This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-20977765
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Liam Fox: Gay marriage plans 'divisive and wrong' | |
(about 9 hours later) | |
The government's plan to legislate for same-sex marriages is "divisive, ill thought through and constitutionally wrong," former Defence Secretary Liam Fox has said. | The government's plan to legislate for same-sex marriages is "divisive, ill thought through and constitutionally wrong," former Defence Secretary Liam Fox has said. |
In a letter to constituents, Mr Fox said same-sex relationships should be treated "with tolerance and respect". | In a letter to constituents, Mr Fox said same-sex relationships should be treated "with tolerance and respect". |
But there did not appear to be "much demand" for the change, he said. | But there did not appear to be "much demand" for the change, he said. |
The government has said that the measure will strengthen the "vital" institution of marriage. | The government has said that the measure will strengthen the "vital" institution of marriage. |
"The legislation looks as though it was made on the hoof to deal with the political problem du jour", Mr Fox wrote. | "The legislation looks as though it was made on the hoof to deal with the political problem du jour", Mr Fox wrote. |
It would put the Church of England in an "anomalous and absurd" position by banning it from carrying out same-sex marriages, he added. | It would put the Church of England in an "anomalous and absurd" position by banning it from carrying out same-sex marriages, he added. |
"If the 'exemption' is, as stated, because the Church had made clear their objection to same-sex marriage then why not exempt the Catholic Church which has been even clearer in its opposition," he said. | "If the 'exemption' is, as stated, because the Church had made clear their objection to same-sex marriage then why not exempt the Catholic Church which has been even clearer in its opposition," he said. |
'Vibrant' | 'Vibrant' |
"The idea of making certain practices illegal for one Christian Church, but not others, risks further weakening and splintering Britain's traditional religion at a time when many Christians feel that they are under threat on a number of secular, political and cultural fronts. | "The idea of making certain practices illegal for one Christian Church, but not others, risks further weakening and splintering Britain's traditional religion at a time when many Christians feel that they are under threat on a number of secular, political and cultural fronts. |
"To fail to understand this is to risk an affront to a large stabilising and normally acquiescent section of this country which will sow completely unnecessary seeds of dissent." | "To fail to understand this is to risk an affront to a large stabilising and normally acquiescent section of this country which will sow completely unnecessary seeds of dissent." |
The anomaly could lead to legal challenges, Mr Fox warned. | The anomaly could lead to legal challenges, Mr Fox warned. |
"We should not be intruding on the freedom of worship that is the proper preserve of the Churches not the courts," he said. | "We should not be intruding on the freedom of worship that is the proper preserve of the Churches not the courts," he said. |
The move would enjoy greater public support if it were "simply an argument about righting a wrong", Mr Fox said. | The move would enjoy greater public support if it were "simply an argument about righting a wrong", Mr Fox said. |
Instead, it "smacks of a form of social engineering of which Conservatives should be instinctively wary". | Instead, it "smacks of a form of social engineering of which Conservatives should be instinctively wary". |
Advocating the change in December, Culture Secretary Maria Miller argued that "extending marriage to same-sex couples will strengthen, not weaken, that vital institution". | Advocating the change in December, Culture Secretary Maria Miller argued that "extending marriage to same-sex couples will strengthen, not weaken, that vital institution". |
"I have been absolutely clear that I would never introduce a bill that encroaches or threatens religious freedoms," she told MPs. | "I have been absolutely clear that I would never introduce a bill that encroaches or threatens religious freedoms," she told MPs. |
"I believe the proposals strike the right balance - protecting important religious freedoms while ensuring that same-sex couples have the same freedom to marry as opposite-sex couples. | "I believe the proposals strike the right balance - protecting important religious freedoms while ensuring that same-sex couples have the same freedom to marry as opposite-sex couples. |
"By making marriage available to everyone, we will ensure that it remains a vibrant institution." | "By making marriage available to everyone, we will ensure that it remains a vibrant institution." |
Previous version
1
Next version