This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-21931007
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Metropolitan Museum of Art's entrance fee 'deceptive' | Metropolitan Museum of Art's entrance fee 'deceptive' |
(about 20 hours later) | |
The Metropolitan Museum of Art's practice of requesting a "recommended" admission fee of $25 (£16) deceives patrons entitled to pay as little as they choose, a lawsuit charges. | The Metropolitan Museum of Art's practice of requesting a "recommended" admission fee of $25 (£16) deceives patrons entitled to pay as little as they choose, a lawsuit charges. |
Under a longstanding agreement with the city of New York, the museum must accept whatever patrons offer to pay. | Under a longstanding agreement with the city of New York, the museum must accept whatever patrons offer to pay. |
But signs at cashier desks appear to demand full price, the suit contends. | But signs at cashier desks appear to demand full price, the suit contends. |
The museum says its "recommended" policy has been place for 40 years and it makes no effort to deceive visitors. | The museum says its "recommended" policy has been place for 40 years and it makes no effort to deceive visitors. |
The lawsuit, filed in New York City on behalf of former patrons, contends that the world famous museum, which receives six million visitors a year, uses misleading marketing and cashier training to deceive unwary visitors. | The lawsuit, filed in New York City on behalf of former patrons, contends that the world famous museum, which receives six million visitors a year, uses misleading marketing and cashier training to deceive unwary visitors. |
Lawyers say the signs in the lobby listing the price of admission with the word "recommended" below in smaller type violate a 1893 law mandating the public be admitted free of charge at least five days and two evenings per week in exchange for monetary grants and rent-free use of city-owned land. | Lawyers say the signs in the lobby listing the price of admission with the word "recommended" below in smaller type violate a 1893 law mandating the public be admitted free of charge at least five days and two evenings per week in exchange for monetary grants and rent-free use of city-owned land. |
The suit, which lawyers hope will eventually represent a broad class of people who have visited the museum in recent years, seeks a change in the admissions policy and reimbursement for those who they say were misled. | The suit, which lawyers hope will eventually represent a broad class of people who have visited the museum in recent years, seeks a change in the admissions policy and reimbursement for those who they say were misled. |
Word choice | Word choice |
Confusion over whether visitors were required to pay the full $25 is "an issue with tourists travelling to the US from a foreign country", Michael Hiller, a lawyer for those who brought the suit, told the BBC. | Confusion over whether visitors were required to pay the full $25 is "an issue with tourists travelling to the US from a foreign country", Michael Hiller, a lawyer for those who brought the suit, told the BBC. |
"They are violating the statute, plainly and simply," Mr Hiller said, referring to the 1893 law. "The museum was designed to make art accessible to the public." | "They are violating the statute, plainly and simply," Mr Hiller said, referring to the 1893 law. "The museum was designed to make art accessible to the public." |
A former employee of the Met is expected to testify, Mr Hiller said. | |
The witness, who trained cashiers from 2007-2011, alleges that signage was changed from "suggested" to "recommended" because administrators believed it would encourage people to pay more, Mr Hiller said. | |
Harold Holzer, a spokesman for the museum, said the 1893 law had been superseded. | Harold Holzer, a spokesman for the museum, said the 1893 law had been superseded. |
New York City agreed to the museum's request in 1970 to charge an admission fee - so long as the amount was left up to individuals and the signage reflected that. | New York City agreed to the museum's request in 1970 to charge an admission fee - so long as the amount was left up to individuals and the signage reflected that. |
About 40% of visitors pay full price, Mr Holzer said. He said gate proceeds allowed the Met to offer free admission to special exhibitions. | About 40% of visitors pay full price, Mr Holzer said. He said gate proceeds allowed the Met to offer free admission to special exhibitions. |
'Access guaranteed' | 'Access guaranteed' |
About 11% of the museum's operating expenses were covered by admissions last year. As a non-profit organisation, the museum pays no income taxes. It is one of the wealthiest museums in the world, with a $2bn investment portfolio. | About 11% of the museum's operating expenses were covered by admissions last year. As a non-profit organisation, the museum pays no income taxes. It is one of the wealthiest museums in the world, with a $2bn investment portfolio. |
Mr Holzer estimated the museum would receive 15-20% of its operating budget from the fees this year, with 11% coming from city grants. | Mr Holzer estimated the museum would receive 15-20% of its operating budget from the fees this year, with 11% coming from city grants. |
The Met believes its policy "guarantees access for people regardless of their ability to pay", Mr Holzer said. He noted other New York City museums charge steep admission fees. | The Met believes its policy "guarantees access for people regardless of their ability to pay", Mr Holzer said. He noted other New York City museums charge steep admission fees. |
Entrance fees for prominent New York City art museums such as the Whitney, the Museum of Modern Art and the Guggenheim range from $18 to $25. | Entrance fees for prominent New York City art museums such as the Whitney, the Museum of Modern Art and the Guggenheim range from $18 to $25. |
Mr Hiller demands the museum stop charging entirely for admission and remove the cashier desks. | Mr Hiller demands the museum stop charging entirely for admission and remove the cashier desks. |
"You have got to eliminate any effort to charge people," he said. | "You have got to eliminate any effort to charge people," he said. |
Previous version
1
Next version