This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/london/5410872.stm
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| Ken's suspension order thrown out | Ken's suspension order thrown out |
| (about 12 hours later) | |
| Ken Livingstone's four-week suspension from the mayor's office has been quashed by a High Court judge. | Ken Livingstone's four-week suspension from the mayor's office has been quashed by a High Court judge. |
| He was suspended for his remarks to a Jewish journalist likening him to a Nazi concentration camp guard. | He was suspended for his remarks to a Jewish journalist likening him to a Nazi concentration camp guard. |
| The exchange with Oliver Finegold happened as the mayor left an event in February last year. | The exchange with Oliver Finegold happened as the mayor left an event in February last year. |
| The mayor was challenging a decision by the Adjudication Panel for England that his comments breached the Greater London Authority's code of conduct. | The mayor was challenging a decision by the Adjudication Panel for England that his comments breached the Greater London Authority's code of conduct. |
| The Board of Deputies of British Jews has demanded an apology from the mayor, regardless of the outcome of the case. | The Board of Deputies of British Jews has demanded an apology from the mayor, regardless of the outcome of the case. |
| I think we probably know what the chances of the mayor apologising now are, so we're not holding our breath Jon Benjamin, chief executive, Board of Deputies of British Jews | I think we probably know what the chances of the mayor apologising now are, so we're not holding our breath Jon Benjamin, chief executive, Board of Deputies of British Jews |
| "What he doesn't seem to accept is a number of constituents for whom he is actually mayor - that is Holocaust survivors and the Jewish community - were offended by what he said and that apology he seems to have problems in giving," Jon Benjamin, the chief executive of the organisation, said. | "What he doesn't seem to accept is a number of constituents for whom he is actually mayor - that is Holocaust survivors and the Jewish community - were offended by what he said and that apology he seems to have problems in giving," Jon Benjamin, the chief executive of the organisation, said. |
| At the High Court, Mr Justice Collins said the suspension would be overturned, regardless of whether or not the mayor won his appeal against the Adjudication Panel for England's finding. | At the High Court, Mr Justice Collins said the suspension would be overturned, regardless of whether or not the mayor won his appeal against the Adjudication Panel for England's finding. |
| The judge said: "I have made it clear the suspension will be quashed whatever I decide on whether the Panel's finding was correct." | The judge said: "I have made it clear the suspension will be quashed whatever I decide on whether the Panel's finding was correct." |
| He reserved his final judgment on Mr Livingstone's appeal to a later date, saying: "It is not an easy case. There are certain ramifications, whatever I decide, which will affect other matters." | He reserved his final judgment on Mr Livingstone's appeal to a later date, saying: "It is not an easy case. There are certain ramifications, whatever I decide, which will affect other matters." |
| Flawed decision | Flawed decision |
| The public were "heartily sick of the whole saga", Mr Benjamin said. | The public were "heartily sick of the whole saga", Mr Benjamin said. |
| "I think we probably know what the chances of the mayor apologising now are, so we're not holding our breath," he said. | "I think we probably know what the chances of the mayor apologising now are, so we're not holding our breath," he said. |
| During the two-day hearing, Mr Livingstone's lawyers argued the panel's decision, made in February, was legally flawed on a number of grounds. | During the two-day hearing, Mr Livingstone's lawyers argued the panel's decision, made in February, was legally flawed on a number of grounds. |
| This included the fact the Mayor had not been acting in his official capacity at the time of the incident. | This included the fact the Mayor had not been acting in his official capacity at the time of the incident. |
| The panel's ruling was defended by the Ethical Standards Officer, who referred the case to the disciplinary body. | The panel's ruling was defended by the Ethical Standards Officer, who referred the case to the disciplinary body. |
| The ESO contended the Mayor's arguments were over-complicated and "trivialised" the code of conduct and there was no basis for the judge substituting his own judgment for that of the panel. | The ESO contended the Mayor's arguments were over-complicated and "trivialised" the code of conduct and there was no basis for the judge substituting his own judgment for that of the panel. |
| John Biggs, Labour's London Assembly member for City and London, welcomed the judge's decision to quash the order saying: "It should be for Londoners to decide if the Mayor should be removed from office and not an unelected quango. I am pleased that the judge agrees with us." | John Biggs, Labour's London Assembly member for City and London, welcomed the judge's decision to quash the order saying: "It should be for Londoners to decide if the Mayor should be removed from office and not an unelected quango. I am pleased that the judge agrees with us." |
| If the appeal fails, Mr Livingstone will be responsible for paying his own legal costs, estimated at £80,000, although he will continue to be paid. | If the appeal fails, Mr Livingstone will be responsible for paying his own legal costs, estimated at £80,000, although he will continue to be paid. |