This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk/6446649.stm
The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
Soldiers cleared over Iraq abuse | Soldiers cleared over Iraq abuse |
(about 1 hour later) | |
A court martial has cleared two UK soldiers of failing to ensure their men did not abuse Iraqi civilians in Basra. | A court martial has cleared two UK soldiers of failing to ensure their men did not abuse Iraqi civilians in Basra. |
Maj Michael Peebles and Warrant Officer Mark Davies had denied charges of negligently performing their duties. | Maj Michael Peebles and Warrant Officer Mark Davies had denied charges of negligently performing their duties. |
In all, six soldiers were acquitted at the hearing in Bulford, Wiltshire. A seventh soldier had previously admitted one charge of inhumane treatment. | |
The allegations arose after the death of an Iraqi prisoner, Baha Mousa, in British custody during September 2003. | The allegations arose after the death of an Iraqi prisoner, Baha Mousa, in British custody during September 2003. |
Cpl Donald Payne, who admitted inhumane treatment, is the only soldier to have been convicted at the end of the six-month hearing. | |
'Come unstuck' | 'Come unstuck' |
Senior soldiers and defence lawyers hit out at the court martial system following the Tuesday's acquittals. | |
We are relieved that today, after three and a half years, there is a sense of closure Col David Black Timeline: Iraq abuse trial | |
Gilbert Blades, solicitor for Maj Peebles, said the case "exposed the weaknesses and gaps" in the system. | |
"If charges are brought, the case should be capable of standing up to scrutiny by the court," he said. | "If charges are brought, the case should be capable of standing up to scrutiny by the court," he said. |
But Mr Blades claimed that none of the soldiers who faced court martial should have been charged - with the exception of Cpl Payne. | But Mr Blades claimed that none of the soldiers who faced court martial should have been charged - with the exception of Cpl Payne. |
"[Prosecutors] have come unstuck every time they have dealt with this type of case," he added. | |
The seven soldiers were all from the Queen's Lancashire Regiment. | |
'Extraordinary ordeal' | |
Col David Black, of the QLR's Regimental Council, said that British servicemen needed to operate without being "inhibited by the fear of such actions by over zealous and remote officialdom". | |
Col Jorge Mendonca was cleared of negligently performing a duty | |
Col Black labelled the trial an "extraordinary ordeal" for the soldiers, their families and the regiment as a whole. | |
"We are relieved that today, after three and a half years, there is a sense of closure." | |
But Phil Shiner, who represented the Iraqis at the court martial, labelled the outcome a "travesty". | |
"It gives the victims nothing. It raises more questions than it answers." | |
The court martial dealt with claims that the soldiers abused a group of Iraqis arrested at a Basra hotel where the Army had found weapons and suspected bomb-making equipment. | |
Among those charged but later acquitted was Col Jorge Mendonca - the most senior UK soldier in recent history to face a court martial. | |
Baha Mousa, 26, was among the group of detainees. He later died. | |
It was found he had 93 separate injuries to his body. |