This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/5315636.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Fears over nuclear terror threat | Fears over nuclear terror threat |
(about 3 hours later) | |
Concerns that terrorists could attack Britain's nuclear power network have failed to be addressed by plans for new nuclear plants, says Charles Clarke. | Concerns that terrorists could attack Britain's nuclear power network have failed to be addressed by plans for new nuclear plants, says Charles Clarke. |
The former home secretary says the government's energy review fails to answer key concerns about a new generation of nuclear power stations. | The former home secretary says the government's energy review fails to answer key concerns about a new generation of nuclear power stations. |
In a lecture about Labour's future, Mr Clarke also criticises Gordon Brown for backing calls for new nuclear weapons. | In a lecture about Labour's future, Mr Clarke also criticises Gordon Brown for backing calls for new nuclear weapons. |
He says there is no coherent case for deciding to replace Trident arms now. | He says there is no coherent case for deciding to replace Trident arms now. |
Leadership challenge | Leadership challenge |
His speech in London follows a magazine article in which he said Labour had alienated many of its supporters. | His speech in London follows a magazine article in which he said Labour had alienated many of its supporters. |
He says changing the leadership will not solve the Labour Party's problems and instead there needs to be a debate about future policies. | He says changing the leadership will not solve the Labour Party's problems and instead there needs to be a debate about future policies. |
The power of nuclear energy makes it a natural magnet for terrorist activity of a variety of types Charles Clarke | The power of nuclear energy makes it a natural magnet for terrorist activity of a variety of types Charles Clarke |
He denies claims by Ed Balls, the economic secretary to the Treasury - and one of Gordon Brown's closest allies - that such calls mean "navel gazing". | He denies claims by Ed Balls, the economic secretary to the Treasury - and one of Gordon Brown's closest allies - that such calls mean "navel gazing". |
And he stresses his contribution to the debate is not part of any leadership bid. | And he stresses his contribution to the debate is not part of any leadership bid. |
The government energy review earlier this year gave the green light to a new generation of nuclear power plants, but Mr Clarke says he remains sceptical. | The government energy review earlier this year gave the green light to a new generation of nuclear power plants, but Mr Clarke says he remains sceptical. |
The problem of how to dispose of nuclear waste safely and effectively has still not been properly sorted out, he says. | The problem of how to dispose of nuclear waste safely and effectively has still not been properly sorted out, he says. |
Mr Clarke argues that the costs of nuclear are very great and it is unlikely any private firm would meet them, leaving the state having to stump up the funds. | Mr Clarke argues that the costs of nuclear are very great and it is unlikely any private firm would meet them, leaving the state having to stump up the funds. |
'Sceptical' | 'Sceptical' |
The safety of plants must be guaranteed, he says. | The safety of plants must be guaranteed, he says. |
"The power of nuclear energy makes it a natural magnet for terrorist activity of a variety of types," he says. | "The power of nuclear energy makes it a natural magnet for terrorist activity of a variety of types," he says. |
"We need to be absolutely certain that we can protect ourselves completely against that threat, the cost of which by the way also has to be met by the state. | "We need to be absolutely certain that we can protect ourselves completely against that threat, the cost of which by the way also has to be met by the state. |
Not everyone believes a new leader will solve Labour's problems BBC political editor Nick Robinson Read Nick's thoughts in full | |
"So I am genuinely sceptical and I do not think that the Energy Review answers these concerns adequately. | "So I am genuinely sceptical and I do not think that the Energy Review answers these concerns adequately. |
"On the basis of the information I have so far seen, I am not convinced of the case for proceeding to a new generation of nuclear power stations in this country. | "On the basis of the information I have so far seen, I am not convinced of the case for proceeding to a new generation of nuclear power stations in this country. |
"I believe that investment in conservation and renewable energy offers a more reliable route to the energy sustainability which this country needs." | "I believe that investment in conservation and renewable energy offers a more reliable route to the energy sustainability which this country needs." |
Brown criticism | Brown criticism |
In his speech, Mr Clarke is equally scathing about the way debate on a possible replacement for the Trident nuclear weapons system has been handled. | In his speech, Mr Clarke is equally scathing about the way debate on a possible replacement for the Trident nuclear weapons system has been handled. |
Chancellor Mr Brown used a lecture at The Guildhall in London to signal his support for keeping Britain's "independent nuclear deterrent". | Chancellor Mr Brown used a lecture at The Guildhall in London to signal his support for keeping Britain's "independent nuclear deterrent". |
But Mr Clarke says there needs to be a full consideration of all the options. | But Mr Clarke says there needs to be a full consideration of all the options. |
"Our resource and strategic allocation should depend on the conclusions of that consideration and should not be pre-empted," he says. | "Our resource and strategic allocation should depend on the conclusions of that consideration and should not be pre-empted," he says. |
"In short a convincing argument for taking the step which the chancellor announced at the Guildhall has yet to be presented." | "In short a convincing argument for taking the step which the chancellor announced at the Guildhall has yet to be presented." |
Aviation tax? | Aviation tax? |
The former home secretary will also argue that the case for green taxes is now "unanswerable". | The former home secretary will also argue that the case for green taxes is now "unanswerable". |
Good progress has been made on taxing fuel and it needs to be taken further, he says. | Good progress has been made on taxing fuel and it needs to be taken further, he says. |
And the case for extra taxes on aviation is now "difficult to refute", he argues. | And the case for extra taxes on aviation is now "difficult to refute", he argues. |
Previous version
1
Next version