This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/apr/23/brodie-clark-immigration-theresa-may
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 4 | Version 5 |
|---|---|
| Brodie Clark blames home secretary for immigration queues | Brodie Clark blames home secretary for immigration queues |
| (4 months later) | |
| Frontline immigration staff are becoming little more than "box-tickers and rules followers" as a result of the government's passport-checking policy, according to the former head of the UK border force. | Frontline immigration staff are becoming little more than "box-tickers and rules followers" as a result of the government's passport-checking policy, according to the former head of the UK border force. |
| Brodie Clark said full passport checks introduced by the home secretary last autumn were causing lengthy delays at London's major airports and undermining security. | Brodie Clark said full passport checks introduced by the home secretary last autumn were causing lengthy delays at London's major airports and undermining security. |
| Writing in the Times, (subscription required) he described Theresa May's decision to suspend risk-based border controls as a "kneejerk reaction" and said they would be reinstated. | Writing in the Times, (subscription required) he described Theresa May's decision to suspend risk-based border controls as a "kneejerk reaction" and said they would be reinstated. |
| Clark argued there had been "a crisis in confidence among border staff" since he resigned from his position last November after allowing certain passenger checks to be relaxed without seeking ministerial approval. | Clark argued there had been "a crisis in confidence among border staff" since he resigned from his position last November after allowing certain passenger checks to be relaxed without seeking ministerial approval. |
| He wrote: "The early journey we took into a more risk-based approach to checking passengers arriving in Britain has been shelved. | He wrote: "The early journey we took into a more risk-based approach to checking passengers arriving in Britain has been shelved. |
| "Instead, we are back to the laborious and less effective policy of checking every passenger to a similar level, regardless of whether a particular individual is ever likely to pose a threat. | "Instead, we are back to the laborious and less effective policy of checking every passenger to a similar level, regardless of whether a particular individual is ever likely to pose a threat. |
| "It means that sticking to the process becomes the measure of success, not results from checking." | "It means that sticking to the process becomes the measure of success, not results from checking." |
| He said the approach meant staff were not using their experience and were reduced to being "little more than box-tickers and rules followers". | He said the approach meant staff were not using their experience and were reduced to being "little more than box-tickers and rules followers". |
| He added: "The pressures of long queues reduces the effectiveness of border staff – put simply, it leads to mistakes." | He added: "The pressures of long queues reduces the effectiveness of border staff – put simply, it leads to mistakes." |
| Clark, who was speaking for the first time since receiving compensation after settling a constructive dismissal case against the Home Office, said the full check policy meant staff were being moved away from "vital security work" and instead doing "low-value, low-return passenger checking". | Clark, who was speaking for the first time since receiving compensation after settling a constructive dismissal case against the Home Office, said the full check policy meant staff were being moved away from "vital security work" and instead doing "low-value, low-return passenger checking". |
| He argued that the government should have the "sense and the confidence to focus on who might be a risk". | He argued that the government should have the "sense and the confidence to focus on who might be a risk". |
| Clark said technological advances in border controls, such as the introduction of electronic checking, had improved efficiency and security, meaning officials no longer needed to rely on the "old-fashioned civil service approach of putting process before results". | Clark said technological advances in border controls, such as the introduction of electronic checking, had improved efficiency and security, meaning officials no longer needed to rely on the "old-fashioned civil service approach of putting process before results". |
| He said: "It short changes the British public and is a shameful failure to harness the potential of staff, experience and technology." | He said: "It short changes the British public and is a shameful failure to harness the potential of staff, experience and technology." |
| Clark called for a three-pronged approach to patrolling Britain's borders that focused on technology, the effective use of frontline staff and an approach based on risk. | Clark called for a three-pronged approach to patrolling Britain's borders that focused on technology, the effective use of frontline staff and an approach based on risk. |
| "Only by doing all three do we stand any chance of continuing the progress against criminality and terrorism, particularly when resources are being reduced and the number of goods arriving in the UK is dramatically increasing," he said. | "Only by doing all three do we stand any chance of continuing the progress against criminality and terrorism, particularly when resources are being reduced and the number of goods arriving in the UK is dramatically increasing," he said. |
| Clark also warned that the government's plan to introduce a separate border force could threaten security in the runup to the Olympics. | Clark also warned that the government's plan to introduce a separate border force could threaten security in the runup to the Olympics. |
| "The home secretary's plans for a separate border force outside the UK Border Agency will inevitably take watchful eyes off the security ball as new structures are put in place," he wrote. | "The home secretary's plans for a separate border force outside the UK Border Agency will inevitably take watchful eyes off the security ball as new structures are put in place," he wrote. |
| Clark added in his article: "The political kneejerk reaction that suspended risk-based border controls has undoubtedly made it difficult to reinstate this sensible policy. But nothing is surer – it will be reintroduced." | Clark added in his article: "The political kneejerk reaction that suspended risk-based border controls has undoubtedly made it difficult to reinstate this sensible policy. But nothing is surer – it will be reintroduced." |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. | Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. |