This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/6444725.stm
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Teen abortion 'right to know' bid | Teen abortion 'right to know' bid |
(about 5 hours later) | |
Parents should be told if under-age girls are given advice on contraception or abortion, to help them with "very serious" decisions, says a Tory MP. | |
Sex education is currently based on information about contraception, but what children need is more advice and guidance, argues Angela Watkinson. | |
About 4,000 under-16s a year have abortions in England and Wales. | |
Similar laws in the US are said to have resulted in a 15 to 20% drop in abortion rates for minors. | Similar laws in the US are said to have resulted in a 15 to 20% drop in abortion rates for minors. |
Mrs Watkinson said that the whole premise of sex education was wrong. | |
'Quite illogical' | |
"Very young children are bombarded with information about sex, information about contraception and then an assumption is made that they are going to make wise decisions with this information," she said. | |
She said this was "quite illogical", and said the decision to have an abortion was "far too serious... for a very young girl to reach on her own, or with the advice of a stranger." | |
Noting a report that suggested 40% of UK children aged under 16 were sexually active, she said many girls were "lulled into a false sense of security" by the emphasis on contraception - when in fact condoms often failed. | |
I feel very strongly parents ought to be involved in these very serious life-changing decisions Angela Watkinson | |
Mrs Watkinson will present her Contraception and Abortion (Parental Information) Bill to the Commons on Wednesday. | |
It is a Ten Minute Rule Bill which means it is unlikely to become law, but Mrs Watkinson hopes it will publicise the issue more widely. | |
She said she wanted parents to be informed of any advice on contraception and abortions - although they would not be allowed to impose their decision on the child. | |
Gillick ruling | |
"I feel very strongly parents ought to be involved in these very serious life-changing decisions," she said. | |
At a press conference on Tuesday, she was backed by two experts who argued that scrapping confidential advice for the under-16s would not lead more to have unprotected sex. | |
Professor David Paton, of Nottingham University Business School, said the only statistics available showed that had not happened. | |
We don't stand a snowball's chance of the teenage pregnancy targets being met Dr Trevor Stammers | |
He pointed to the UK's Gillick ruling of 1984, which banned the provision of contraceptives to under-16s without the parent's involvement - but was overturned a year later. | |
Visits to family planning clinics had dropped during that year, but the number of pregnancies among under 16s had remained stable, he said - something partly explained by fewer minors choosing to have sex. | |
Putting aside the moral arguments about the parents' right to know, the evidence was "very clear" that the laws led to fewer abortions, pregnancies and possibly sexually transmitted diseases among teens, he said. | |
Sexual health | |
The government wants to halve the conception rate in under-18s in England by 2010. | The government wants to halve the conception rate in under-18s in England by 2010. |
But Dr Trevor Stammers, a GP and senior tutor at St George's, University of London, said he believed sexual health was "rapidly declining". | |
"We don't stand a snowball's chance of the teenage pregnancy targets being met," he said. | |
He said many doctors had been "conditioned" to act as providers of contraception, and some GPs were frightened of being sued if they did not provide the pill to minors. | |
He said it was a "lie" to tell youngsters that as long as they used a condom "you will be all right" and said up to 80% of unplanned pregnancies were due to failed contraception. | |
And he said that the proposed bill was "the only way forward if we really do mean business about improving the sexual health of young people". | |
Seven US states enforced parental involvement laws for abortion in 1984 - now more than 30 enforce them. |