This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/sep/05/clinton-china-differences-syria-sea-row
The article has changed 8 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Clinton and China leaders fail to resolve differences over Syria crisis and sea row | Clinton and China leaders fail to resolve differences over Syria crisis and sea row |
| (about 1 month later) | |
| Talks between US secretary of state, Hillary Clinton, and Chinese leaders have failed to come to agreement over how to end the crisis in Syria and resolve Beijing's territorial disputes with its neighbours in the South China Sea. | Talks between US secretary of state, Hillary Clinton, and Chinese leaders have failed to come to agreement over how to end the crisis in Syria and resolve Beijing's territorial disputes with its neighbours in the South China Sea. |
| Clinton, who met President Hu Jintao, the foreign minister, Yang Jiechi, and other top officials – but not leader-in-waiting Xi Jinping – wants China to stop backing the regime of Syria's President Bashar Assad, and has been pushing for it to be more flexible in lowering tensions over the potentially oil-rich South China Seas. | Clinton, who met President Hu Jintao, the foreign minister, Yang Jiechi, and other top officials – but not leader-in-waiting Xi Jinping – wants China to stop backing the regime of Syria's President Bashar Assad, and has been pushing for it to be more flexible in lowering tensions over the potentially oil-rich South China Seas. |
| But comments from Clinton and Yang on Wednesday showed the countries remain deeply divided on those issues, although both maintained they are committed to working together despite their differences. | But comments from Clinton and Yang on Wednesday showed the countries remain deeply divided on those issues, although both maintained they are committed to working together despite their differences. |
| The US and other countries are upset that China and Russia have repeatedly used their veto powers in the UN security council to block actions that could have led to sanctions against Assad's regime. China says Syria's civil war needs to be resolved through negotiations and not outside pressure. | The US and other countries are upset that China and Russia have repeatedly used their veto powers in the UN security council to block actions that could have led to sanctions against Assad's regime. China says Syria's civil war needs to be resolved through negotiations and not outside pressure. |
| "I think history will judge that China's position on the Syria question is a promotion of the appropriate handling of the situation," Yang told a news conference with Clinton. "For what we have in mind is the interests of the people of Syria and the region and the interests of peace, stability and development in the region and throughout the world." | "I think history will judge that China's position on the Syria question is a promotion of the appropriate handling of the situation," Yang told a news conference with Clinton. "For what we have in mind is the interests of the people of Syria and the region and the interests of peace, stability and development in the region and throughout the world." |
| The comment was a direct rebuke to Clinton, who has said previously that vetoes by China and Russia of UN security council sanctions on the Assad regime have put them "on the wrong side of history". | The comment was a direct rebuke to Clinton, who has said previously that vetoes by China and Russia of UN security council sanctions on the Assad regime have put them "on the wrong side of history". |
| She responded bluntly to Yang by saying the violence was boiling over into other countries such as Jordan and Turkey and that the security council had to act. | She responded bluntly to Yang by saying the violence was boiling over into other countries such as Jordan and Turkey and that the security council had to act. |
| "It is no secret that we have been disappointed by Russia and China's actions blocking tougher UN security council resolutions and we hope to continue to unite behind a real path forward to end the violence in Syria," she said. | "It is no secret that we have been disappointed by Russia and China's actions blocking tougher UN security council resolutions and we hope to continue to unite behind a real path forward to end the violence in Syria," she said. |
| Clinton had been scheduled to meet China's vice-president, Xi Jinping, who is expected to take over as leader later this year, but that was cancelled by the Chinese for "unexpected scheduling reasons", State department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland said. | Clinton had been scheduled to meet China's vice-president, Xi Jinping, who is expected to take over as leader later this year, but that was cancelled by the Chinese for "unexpected scheduling reasons", State department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland said. |
| A meeting between Xi and the visiting prime minister of Singapore, Lee Hsien Loong, also was cancelled without explanation. | A meeting between Xi and the visiting prime minister of Singapore, Lee Hsien Loong, also was cancelled without explanation. |
| Yang would say only there should not be "unnecessary speculation" about changes to Clinton's schedule. | Yang would say only there should not be "unnecessary speculation" about changes to Clinton's schedule. |
| Before meeting Hu, the secretary of state said the US-China relationship was strong even though there were disagreements over issues including Syria, the South China Sea and human rights. "We are able to explore areas of agreement and disagreement in a very open manner, which I think demonstrates the maturity of the relationship and the chance to take it further in the future," Clinton said. | Before meeting Hu, the secretary of state said the US-China relationship was strong even though there were disagreements over issues including Syria, the South China Sea and human rights. "We are able to explore areas of agreement and disagreement in a very open manner, which I think demonstrates the maturity of the relationship and the chance to take it further in the future," Clinton said. |
