This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/6598885.stm
The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| UK terror suspects win key ruling | |
| (20 minutes later) | |
| Two Libyans terror suspects have won an appeal against deportation from the UK. | Two Libyans terror suspects have won an appeal against deportation from the UK. |
| The men, known only as DD and AS, argued they should not be deported to their home country because they could be jailed and tortured. | The men, known only as DD and AS, argued they should not be deported to their home country because they could be jailed and tortured. |
| The government rejected their case, saying it had signed a special memorandum of understanding with Libya to protect deportees from mistreatment. | The government rejected their case, saying it had signed a special memorandum of understanding with Libya to protect deportees from mistreatment. |
| But in the first test of the case, the Special Immigration Appeals Commission said the men could not be sent back. | But in the first test of the case, the Special Immigration Appeals Commission said the men could not be sent back. |
| Under international human rights law, the UK does not deport people to regimes where they may face persecution or torture. | Under international human rights law, the UK does not deport people to regimes where they may face persecution or torture. |
| But in October 2005, the government signed an historic deal with Libya, under which Colonel Gaddafi's government pledged not to mistreat anyone deported to Tripoli from the UK. | But in October 2005, the government signed an historic deal with Libya, under which Colonel Gaddafi's government pledged not to mistreat anyone deported to Tripoli from the UK. |
| Similar memorandums of understanding (MOU) have been signed with Jordan and Lebanon. A different diplomatic agreement is in place with Algeria covering the treatment of returnees. | Similar memorandums of understanding (MOU) have been signed with Jordan and Lebanon. A different diplomatic agreement is in place with Algeria covering the treatment of returnees. |
| But in his ruling, Mr Justice Ouseley, chairman of the Special Immigration Appeals Commission, the body that deals with deportation of terror suspects, said that in the case of the Libyan men there remained a real risk of mistreatment. | But in his ruling, Mr Justice Ouseley, chairman of the Special Immigration Appeals Commission, the body that deals with deportation of terror suspects, said that in the case of the Libyan men there remained a real risk of mistreatment. |
| The European Convention on Human Rights could be breached if the two men were removed to Libya, he said, although he indicated it was not a "probable risk". | The European Convention on Human Rights could be breached if the two men were removed to Libya, he said, although he indicated it was not a "probable risk". |
| "There is also real risk that the trial of the appellants would amount to a complete denial of a fair trial," he added. | "There is also real risk that the trial of the appellants would amount to a complete denial of a fair trial," he added. |
| Controversial deals | |
| The MOUs signed with Libya, Jordan and Lebanon are a key plank of the government's strategy to deport terrorism suspects it says it cannot put on trial in the UK. | |
| The government should abandon this policy of trying to find a way around the international ban on torture Kate Allen, Amnesty International UK signs Libya deportation deal | |
| After signing the deal with Tripoli, the government said it believed the assurances given would enable the British courts to legally deport foreign terror suspects without breaching the UK's international obligations. | |
| The prime minister's official spokesman said the MOU with Libya was "more specific in terms of an individual's rights" than international human rights law. | |
| The government had also been seeking to put in place independent monitoring of the welfare of any returnees to ensure Libya lived up to the deal. | |
| But in a statement, solicitors for DD and AS said: "It was common ground between the government and [our clients] that political opponents of the Gaddafi regime are reasonably likely to be tortured or otherwise ill-treated if returned to Libya." | |
| Deportation queue | |
| As of February this year, there were 23 foreign nationals awaiting deportation on national security grounds. | |
| Three unnamed Algerians and one Jordanian have lost appeals against deportation. The ruling in the case of Jordanian radical cleric Abu Qatada was a key victory for the Home Office. | |
| A further three Algerians had withdrawn their appeals to the Special Immigration Appeals Commission, but were still waiting deportation. | |
| Sixteen other terrorism suspects were awaiting hearings or decisions - two of them being the Libyan men who won their case on Friday. |