This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/6956113.stm
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Judge overturns Haneef visa ban | |
(about 1 hour later) | |
A court in Australia has overturned a government decision to cancel the visa of an Indian doctor briefly charged over failed bomb attacks in the UK. | A court in Australia has overturned a government decision to cancel the visa of an Indian doctor briefly charged over failed bomb attacks in the UK. |
The court ruled that the government had erred when it cancelled Mohamed Haneef's visa on character grounds. | The court ruled that the government had erred when it cancelled Mohamed Haneef's visa on character grounds. |
Dr Haneef was accused of links with failed attacks in London and Glasgow. | |
But all the charges against him were dropped after Australia's chief prosecutor reviewed the case and said a mistake had been made. | |
The BBC's Nick Bryant, in Sydney, says the court's decision will be a major embarrassment for the Australian government. | The BBC's Nick Bryant, in Sydney, says the court's decision will be a major embarrassment for the Australian government. |
It first cancelled Dr Haneef's work visa after a magistrate granted him bail, then refused to reinstate it when charges against him were dropped. | |
Dr Haneef, who has now returned to India, has consistently denied any wrongdoing. | Dr Haneef, who has now returned to India, has consistently denied any wrongdoing. |
'Wrong test' | |
At a hearing in Brisbane, Justice Jeffrey Spender ruled that Immigration Minister Kevin Andrews used the wrong criteria when he revoked Dr Haneef's visa. | At a hearing in Brisbane, Justice Jeffrey Spender ruled that Immigration Minister Kevin Andrews used the wrong criteria when he revoked Dr Haneef's visa. |
HANEEF CASE TIMELINE 2 July: Arrested in Brisbane14 July: Charged with providing "reckless support" to terrorism16 July: Granted bail, but kept in custody after work visa revoked27 July: Charges dropped29 July: Returns to India21 Aug: Court overturns government visa decision | |
"The minister cancelled the visa by adopting a wrong criterion; he fell into jurisdictional error by applying the wrong test," he said. | |
"That error infects the cancellation decision. It follows that the decision must be set aside." | |
The new ruling does not mean that Dr Haneef's visa will automatically be reinstated. The ruling is suspended for 21 days to give the government time to formulate a response. | |
Dr Haneef's lawyer, Peter Russo, said that he hoped Mr Andrews would accept the decision with "good grace", allowing the doctor to return to Australia to continue his medical work and training. | Dr Haneef's lawyer, Peter Russo, said that he hoped Mr Andrews would accept the decision with "good grace", allowing the doctor to return to Australia to continue his medical work and training. |
There was no immediate response from the government, although Mr Andrews had earlier indicated he would consider appealing. | |
UK relatives | |
Dr Haneef had been working at a hospital on Australia's Gold Coast when he was arrested on 2 July. He was held for several days before being charged with giving "reckless support" to terrorism. | Dr Haneef had been working at a hospital on Australia's Gold Coast when he was arrested on 2 July. He was held for several days before being charged with giving "reckless support" to terrorism. |
A magistrate granted him bail, but within hours Mr Andrews had revoked his employment visa, allowing the authorities to keep him in detention. | A magistrate granted him bail, but within hours Mr Andrews had revoked his employment visa, allowing the authorities to keep him in detention. |
When key evidence linking Dr Haneef to the suspects in the UK attacks was found to be flawed, the charges were dropped, but not the visa ruling. | When key evidence linking Dr Haneef to the suspects in the UK attacks was found to be flawed, the charges were dropped, but not the visa ruling. |
Dr Haneef's defence team has argued that the immigration laws were applied simply to keep him behind bars while the criminal case against him was falling apart. | Dr Haneef's defence team has argued that the immigration laws were applied simply to keep him behind bars while the criminal case against him was falling apart. |
Dr Haneef is the cousin of Sabeel Ahmed, one of three people charged in the UK over the failed attacks. | Dr Haneef is the cousin of Sabeel Ahmed, one of three people charged in the UK over the failed attacks. |
Mr Ahmed's brother, Kafeel, was the driver of a jeep which crashed into Glasgow Airport in flames on 30 June. He died from his injuries earlier this month. | Mr Ahmed's brother, Kafeel, was the driver of a jeep which crashed into Glasgow Airport in flames on 30 June. He died from his injuries earlier this month. |