This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-21932682
The article has changed 13 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
US Supreme Court to hear gay marriage cases | US Supreme Court to hear gay marriage cases |
(about 1 hour later) | |
The US Supreme Court is to consider two landmark cases on gay marriage in back-to-back-hearings this week. | The US Supreme Court is to consider two landmark cases on gay marriage in back-to-back-hearings this week. |
On Tuesday, the justices will weigh a California constitutional amendment banning same-sex unions, passed after gay marriage became legal there. | On Tuesday, the justices will weigh a California constitutional amendment banning same-sex unions, passed after gay marriage became legal there. |
On Wednesday, a federal law defining marriage as between a man and a woman only, for the purpose of taxes and benefits, is up for review. | On Wednesday, a federal law defining marriage as between a man and a woman only, for the purpose of taxes and benefits, is up for review. |
The court is expected to hand down its ruling by the end of June. | The court is expected to hand down its ruling by the end of June. |
Outside the court in Washington DC, dozens of people have been queuing, some of them for several days, to secure a seat for the much-anticipated hearings. | Outside the court in Washington DC, dozens of people have been queuing, some of them for several days, to secure a seat for the much-anticipated hearings. |
Among those in court on Tuesday will be a lesbian cousin of Chief Justice John Roberts, the Los Angeles Times reports. | Among those in court on Tuesday will be a lesbian cousin of Chief Justice John Roberts, the Los Angeles Times reports. |
California case | California case |
The first case will concern California's ban on same-sex marriages, known as Proposition 8, which was approved by that state's voters in a referendum in November 2008. | |
But its passage came only after some 18,000 gay marriages had already taken place in the state, following its legalisation of such unions earlier the same year. | |
Two same-sex couples filed a lawsuit, known as also known as Hollingsworth v Perry, against Proposition 8. | |
As the state of California refused to defend it, the organisation that had sponsored Proposition 8 stepped in as defendants. | |
In 2010, a federal court ruled against Proposition 8, saying the state had not demonstrated a good reason for infringing on what the judge saw as a fundamental right for all couples to marry. | In 2010, a federal court ruled against Proposition 8, saying the state had not demonstrated a good reason for infringing on what the judge saw as a fundamental right for all couples to marry. |
Supporters of the ban appealed against that ruling, but the court of appeals also said the amendment was unconstitutional. | |
Anti-gay marriage activists then petitioned the Supreme Court to review the case. They want the question of whether marriage should be defined as a union between a man and a woman to be left up to individual US states. | |
The Obama administration is not taking part in the case, but has filed what is called a "friend of the court" briefing, asking the Supreme Court to strike down the anti-gay marriage amendment. | The Obama administration is not taking part in the case, but has filed what is called a "friend of the court" briefing, asking the Supreme Court to strike down the anti-gay marriage amendment. |
Inspecting the constitution | Inspecting the constitution |
On Wednesday, the US Supreme Court will consider a federal law called the Defense of Marriage Act (Doma), which legally defines marriage as between a man and a woman. | |
Under that law, same-sex couples are not eligible for federal benefits and tax breaks claimed by straight couples. | Under that law, same-sex couples are not eligible for federal benefits and tax breaks claimed by straight couples. |
Doma, signed in 1996 by former President Bill Clinton, has been overturned by four federal courts and two courts of appeal. They said the legislation unfairly discriminated against same-sex couples. | |
The lawsuit was triggered by Edith Windsor, 83, who was required to pay $380,000 (£250,000) in federal estate taxes when her wife died in 2008. Straight couples would be exempt from such taxes. | |
On Monday, the two couples involved in the Proposition 8 case visited the National Archives to inspect the original text of the US Constitution. | On Monday, the two couples involved in the Proposition 8 case visited the National Archives to inspect the original text of the US Constitution. |
Their visit was to "reflect on the importance of their case for gay and lesbian couples across the nation", said the American Foundation for Equal Rights, which supports their case. | Their visit was to "reflect on the importance of their case for gay and lesbian couples across the nation", said the American Foundation for Equal Rights, which supports their case. |
Overnight vigils have been planned across the country ahead of the hearings. | Overnight vigils have been planned across the country ahead of the hearings. |
Currently, nine US states and the District of Columbia permit same-sex marriage. Eight other states allow civil unions or domestic partnerships with virtually all state marriage benefits, but do not allow couples to marry. | Currently, nine US states and the District of Columbia permit same-sex marriage. Eight other states allow civil unions or domestic partnerships with virtually all state marriage benefits, but do not allow couples to marry. |
Recent opinion polls have shown a rapid growth in public support for the issue, and that most Americans now believe it should be legal. | Recent opinion polls have shown a rapid growth in public support for the issue, and that most Americans now believe it should be legal. |
The Supreme Court cases follow a flurry of declarations in support of gay marriage by high-profile figures, including last week by former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. | |
Days earlier, Ohio's Rob Portman became the first Republican senator to back gay marriage. | |
On Sunday, Democratic Senator Claire McCaskill of Missouri said she also backed it. | On Sunday, Democratic Senator Claire McCaskill of Missouri said she also backed it. |
And on Monday, another Democratic senator, Mark Warner of Virginia, adopted the same stance, in a statement to Time magazine. | And on Monday, another Democratic senator, Mark Warner of Virginia, adopted the same stance, in a statement to Time magazine. |