
He said the UK could not operate a Guantanamo Bay-style prison, referring to the US facility in which suspects are being held indefinitely without trial.He said the UK could not operate a Guantanamo Bay-style prison, referring to the US facility in which suspects are being held indefinitely without trial.
Taxpayers' expense
A senior government lawyer, James Eadie QC, described this situation in court as a "perfect legal storm" because the Army suspects all the detainees have links to insurgents.A senior government lawyer, James Eadie QC, described this situation in court as a "perfect legal storm" because the Army suspects all the detainees have links to insurgents.
The families of two of the men who appear to have been held the longest said they were arrested in the spring last year and interrogated in the weeks that followed.The families of two of the men who appear to have been held the longest said they were arrested in the spring last year and interrogated in the weeks that followed.
But legal papers state their interrogation ended "many months ago".But legal papers state their interrogation ended "many months ago".
Mr Shiner said Mr Hammond had refused to allow the detainees access to legal representation but had now granted lawyers an hour-long telephone call with two of the Afghans on Wednesday.Mr Shiner said Mr Hammond had refused to allow the detainees access to legal representation but had now granted lawyers an hour-long telephone call with two of the Afghans on Wednesday.
The defence secretary was keen to point out that the Afghans' case was being brought "at the expense, of course, of the British taxpayer, because Mr Shiner's actions are funded by the legal aid system".