| She had arrived in China from Indonesia, where she urged south-east Asian nations to present a unified front in dealing with Beijing in attempts to ease rising tensions in the South China Sea. China and a host of south-east Asian countries, including the Philippines, Vietnam and Brunei, have overlapping claims to several small but potentially energy-rich areas of sea, reefs and islands. | She had arrived in China from Indonesia, where she urged south-east Asian nations to present a unified front in dealing with Beijing in attempts to ease rising tensions in the South China Sea. China and a host of south-east Asian countries, including the Philippines, Vietnam and Brunei, have overlapping claims to several small but potentially energy-rich areas of sea, reefs and islands. |
| The US wants China and the other claimants to adopt a binding code of conduct for the region, along with a process to resolve maritime disputes without coercion, intimidation or the use of force. | The US wants China and the other claimants to adopt a binding code of conduct for the region, along with a process to resolve maritime disputes without coercion, intimidation or the use of force. |
| Clinton wants the Chinese to drop their insistence on settling conflicting claims with individual nations and instead embrace a multilateral mechanism that will give the smaller members of the Association of South East Asian Nations (Asean) greater clout in negotiations. | Clinton wants the Chinese to drop their insistence on settling conflicting claims with individual nations and instead embrace a multilateral mechanism that will give the smaller members of the Association of South East Asian Nations (Asean) greater clout in negotiations. |
| She said she wanted all sides to make meaningful progress before a November summit of east Asian leaders that President Barack Obama plans to attend in Cambodia. | She said she wanted all sides to make meaningful progress before a November summit of east Asian leaders that President Barack Obama plans to attend in Cambodia. |
| "We believe … that it is timely now to proceed with that work and help to lower the tensions and create the code of conduct in the next period, hopefully in preparation for the east Asia ummit," she said. | "We believe … that it is timely now to proceed with that work and help to lower the tensions and create the code of conduct in the next period, hopefully in preparation for the east Asia ummit," she said. |
| Yang, however, repeated China's statements that it is ready to discuss the sea disputes only through bilateral talks in which many believe that China would have an unfair upper hand. And, he was lukewarm over the idea of reaching an agreement before November, saying China and some of its friends in Asean wanted to work only toward the "eventual adoption of a code of conduct". | Yang, however, repeated China's statements that it is ready to discuss the sea disputes only through bilateral talks in which many believe that China would have an unfair upper hand. And, he was lukewarm over the idea of reaching an agreement before November, saying China and some of its friends in Asean wanted to work only toward the "eventual adoption of a code of conduct". |
| "China has sovereignty over the islands in the South China Sea and the adjacent waters. There is plenty of historical and jurisprudence evidence of that," he said. | "China has sovereignty over the islands in the South China Sea and the adjacent waters. There is plenty of historical and jurisprudence evidence of that," he said. |
| Yang also rejected that there was any threat to international maritime commerce from the rising tensions over the disputes. Washington has cited the disputes as a reason why peaceful settlements of the claims are a US national security interest. | Yang also rejected that there was any threat to international maritime commerce from the rising tensions over the disputes. Washington has cited the disputes as a reason why peaceful settlements of the claims are a US national security interest. |
| "The freedom and safety of navigation in the South China Sea is assured," he said. "There is no issue currently in this area nor will there ever be issues in that area in the future." | "The freedom and safety of navigation in the South China Sea is assured," he said. "There is no issue currently in this area nor will there ever be issues in that area in the future." |
| Clinton and her comments on the South China Sea have been strongly criticised in the official Chinese media over the last two days. Hu gave what may have been another sign of Beijing's unhappiness with Clinton at the beginning of their talks by praising her only for implementing a student exchange initiative and for "actively" pushing for the construction of the US pavilion at the Shanghai World Expo two years ago. | Clinton and her comments on the South China Sea have been strongly criticised in the official Chinese media over the last two days. Hu gave what may have been another sign of Beijing's unhappiness with Clinton at the beginning of their talks by praising her only for implementing a student exchange initiative and for "actively" pushing for the construction of the US pavilion at the Shanghai World Expo two years ago. |
| Clinton said she also urged China to use "its unique influence" to help bring change to its impoverished and isolated neighbour North Korea, where Kim Jong-un became leader when his father died late last year. | Clinton said she also urged China to use "its unique influence" to help bring change to its impoverished and isolated neighbour North Korea, where Kim Jong-un became leader when his father died late last year. |
| "There is an opportunity for the new leadership of North Korea to improve the lives of the people of North Korea," Clinton said. | "There is an opportunity for the new leadership of North Korea to improve the lives of the people of North Korea," Clinton said. |
| Clinton is in China at the mid-point of an 11-day, six-nation tour of the Asia Pacific region that started in the Cook Islands. After she leaves China, she will visit East Timor and Brunei before heading to Russia's far east to represent the US at the annual meeting of leaders from the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum in Vladivostok. | Clinton is in China at the mid-point of an 11-day, six-nation tour of the Asia Pacific region that started in the Cook Islands. After she leaves China, she will visit East Timor and Brunei before heading to Russia's far east to represent the US at the annual meeting of leaders from the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum in Vladivostok. |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. | |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. Enter your email address to subscribe. |