This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/sep/28/binyamin-netanyahu-un-bomb-admiration
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 4 | Version 5 |
|---|---|
| Binyamin Netanyahu's UN bomb triggers derision and admiration | Binyamin Netanyahu's UN bomb triggers derision and admiration |
| (8 days later) | |
| It was certainly explosive, but did it bomb? Binyamin Netanyahu's show-stopping stunt at the UN general assembly went instantly viral, with memes, remixes and scathing tweets spreading across the internet like shrapnel. But while the ridicule quota was high, there was also admiration. | It was certainly explosive, but did it bomb? Binyamin Netanyahu's show-stopping stunt at the UN general assembly went instantly viral, with memes, remixes and scathing tweets spreading across the internet like shrapnel. But while the ridicule quota was high, there was also admiration. |
| Twenty-five minutes into his address, the Israeli prime minister reached under the podium and pulled out a folded card. "This is a bomb," he announced – words which in other circumstances might have led to security guards tackling him to the ground. | Twenty-five minutes into his address, the Israeli prime minister reached under the podium and pulled out a folded card. "This is a bomb," he announced – words which in other circumstances might have led to security guards tackling him to the ground. |
| It was, rather, a crude cartoon of a bomb, complete with fuse, which Netanyahu rather unnecessarily pointed out: "This is a fuse." He then talked through the three stages of uranium enrichment necessary before it could become a real bomb. | It was, rather, a crude cartoon of a bomb, complete with fuse, which Netanyahu rather unnecessarily pointed out: "This is a fuse." He then talked through the three stages of uranium enrichment necessary before it could become a real bomb. |
| Finally in a moment of eye-popping theatricality, he produced a marker pen. After a summer of prodding, pleading, wheedling and commanding the president of the United States to publicly declare a red line for Iran's nuclear programme, Bibi was taking over the drawing board. | Finally in a moment of eye-popping theatricality, he produced a marker pen. After a summer of prodding, pleading, wheedling and commanding the president of the United States to publicly declare a red line for Iran's nuclear programme, Bibi was taking over the drawing board. |
| "Where should the red line be drawn?" he asked with a rhetorical flourish. Head bent towards his diagram, pen in hand, he went on: "The red line should be drawn right here." And there it was, a thick, shockingly bright red line, across the 90% mark on Iran's nuclear bomb. | "Where should the red line be drawn?" he asked with a rhetorical flourish. Head bent towards his diagram, pen in hand, he went on: "The red line should be drawn right here." And there it was, a thick, shockingly bright red line, across the 90% mark on Iran's nuclear bomb. |
| "WE HAVE ACTUAL RED LINES," tweeted the journalist Joseph Dana. "Netanyahu is beyond parody at this point." | "WE HAVE ACTUAL RED LINES," tweeted the journalist Joseph Dana. "Netanyahu is beyond parody at this point." |
| The Atlantic columnist Jeffery Goldberg had likened Bibi's bomb to Clint Eastwood's chair, referring to the actor's cringeworthy address to an empty chair supposed to represent Barack Obama at the Republican national convention. | The Atlantic columnist Jeffery Goldberg had likened Bibi's bomb to Clint Eastwood's chair, referring to the actor's cringeworthy address to an empty chair supposed to represent Barack Obama at the Republican national convention. |
| A former White House spokesman, Ari Fleischer, tweeted: "Bibi's use of that chart was one of the most effective, gripping, uses of a chart I've ever seen. Is the world listening??" | A former White House spokesman, Ari Fleischer, tweeted: "Bibi's use of that chart was one of the most effective, gripping, uses of a chart I've ever seen. Is the world listening??" |
| Most Israeli newspaper commentators concentrated on the consequences of Netanyahu's gimmick. | Most Israeli newspaper commentators concentrated on the consequences of Netanyahu's gimmick. |
| "Despite all the mocking of various individuals of little faith, the image of the Israeli prime minister and the bomb will be broadcast in every news edition around the world, and will be incorporated in the video clips made by the Republican party for the presidential campaign," wrote Nahum Barnea in Yedioth Ahronoth. | "Despite all the mocking of various individuals of little faith, the image of the Israeli prime minister and the bomb will be broadcast in every news edition around the world, and will be incorporated in the video clips made by the Republican party for the presidential campaign," wrote Nahum Barnea in Yedioth Ahronoth. |
| But, he said, "the red line Netanyahu drew is binding for one country. If one takes his statements seriously, within a short time, months at most, if Iran is not deterred and if the US does not attack, Israel will launch an attack on its own." | But, he said, "the red line Netanyahu drew is binding for one country. If one takes his statements seriously, within a short time, months at most, if Iran is not deterred and if the US does not attack, Israel will launch an attack on its own." |
| Ben Caspit, writing in Ma'ariv, said: "The picture of the bomb … portrayed a certain charming childishness, but in the same breath we can determine with certainty that this picture will be broadcast over and over in every language to the television viewers, and Netanyahu, as they say, will have made his point." | Ben Caspit, writing in Ma'ariv, said: "The picture of the bomb … portrayed a certain charming childishness, but in the same breath we can determine with certainty that this picture will be broadcast over and over in every language to the television viewers, and Netanyahu, as they say, will have made his point." |
| The prime minister, wrote Yossi Verter in Haaretz, "did what he does best: he took a complex, amorphous topic and made it simpler, more tangible, more easily absorbed and understood … Was this an effective exercise or was it ridiculous? Helpful or harmful? It's too early to tell. What's certain is that no one can ignore his address, even if they'd want to." | The prime minister, wrote Yossi Verter in Haaretz, "did what he does best: he took a complex, amorphous topic and made it simpler, more tangible, more easily absorbed and understood … Was this an effective exercise or was it ridiculous? Helpful or harmful? It's too early to tell. What's certain is that no one can ignore his address, even if they'd want to." |
| He went on: "The ostensibly comic interlude that we witnessed yesterday … didn't make us laugh. It was black humour. Nuclear humour. And it certainly ought not to distract us from the fact that Netanyahu, for the first time in public, unequivocally set the summer of 2013 as the last chance to stop the Iranian nuke before it's too late." | He went on: "The ostensibly comic interlude that we witnessed yesterday … didn't make us laugh. It was black humour. Nuclear humour. And it certainly ought not to distract us from the fact that Netanyahu, for the first time in public, unequivocally set the summer of 2013 as the last chance to stop the Iranian nuke before it's too late." |
| • This article was amended on 1 October 2012 to correct a misspelling of Ari Fleischer's name. | • This article was amended on 1 October 2012 to correct a misspelling of Ari Fleischer's name. |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. | Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. Enter your email address to subscribe. | Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. Enter your email address to subscribe. |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox every weekday. |