This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/mar/20/barack-obama-palestinians-optimistic-israel

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Obama has disappointed Palestinians. But I'm optimistic about his Israel visit Obama has disappointed Palestinians. But I'm optimistic about his Israel visit
(6 months later)
It would be unrealistic to expect a breakthrough from President Obama's visit to Israel, particularly given how pessimistic Palestinians have become over the US administration's role in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. The hope is that the visit does not make things worse. But this deterioration can only be stopped if Palestinians themselves leverage the US president's visit to push the issue of whether they deserve to live with dignity like any other sovereign nation.It would be unrealistic to expect a breakthrough from President Obama's visit to Israel, particularly given how pessimistic Palestinians have become over the US administration's role in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. The hope is that the visit does not make things worse. But this deterioration can only be stopped if Palestinians themselves leverage the US president's visit to push the issue of whether they deserve to live with dignity like any other sovereign nation.
Successive Israeli governments have not acknowledged Palestinians as a people like any other, let alone the Israelis. The Israeli government's continued subordination and stripping of Palestinians of all they possess under the veil of security reveals the voracious appetite of an aggressive occupier. It has long been a tedious restatement of the obvious to protest at the outright theft and settlement of Palestinian land in the West Bank and East Jerusalem; the incapacitation of West Bankers with hundreds of humiliation points – called checkpoints; the incarceration of Gaza; and the blunt disrespect to the peace process.Successive Israeli governments have not acknowledged Palestinians as a people like any other, let alone the Israelis. The Israeli government's continued subordination and stripping of Palestinians of all they possess under the veil of security reveals the voracious appetite of an aggressive occupier. It has long been a tedious restatement of the obvious to protest at the outright theft and settlement of Palestinian land in the West Bank and East Jerusalem; the incapacitation of West Bankers with hundreds of humiliation points – called checkpoints; the incarceration of Gaza; and the blunt disrespect to the peace process.
It is obligatory that Palestinians lobby President Obama on what Israel cites as security. They must clarify what it actually means by the term, and how Israel skilfully uses it as a euphemism for continued and aggressive occupation. Even if no progress is sought to advance a resolution to the conflict, the carte blanche Israel affords itself under the name of security calls for scrutiny.It is obligatory that Palestinians lobby President Obama on what Israel cites as security. They must clarify what it actually means by the term, and how Israel skilfully uses it as a euphemism for continued and aggressive occupation. Even if no progress is sought to advance a resolution to the conflict, the carte blanche Israel affords itself under the name of security calls for scrutiny.
The livelihood of Palestinians cannot continue to be trampled down. How does exporting flowers from Gaza to the West Bank affect Israel's security? Or barring ordinary people from travelling between Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem to visit their next of kin? Or allowing economic development for Palestinians to rid themselves of complete dependence on foreign aid?The livelihood of Palestinians cannot continue to be trampled down. How does exporting flowers from Gaza to the West Bank affect Israel's security? Or barring ordinary people from travelling between Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem to visit their next of kin? Or allowing economic development for Palestinians to rid themselves of complete dependence on foreign aid?
Equally important, how does separating Israelis and Palestinians and causing each to view the other as alien help protect Israel?Equally important, how does separating Israelis and Palestinians and causing each to view the other as alien help protect Israel?
It would not be unreasonable to hope that Obama would punctuate his continued commitment to Israel's security with the recognition that it need not stamp on the hope of an entire people for a dignified life. If this is not established, we can only assume that Israel will see it as the US administration's readiness to underwrite Israel's further refusal to contemplate a civilised conclusion to the conflict.It would not be unreasonable to hope that Obama would punctuate his continued commitment to Israel's security with the recognition that it need not stamp on the hope of an entire people for a dignified life. If this is not established, we can only assume that Israel will see it as the US administration's readiness to underwrite Israel's further refusal to contemplate a civilised conclusion to the conflict.
Many Palestinians do not fully understand how Obama ended up tipping the scales in the Middle East so much in favour of Israel after raising expectations so much at the outset of his presidency. But while Obama has disappointed Palestinians, they also have themselves to blame for their internal divisions and for allowing the coupling of their cause with the so called Arab spring.Many Palestinians do not fully understand how Obama ended up tipping the scales in the Middle East so much in favour of Israel after raising expectations so much at the outset of his presidency. But while Obama has disappointed Palestinians, they also have themselves to blame for their internal divisions and for allowing the coupling of their cause with the so called Arab spring.
Renewed focus by Palestinians on their full and deserved rights as a people should also have them separate their cause from the Arab spring. The tendency to portray the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in the light of developments in the Arab world was inevitable. However, it has afforded Israel ample space to continue its aggressive policies almost entirely unwatched.Renewed focus by Palestinians on their full and deserved rights as a people should also have them separate their cause from the Arab spring. The tendency to portray the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in the light of developments in the Arab world was inevitable. However, it has afforded Israel ample space to continue its aggressive policies almost entirely unwatched.
I do not envy President Obama on what must be a delicate visit. Yet I am optimistic that we could help him help us and the Israelis by establishing a significant leap on principle. For a president of a country that upholds life, liberty and the pursuit of freedom and justice, I hope that Obama would be willing to remind Palestinians and Israelis of the equal human beings on the other side. That would constitute the beginnings of the US's willingness to push towards an equitable peace.I do not envy President Obama on what must be a delicate visit. Yet I am optimistic that we could help him help us and the Israelis by establishing a significant leap on principle. For a president of a country that upholds life, liberty and the pursuit of freedom and justice, I hope that Obama would be willing to remind Palestinians and Israelis of the equal human beings on the other side. That would constitute the beginnings of the US's willingness to push towards an equitable peace.
• Comments on this article are set to remain open for 24 hours from the time of publication but may be closed overnight• Comments on this article are set to remain open for 24 hours from the time of publication but may be closed overnight
Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning.