This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/wales/6956752.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
'Notorious' eBay fraud sentence | |
(40 minutes later) | |
A 20-year-old "obsessed" with defrauding customers of the internet auction site eBay has been sentenced to two years' custody. | |
Philip Shortman, from Cwmbran, south Wales, was sent to a detention centre for another £45,000 eBay fraud in 2005. | Philip Shortman, from Cwmbran, south Wales, was sent to a detention centre for another £45,000 eBay fraud in 2005. |
The judge at Newport Crown Court said his deception "strikes at the system" of internet trading "as a whole". | The judge at Newport Crown Court said his deception "strikes at the system" of internet trading "as a whole". |
In the latest fraud he was jailed for conning eBay users of £14,000 and breaching a suspended jail term. | In the latest fraud he was jailed for conning eBay users of £14,000 and breaching a suspended jail term. |
Prosecutor Ian Ibrahim said Shortman, a married father-of-two, had used false names to fraudulently sell goods including 2006 Ryder Cup tickets, a Sony camcorder and a state-of-the-art mobile priced at more than £900. | Prosecutor Ian Ibrahim said Shortman, a married father-of-two, had used false names to fraudulently sell goods including 2006 Ryder Cup tickets, a Sony camcorder and a state-of-the-art mobile priced at more than £900. |
The court heard that he also bought a laptop valued at £250 and computer parts over the net but did not pay for them. | The court heard that he also bought a laptop valued at £250 and computer parts over the net but did not pay for them. |
When the computer seller attempted to get it back when the money failed to appear in his bank account, Shortman sent him abusive emails. | When the computer seller attempted to get it back when the money failed to appear in his bank account, Shortman sent him abusive emails. |
In 2005, when he was 17, Shortman was given a year's detention for conning eBay users out of £45,000 of goods. | In 2005, when he was 17, Shortman was given a year's detention for conning eBay users out of £45,000 of goods. |
Before he was caught he spent the money on limousine rides with friends and a shopping trip to New York. | Before he was caught he spent the money on limousine rides with friends and a shopping trip to New York. |
He is, at the age of 20, somebody who has attracted a certain level of notoriety Laurence Jones, defending | He is, at the age of 20, somebody who has attracted a certain level of notoriety Laurence Jones, defending |
Then in January this year, he was given an eight-month suspended jail term after admitting buying thousands of pounds of stolen fuel cards. | Then in January this year, he was given an eight-month suspended jail term after admitting buying thousands of pounds of stolen fuel cards. |
The court heard he should have been sentenced for the latest fraud last Friday but was being interviewed by police about another offence. | The court heard he should have been sentenced for the latest fraud last Friday but was being interviewed by police about another offence. |
This involved the collection of a Vauxhall Astra from a man in Hay-on-Wye, who later found he could not collect the agreed £850 fee as Shortman had used a false PayPal account. | This involved the collection of a Vauxhall Astra from a man in Hay-on-Wye, who later found he could not collect the agreed £850 fee as Shortman had used a false PayPal account. |
It was the 32nd offence Shortman asked the court to take into consideration. | It was the 32nd offence Shortman asked the court to take into consideration. |
His barrister Laurence Jones told the court Shortman could be described as being "obsessed" with defrauding customers of eBay. | His barrister Laurence Jones told the court Shortman could be described as being "obsessed" with defrauding customers of eBay. |
Mr Jones said: "He is, at the age of 20, somebody who has attracted a certain level of notoriety. | Mr Jones said: "He is, at the age of 20, somebody who has attracted a certain level of notoriety. |
When those like you deceive purchasers and vendors over the internet, it strikes at the system as a whole and brings otherwise respectable trading institutions and individuals into overall disrepute Judge David Morris | When those like you deceive purchasers and vendors over the internet, it strikes at the system as a whole and brings otherwise respectable trading institutions and individuals into overall disrepute Judge David Morris |
"He is 20 and I ask the court to bear that in mind when sentencing him. His best, and perhaps only point of mitigation, is the full and frank admissions made to police during interviews." | "He is 20 and I ask the court to bear that in mind when sentencing him. His best, and perhaps only point of mitigation, is the full and frank admissions made to police during interviews." |
He said Shortman had lower than average intelligence but could gain a sense of achievement from his illegal activities on eBay. | He said Shortman had lower than average intelligence but could gain a sense of achievement from his illegal activities on eBay. |
Mr Jones said Shortman took his role as a father seriously but added: "He accepts that his current behaviour acts as no role model to his children." | Mr Jones said Shortman took his role as a father seriously but added: "He accepts that his current behaviour acts as no role model to his children." |
Sentencing Shortman to a young offenders' institution, Judge David Morris said: "Internet trading depends on trust and honesty. | Sentencing Shortman to a young offenders' institution, Judge David Morris said: "Internet trading depends on trust and honesty. |
"When those like you deceive purchasers and vendors over the internet, it strikes at the system as a whole and brings otherwise respectable trading institutions and individuals into overall disrepute." | "When those like you deceive purchasers and vendors over the internet, it strikes at the system as a whole and brings otherwise respectable trading institutions and individuals into overall disrepute." |
After the case, Gareth Griffith, from eBay, said maintaining a secure site for buyers and sellers was eBay's "first priority". | After the case, Gareth Griffith, from eBay, said maintaining a secure site for buyers and sellers was eBay's "first priority". |
"We are delighted that Mr Shortman, without doubt a persistent and unrepentant fraudster, has been given a prison sentence and that the efforts of our investigations team and our determination to push for a prosecution have been rewarded today," he said. | "We are delighted that Mr Shortman, without doubt a persistent and unrepentant fraudster, has been given a prison sentence and that the efforts of our investigations team and our determination to push for a prosecution have been rewarded today," he said. |
Previous version
1
Next version